Entry
Reader's guide
Entries A-Z
Subject index
Orientalism
In his groundbreaking book Orientalism, Edward Said systematically studies Western scholarship on and representation of the Near East or the Arab world. Focusing on British, French, and U.S. thinkers and artists since the 19th century, Said argues that rather than pure, objective, and disinterested scholarship and cultural practices, Orientalism aims to discursively subjugate the East. It belongs to the imperial drive to, rephrasing Socrates, “know thy colony” and control it. Said incisively diagnoses Orientalist representations as projecting Western desires onto the Orient, rendering the Other as shadow of the Self. The Orient is thus turned into stereotypes of extremities, or the Western Self's aspirations for beauty and love, such as the Islamic harem or Madame Butterfly, and abject fears, such as barbarism and opium. As a result, the Orientalist formula dictates that the Orient is polarized, emptied of psychological depth and subjectivity. The extremes of Samuel Taylor Coleridge's “A sunny pleasure-dome with caves of ice!” in Kubla Khan is split between the demonic and the domestic, with the exotic unfolding in the most predictable manner. The West projects its own neuroses onto the opposing constructs of, among others, Khans and Shangri-las, of the Mongolian horde and the Tibetan religiosity. Inherent in both ends of Orientalist stereotypes are transgressions and taboos that the West must shun otherwise. At a time when science and reason are secularizing the West, the need for myth and what lies beyond reason is displaced onto the Orient. Orientalism, hence, allows the West to articulate its own repressions in the name of representing the East. Thus, the West creates an identity for the Orient based on Western rather than Eastern ideas and notions. This entry focuses on the theoretical framework underlying Said's work, the response to Orientalism, and its application in the realm of global capitalism.
Theoretical Framework
The theoretical framework of Orientalism derives primarily from Michel Foucault's discourse theory and Antonio Gramsci's concept of hegemony. Foucault inspires Said to cross the distinction between nonpolitical and political knowledge in that Western Orientalists are vested in the maintenance of power over their subject matter of the East. Accordingly, no such thing as true, apolitical knowledge exists. Gramsci, on the other hand, demonstrates that consensus or hegemony can be forged in a civil society without resorting to coercion or violence. Foucauldian discursive power is woven into Gramscian hegemony to buttress Saidian Orientalism.
Reaction
Iconoclastic and controversial, Said's Orientalism has been credited by some as having single-handedly inaugurated postcolonialism. Said provides a counter-hegemonic theoretical basis for Western liberals and non-Western academics in search of an alternative to canonical criticism. Many postcolonial scholars build on Said's foundational work: Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak links Said with Jacques Derrida's notion of deconstruction and the subaltern group that argues for the need for strategic essentializing; Homi Bhabha refers to Frantz Fanon's psychoanalysis with Saidian colonial stereotypes when interrogating the ambivalence of nation and narration. Other scholars have taken Said to task for creating yet another totalizing, master narrative. Instead of Orientalism, critics accuse Said of Occidentalizing, to the extent of anti-Western rhetoric from a Western-trained elite of Palestinian descent. Critics cite as an example Said's fervent devotion to the Palestinian cause in The Question of Palestine, which Said supporters see as engaged scholarship.
...
- Art
- Class
- Culture, Ethnicity, and Race
- Agency
- Biracial Identity
- Class
- Class Identity
- Code-Switching
- Complex Inequality
- Critical Race Theory
- Culture
- Culture, Ethnicity, and Race
- Diaspora
- Dimensions of Cultural Variability
- Diversity
- Ethnicity
- Group Identity
- Hegemony
- Race Performance
- Racial Contracts
- Racial Disloyalty
- Society and Social Identity
- Status
- White Racial Identity
- Whiteness Studies
- Xenophobia
- Developing Identities
- Age
- Being and Identity
- Consciousness
- Deindividuation
- Development of Identity
- Development of Self-Concept
- Evolutionary Psychology
- Extraordinary Bodies
- Generation X and Generation Y
- Habitus
- Hybridity
- Id, Ego, and Superego
- Individual
- Individual Autonomy
- Individuation
- Intersubjectivity
- Mind-Body Problem
- Nigrescence
- Person
- Personal Identity versus Self-Identity
- Philosophy of Organization and Identity
- Reflexive Self or Reflexivity
- Saturated Identity
- Self
- Self-Affirmation Theory
- Self-Assessment
- Self-Concept
- Self-Discrepancy Theory
- Self-Efficacy
- Self-Enhancement Theory
- Self-Esteem
- Self-Image
- Self-Monitoring
- Self-Perception Theory
- Self-Portraits
- Self-Presentation
- Self-Schema
- Self-Verification
- Socialization
- Theory of Mind
- Gender, Sex, and Sexuality
- Identities in Conflict
- Accommodation
- Acculturation
- Adaptation
- Bilingualism
- Biracial Identity
- Clan Identity
- Conflict
- Corporate Identity
- Cultural Contracts Theory
- Culture Shock
- Double Consciousness
- Identification
- Identity Change
- Identity Diffusion
- Identity Negotiation
- Identity Salience
- Identity Uncertainty
- Intercultural Personhood
- Mindfulness
- Mobilities
- Modernity and Postmodernity
- Passing
- Perceptual Filtering
- Philosophy of Mind
- Simulacra
- Language and Discourse
- Ascribed Identity
- Avowal
- Brachyology
- Colonialism
- Deconstruction
- Dialect
- Discourse
- English as a Second Language (ESL)
- Ethnicity
- Etic/Emic
- Figures of Speech
- Forms of Address
- Framing
- Hermeneutics
- Hyperreality and Simulation
- Idiomatic Expressions
- Intonation
- Invariant Be
- Labeling
- Language
- Language Development
- Language Loss
- Language Variety in Literature
- Narratives
- Phonological Elements of Identity
- Pidgin/Creole
- Profanity and Slang
- Public Sphere
- Rhetoric
- Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis
- Satire
- Semantics
- Semiotics
- Signification
- Structuration
- Style/Diction
- Symbolism
- Tag Question
- Trickster Figure
- Living Ethically
- Media and Popular Culture
- Articulation Theory
- Consciousness
- Consumption
- Critical Theory
- Cultural Capital
- Cultural Studies
- Embeddedness/Embedded Identity
- Framing
- Frankfurt School
- Globalization
- Material Culture
- Media Studies
- Mediation
- Propaganda
- Social Capital
- Society of the Spectacle
- Spectacle and the Self
- Stock Character
- Surveillance and the Panopticon
- Technology
- Values
- Visual Culture
- Visual Pleasure
- Nationality
- Citizenship
- Civic Identity
- Clan Identity
- Collective/Social Identity
- Collectivism/Individualism
- Culture
- Diaspora
- First Nations
- Historicity
- Identity and Democracy
- Immigration
- Memory
- Nationalism
- Patriotism
- Philosophical History of Identity
- Political Identity
- Sovereignty
- State Identity
- Terrorism
- Third World
- Transnationalism
- Transworld Identity
- War
- Worldview
- Protecting Identity
- Relating across Cultures
- Religion
- Representations of Identity
- Archetype
- Attribution
- Authenticity
- Basking in Reflected Glory
- Bricolage
- Commodity Self
- Critical Realism
- Cultural Representation
- Desire and the Looking-Glass Self
- Existentialist Identity Questions
- Extraordinary Bodies
- Hyperreality and Simulation
- Identification
- Identity Politics
- Intertextuality
- Looking-Glass Self
- Masking
- Material Culture
- Mimesis
- Minstrelsy
- Orientalism
- Other, The
- Philosophy of Organization and Identity
- Race Performance
- Self-Presentation
- Social Constructionist Approach to Personal Identity
- Social Constructivist Approach to Political Identity
- Stereotypes
- Subjectivity
- Theories of Identity
- Afrocentricity
- Articulation Theory
- Asiacentricity
- Black Atlantic
- Cognitive Dissonance Theory
- Communication Competence
- Communication Theory of Identity
- Contact Hypothesis
- Corporate Identity
- Critical Race Theory
- Critical Realism
- Critical Theory
- Cultivation Theory
- Cultural Contracts Theory
- Enryo-Sasshi Theory
- Ethnolinguistic Identity Theory
- Eurocentricity
- Global Village
- Identity Scripts
- Immediacy
- Interaction Order
- Mirror Stage of Identity Development
- Modernity and Postmodernity
- Optimal Distinctiveness Theory
- Organizational Identity
- Otherness, History of
- Persistence, Termination, and Memory
- Phenomenology
- Philosophy of Identity
- Political Economy
- Postliberalism
- Pragmatics
- Public Sphere
- Racial Contracts
- Regulatory Focus Theory
- Social Comparison Theory
- Social Economy
- Social Identity Theory
- Sociometer Hypothesis
- Symbolic Interactionism
- Terror Management Theory
- Theory of Mind
- Third Culture Building
- Uncertainty Avoidance
- World Systems Theory
- Loading...
Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL
-
Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
-
Read modern, diverse business cases
-
Explore hundreds of books and reference titles
Sage Recommends
We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.
Have you created a personal profile? Login or create a profile so that you can save clips, playlists and searches