Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Film: Deaf Characters

This entry focuses on films made by American and foreign filmmakers who have little or no special interest in or knowledge about deaf people or Deaf communities. Casting hearing actors to portray deaf characters is unfortunately common. Because neither the filmmakers, the expected audiences, nor the actors know anything about d/Deaf people, inauthenticities are widespread. These problems are only slightly improved by casting a Deaf actor: Deaf actors can portray authentic use of a sign language but are often limited by the script, the director, and the editing process. Therefore, while the signing community commends the casting of Deaf actors, the discussion here focuses on the deaf characters themselves and reasons for their inclusion in the story. In the following, the actors are labeled either “D” for Deaf or “h” for hearing. If there is no label, the actor’s status is unknown.

Deaf Main Characters

Films such as The Miracle Worker (1962, Patty Duke h), The Hammer (2010, Russel Harvard D), Music Within (2007, Ron Livingston h), and the Lon Chaney story, Man of a Thousand Faces (1957) are dramatized biographies of famous deaf people—or in the case of Chaney, the story of a famous actor with Deaf parents (Celia Lovsky h and Nolan Leary h)—who must struggle in a hostile, biased world. Other than these movies based on true stories, only a few films have a main character who is deaf. One such film is Johnny Belinda (1949). It begins with Belinda (Jane Wyman h) depicted as almost a non-person, until a kindly doctor arrives in town and teaches her sign language. The German film Stille Liebe (2001) is about a Deaf nun (Emmauelle Laborit D) who, just after taking her vows, meets a Deaf Latvian immigrant (Lars Otterstedt D) and falls in love. In the South Korean film, Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance (2002), the main character is a deaf man (Shin Ha-kyun) working in the black market organ trade. The Indian film Iqbal (2005) features a deaf boy (Shreyas Talpade) in a rural village who dreams of becoming a cricket player and actually makes the national team. Bangkok Dangerous (1999) is an unusual film in that the main character is a deaf contract killer (Pawarith Monkolpisit h), and in an early flashback, the audience gets a glimpse of how he was taunted as a deaf child. Other films feature deaf criminals, for example, Requiem for a Dream (2000, Bryan Chattoo D) and No Way Out (1950, Harry Bellaver h), but only as minor characters.

Beyond Silence (1996), is perhaps the only major movie about a hearing child’s relationship with her Deaf parents (Howie Seago D and Emanuelle Laborit D). This German film is unusual in its depiction of a Deaf character’s emotional growth. Khamoshi: The Musical (1996) is a Bollywood remake of Beyond Silence.

Deaf Communities

Virtually no films show their deaf characters living in Deaf communities, or even in relationships with another deaf person. Children of a Lesser God (1986) broke ground in its scenes set in a deaf school and at a Deaf party, but it actually focused on the experiences of a speech teacher who falls in love with a Deaf janitor, Sarah (Marlee Matlin d). Matlin won an Academy Award for her portrayal of Sarah but, ironically, the movie proved frustrating to Deaf viewers, who found that the ASL dialogue had been pushed out of the frame by camera angles and editing.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading