Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Urban diseconomies refer to cost increases that occur as a result of urban growth. Globalization has created nodes of commerce and information that stimulate the expansion of urban areas. Consequently, an increasing number of places must confront problems associated with urban diseconomies. Symptoms of urban diseconomies may manifest differently depending on political, social, and other conditions.

One way to conceptualize the nexus between urban size and welfare is to consider the balance of two countervailing forces. On the one hand, as an area grows, economies of size operate to lower costs and improve efficiency. Economic advantages of increased size are known as agglomeration economies. Conversely, urban diseconomies tend to increase costs and lower productivity. They counteract the tendency for agglomeration economies to concentrate economic processes in a single place.

Urban diseconomies are critical to understanding optimum city size. Economists consider optimum city size as the point at which urban diseconomies offset economic advantages of agglomeration. Optimum size was considered that point where economies from larger size and urban diseconomies combine to maximize per capita income or some other welfare indicator. More complex analysis suggests that (a) there is no single optimum size because tastes and preferences of individuals differ; (b) optimum size of one urban place depends on the size and location of other places in the regional and global system of cities; and (c) cultural, political, geographical, and other features also influence the relationship between urban size and efficiency.

Conceptual Issues

There are several conceptual issues associated with urban diseconomies. First, size may reflect population, economic activity, or other indicators. Although measures of size are usually highly correlated, they can result in different indicators of urban diseconomies.

Identifying the area under consideration also is important when considering urban diseconomies. Imagine a political jurisdiction such as a city located within a larger metropolitan area. The metropolitan area might be experiencing significant urban diseconomies, whereas the city might accommodate growth without experiencing significant diseconomies, and vice versa. So, although a political jurisdiction might be experiencing diseconomies as the region grows, if the focus is only a smaller jurisdiction and not the larger region, further growth might improve welfare.

The geographical size of the region may also influence the nature of urban diseconomies. Problems associated with congestion, for instance, are more likely to be noticed in high-density places, whereas problems associated with construction of new infrastructure are more likely found in low-density places.

The Importance of Externalities

Problems due to externalities (spillover costs as one person's actions interfere with others) contribute to urban diseconomies and often call for government intervention. As cities grow, costs from externalities may increase because new entrants do not bear the full costs they impose on others. Facing this incentive system, some cities may grow too large. Some of the costs of new populations or other economic activity are often paid by existing residents.

One reason externalities become more serious problems as size increases is that the number of externalities created tends to increase in proportion to the population, as does the number of persons affected by each externality event. Because larger cities have both more externality-creating events and more people affected by each event, costs of externalities tend to increase exponentially with population size. This generalization models the relationship between urban size and costs due to externalities rather than reflecting the complexity of real-world problems. Laws, customs, and attitudes can affect both the tendency to create externality-causing events and the extent of harm from an externality event.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading