Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Applied Fields: Neuropsychology

Introduction

Neuropsychological assessment as a formal procedure is a relatively recent development. Its evolution has paralleled advances, in the past fifty years, in the areas of neuroscience in general, and cognitive neuroscience in particular. It has also been influenced by developments in applied clinical disciplines such as neurology, neuroradiology, rehabilitation medicine, special education, geriatrics, developmental psychology, etc. In this section, we review the historical trajectory of this aspect of clinical neuropsychology, and present the current state of the field.

Historical Antecedents

Neuropsychological assessment did not come of age until after the Second World War. In the second half of the 19th century, there had been a flurry of clinical studies that correlated brain structures and cognitive activity. The work of Broca, Déjerine, Jastrowitz, Korsakoff, Lichteim, Liepmann, Oppenheimer, Ribot, Wernicke, and many others in the latter part of the 19th century described the neurological substrates of disorders such as the aphasias, apraxias, amnesia, and frontal disinhibition (Walsh, 1978; Benton, 2000). However, these advances in localization of function lay dormant (except in the USSR) for over half a century. This approach regained its popularity in the 1950s and 1960s, in part as a result of the work of Brenda Milner and her colleagues in Montreal, who described the pivotal role of the hippocampus in memory (Scoville & Milner, 1957), and in part due to the work of Benton, Zangwill, Hecaen, Ajurriaguera, and Goodglass. Sperry's work and the seminal case study of a human deconnection syndrome (Geschwind & Kaplan, 1962) lent further impetus to the belief that higher cognitive functions could be componentialized and subjected to analysis via objective techniques. Interest in the pioneering 19th century studies and their potential contribution to the study of brain-behaviour relationships was revived by Norman Geschwind in Boston at approximately the same time (Geschwind, 1997).

Paradigms in Neuropsychological Assessment

Global Measures of Brain Damage

At the outset, the primary goal of the neuropsychological evaluation in the United States was to assist in differentiating behavioural disorders of ‘organic’ (i.e. structural) nature, from those of ‘functional’ (i.e. psychological) origin. This focus can be attributed to the influence of psychoanalytic thinking, which postulated that psychiatric disturbance could result from intrapsychic (moral and psychological) and disturbed inter-personal relationships (Hill, 1978: vii). Further, clinicians in the USA and Britain were formed in a positivist, psychometric culture, which has more readily trusted an actuarial, mechanistic approach to data gathering, and statistically driven decision-making algorithms (Meehl, 1954), while being less comfortable with the methodology of single-case studies. Thus Ward Halstead's purpose in designing tests was to determine whether a person had sustained brain damage or not, asking, ‘more practically, can convenient indices be found which, like blood pressure, accurately reflect the normal and pathological range of variance for the individual? Is there a pathology of biological intelligence which is of significance to psychiatry and to our understanding of normal behaviour?’ (Halstead, 1947: 7). He noted accurately that the tests developed by Binet and standardized by Terman (for the purpose of identifying ‘subnormal’ children who required remediation in school) were completely insensitive to the effects of brain damage. Citing the work of Hebb and Penfield (1940) he wrote, ‘Evidence is now on record to the effect that surgical removal of one or both prefrontal lobes – that is, a mass of brain substance constituting about one-fourth of the total cerebrum – may not significantly alter the I.Q.’ (Halstead, 1947: 7).

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading