Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

ESSENTIALLY COMMUNISM is a system of social organization in which property, and in particular productive assets, are held in common, that is, owned by the group or community instead of by individuals. In the broadest sense it comprises communistic anarchism, socialism, and communism in the strict sense. Anarchism calls for the abolishment of private property and any form of government. Socialism, on the other hand, implies the collective ownership and management primarily of the vital economic resources, or means of production. As such, socialism would be the first stage of communism, when the necessity for private property would cease and all the goods would be commonly owned. However, the modern use of the term socialism implies the abandonment of violence and revolutionary means to achieve an egalitarian society.

The rise of capitalism, reinforced by the Industrial Revolution, which began in the 18th century, created conditions that gave rise to modern communism. The working environment, wages, hours, and overall factory conditions for the new industrial laborers were appalling. The first comprehensive criticism came from French intellectuals. Gabriel de Mably (Doutes proposés aux philosophes économiques, 1768) and Morelly (Code de la nature, 1755), both apostate priests, relying on Plato's and Jean-Jacques Rousseau's ideas, advocated the equality and state ownership of property and industry. It was Morelly's ideas on state ownership that were embraced by the French Revolutionists. The revolution, however, fell short of fulfilling demands for economic egalitarianism.

Ideologists

François Babeuf was chief ideologist and leader of a group of disillusioned revolutionaries who strenuously advocated economic equality—the right of all men to work and to share in the products of the economy. The form of communism desired by the conspirators referred mainly to the distribution of goods rather than to the means of production. He founded a political journal, the Journal de la liberté de la presse (later the Tribun du peuple), and formed a secret society known as the Conspiracy of the Equals that plotted to overthrow the government.

His plans included compulsory labor and public distribution of the product according to individual needs. The plot was betrayed to the government and Babeuf was guillotined. His doctrines, however, known as Babouvism, were kept alive by secret revolutionary societies and by his coconspirators.

Count Henri de Saint-Simon did not demand common ownership of all property. In that regard his ideas, as exposed in his Nouveau Christianisme (1825), are socialist rather than communist. A founder of utopian socialism, he was the first to emphasize the division of modern society into employers and workingmen. His writings contain ideas of positivism (Auguste Comte was his pupil at the time), socialism, federation of the nations of Europe, and many other modern trends. Saint Simon envisioned the role of state as the manager of industry, assuring that particular tasks are assigned according to capacity and rewards are accrued in proportion to work. In his model, the state and central government, rather than local authorities and/or voluntary associations, played the pivotal role in arranging the economic life of the society.

Charles Fourier, Saint-Simon's contemporary and author of Traité de l’association domestique-agricole (1822), advocated a different approach. According to Fourier the organization of economic life was carried out by local communities called phalanxes. The members were to live a common life and dwell in one large building called the phalansterie. Individual preferences played an important role in determining working assignments, although frequent changes of occupation were envisioned. A minimum wage that ensured a comfortable livelihood was guaranteed to every worker. The surplus product would be divided among labor and capital, but the least desirable work would obtain the highest compensation.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading