Town Hall Meetings

Town hall meetings are considered among the most common methods of public involvement in the United States. Thousands of these meetings are held annually, and U.S. population-based polls generally suggest that between 40% to 50% of people surveyed about public engagement report attending some type of town hall meeting in the last 12 months. Also known as public meetings and public hearings, town hall meetings are frequent methods of science and technical communication for environmental or risk management purposes. For example, zoning boards may hold meetings to discuss permitting for new land uses or variances to existing land uses. County or state health or environmental agencies may hold meetings to present information about local public health issues, such as air quality reports or toxic waste sites. The federal government may hold meetings as part of its advisory committee process, whereby it receives counsel from scientific advisers or as a process to solicit input from stakeholders on other scientific, technical, or health-related issues. Although town meetings may seem to represent “democracy in action,” they are not without their drawbacks.

Today's town hall meetings have their origins in traditional New England town meetings, some of which are still held annually to decide issues related to town management. Firmly rooted in democratic traditions, town hall meetings symbolize certain freedoms that Americans hold sacred, including the rights of free speech and assembly, where citizens gather and express their views openly and freely about their government. Town hall meetings also epitomize the normative ideal of representation, meaning that citizens have the right to have their voice heard in a democracy that derives its authority from citizens. In addition to satisfying democratic principles, town hall meetings can have substantive impact on decisions, such as when citizens provide important information or comment on issues at hand. Further, town hall meetings serve as a venue for citizens to gather information about current events in their community, region, state, or nation. Finally, town hall meetings can help to ensure the perceived legitimacy and acceptability of decisions when citizens believe meeting organizers were genuine in their intent to create a fair and balanced decision-making process.

Although town hall meetings may be often associated with decision-making purposes, not all are held for decision making. Rather, they may take place for the purpose of discussing issues, developing recommendations, providing information, reviewing projects, and seeking input. Just as town hall meetings serve many purposes, they serve many audiences. These include lay audiences or citizens without technical training, businesses, special interest groups, journalists, public officials, and other scientists and technical experts. The audience varies because essentially anyone can hold a town hall meeting, including nongovernmental groups, such as religious organizations, neighborhood associations, and other public interest groups. Even so, most town hall meetings are associated with some type of public or municipal body, such as school boards, local planning committees, zoning commissions, and various county, state, and federal agencies. Even political candidates vying for the office of U.S. President have used the “town hall meeting” moniker to describe some of their communication with the public.

...