Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

A grandfather clause is a statement in law or policy granting specified exceptions to new regulations, based on preexisting practices or guarantees.

The term in its original usage specifically addressed free male U.S. voting rights in the 19th century. In their initial form, grandfather clauses in states such as Louisiana exempted voters who may have otherwise failed to meet either literacy or property requirements necessary to vote. A male voter whose father or grandfather voted prior to January 1, 1867, or was a war veteran, was exempt from these stipulations. Such clauses were often referred to as “old soldier” or “grandfather” clauses.

Thus, the terminology of “being grandfathered in” derived from the practice of allowing landless or perhaps illiterate white males the right to vote while disenfranchising African Americans male voters. The practice would stifle not only black voter representation in the south; it would also disenfranchise several thousand poor, white voters. Along with numerous other strategies, undesirable voters of many ethnicities would be affected by such clauses. Suppression of their votes would have a lasting effect on the American political process and would not be adequately addressed until the Voting Rights Act of 1965.

Background

In the aftermath of the Civil War a critical debate arose among members of Congress regarding the full enfranchisement of newly emancipated blacks. Northern Republicans and southern Democrats were unilaterally divided. The passage of the Thirteenth Amendment (abolition of slavery, 1863), Fourteenth Amendment (guarantees citizenship of blacks, 1868) and Fifteenth Amendment (the right to vote, 1870) to the U.S. Constitution, sometimes referred to as the Reconstruction amendments, reflected Republican ideals and demonstrated the party's dominance by the end of the Civil War.

Remaking America along Republican lines would mean a greater inclusion of African Americans not only as free black citizens but also as voters willing to forge a partnership with the Republican Party. The Reconstruction amendments posed a tremendous threat to many southern Democrats’ view of African Americans as inferior. The attempt at enfranchisement sought by the Fifteenth Amendment jeopardized the political power of the Democratic Party within Congress.

In a show of force, the 1867 Reconstruction acts, with radical Republicans at the helm, established a military presence within former Confederate states by dividing the south into five military districts, with federal troops dispatched to each; requiring southern states to draft state constitutions that allowed black male suffrage; and prohibiting former Confederate states from taking their seats in Congress until their ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment. The humiliation of southern failure during the Civil War was further exacerbated by these congressional defeats.

The Rise of a New South

Following the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln in 1865, President Andrew Johnson sought to placate southern states by softening the requirements necessary for reentry to the Union. However, a mostly Republican Congress felt the south should receive harsher punishment for its secessionary actions. Johnson's efforts, while endearing him to southern Democrats, were largely ineffective and nearly cost him the presidency.

The election of 1876 once again shifted political power between the north and south. The hotly contested presidential race between Republican Rutherford B. Hayes and Democratic candidate Samuel Tilden ended with Tilden receiving the popular vote and Hayes a majority of electoral votes. Hayes was, however, allowed to take office contingent upon his agreement to push for pro-Democratic reforms. Often called the Compromise of 1877, such reforms included the removal of all federal troops from Confederate states. Louisiana, South Carolina, and Florida would be the beneficiaries of this decision.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading