Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

The upsurge of homelessness in the United States and other western countries since the late 1970s has stimulated a new level of concern about mental illness in homeless people. In earlier times, the chronic alcoholic stereotype often pervaded discussions of homelessness, leading to negative labels such as “wino” and “skid row bum.” The more recent focus on mental illness in homeless people was occasioned by their high visibility since the 1980s in major American and European cities, and by the public perception that many homeless people were seriously disabled by mental illness. There was concern that these high numbers were a result of the policies of deinstitutionalization that dominated mental health care since the 1970s.

For more than a century, Americans have generally accepted that the care and treatment of people with serious mental illnesses is a public responsibility. Until the middle of the twentieth century, this responsibility was largely met through state mental hospitals, which cared for steadily growing numbers of severely disabled psychiatric patients. The number peaked in 1955, when state and county mental hospitals housed 560,000 patients. Since then, there has been a movement toward treatment in communitybased programs, a trend motivated partly by medical advances and a new philosophy of mental health care, but also by humanitarian and civil rights considerations and the political goal of reducing the huge maintenance costs of public institutions. Deinstitutionalization policies sought to provide care largely on an outpatient basis, with a range of treatment, support, and rehabilitation services for people whose ability to function independently might be severely limited. This task has proved to be costly and complicated. Nevertheless, hundreds of thousands of severely mentally ill people who in a previous era would have been institutionalized indefinitely are now living in community settings.

Community mental health services are provided under local auspices, but unfortunately only a few localities have managed to provide an adequate array of services for the most severely disabled. For some of these people, when family or community supports fail, or when the illness itself hinders good use of available services, homelessness has been the result.

The Extent of the Problem

Concern about homelessness and the search for policies to address the needs of homeless people have prompted a series of research studies in American and European cities to discover what proportion of homeless people are mentally ill.

The simplest, but also the crudest, measure of the prevalence of serious mental illness is to ask homeless people if they have ever been admitted to a psychiatric hospital for treatment. When this question is put to clients of homeless shelters, about one-third of the respondents typically report such a hospital admission. This provides a rough approximation, but it does not identify those persons who may be ill but untreated, or those who have had treatment, but not in a hospital. It is also likely to underestimate the numbers, because for a variety of reasons people may not wish to disclose their history of hospitalization.

More informative data can be obtained by surveys that use standard methods to examine the mental health status of shelter residents or other homeless subgroups. A study of this sort must use rigorous scientific methods to obtain valid data. It requires careful sampling of the population, well-designed interview instruments, and trained interviewers, ideally with clinical backgrounds. With a clinical diagnosis for each person examined, the investigator can estimate the prevalence of mental illness in the population from which the sample was selected. Such studies have confirmed that a very high proportion of homeless people suffer from some type of mental, emotional, or substance use disorder. These range from mild and understandable substance abuse, depression, anxiety, or phobias to life-threatening alcohol-related illnesses, suicidal depression, or severely disabling schizophrenia. Many individuals show signs of more than one of these. In fact, only a small fraction of homeless people contend with no emotional, mental, or substance abuse problems at all.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading