Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

International courts are standing tribunals entrusted with judicial functions over international disputes (that is, disputes governed by international norms, typically involving states as disputing parties). Jurists characterized these courts by a few common attributes, in that they have (1) an independent body of judges; (2) authority to render binding decisions; (3) processes governed by law; (4) a constitutive instrument valid under international law; and (5) a framework independent of any particular dispute. While the term international tribunal is broader in scope, as it encompasses also ad hoc bodies such as arbitration panels, the relevant literature often uses the terms international courts and international tribunals interchangeably.

Functions

The first international courts, such as the Permanent International Court of Justice (1920) and its post–World War II successor, the International Court of Justice (1945), were created as sophisticated dispute resolution mechanisms designed to increase the effectiveness of international procedures for the pacific settlement of disputes. Since international dispute settlement normally requires the consent of all disputing parties, international lawmakers have long sought to provide a diverse menu of procedures (such as conciliation and arbitration) that could accommodate the interests and concerns of all states involved and increase the likelihood of a nonviolent settlement. The permanency of international courts improves their accessibility to the parties, especially in urgent situations. In addition, jurists hoped that the accumulated jurisprudence of international courts, over time, would build confidence in judicial institutions and procedures.

Still, international courts seem to serve other functions as well. Courts such as the European Court of Human Rights (1950) are primarily designed to improve the enforcement of key international norms. Furthermore, courts such as the World Trade Organization Appellate Body (1994) or the European Court of Justice (ECJ, 1957) play an important part in sustaining complex international regimes. International courts can be efficient decision makers that quickly resolve, or at least assist in compartmentalizing, disputes that might otherwise threaten the well-being of complex normative and institutional systems of international cooperation.

Categories

International courts can be divided into three principal categories based on their scope of subject matter and personal jurisdiction. The first category includes the International Court of Justice (also referred to as the World Court), a court of general jurisdiction that serves as the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. It may address all disputes that states choose to refer to it (since 1945, more than one hundred cases have been so referred) and can provide United Nations (UN) organs and affiliated bodies with advisory opinions (since 1945, some twenty-five opinions have been sought). It is composed of fifteen judges elected by the UN General Assembly and Security Council based on their professional expertise (the entire body of judges should, however, adequately represent the various forms of civilization and domestic legal systems of the world). Until now, the Court has proved to be rather effective in resolving some types of disputes (mainly border disputes) but much less so in cases involving high-profile international peace and security conflicts (such as the Iran-United States and Nicaragua-United States conflicts in the 1980s). Furthermore, the willingness of nationstates to broadly accept the Court's jurisdiction and, as a result, its scope of judicial business have been disappointing.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading