Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Are gifted and talented children and adolescents more prone to suicide than their non-gifted peers are? Presently, this question has proven difficult to answer. Tracy Cross and his colleagues have found that this is because of the complexity in defining giftedness, the lack of a designation of giftedness in data colleted on suicide, confidentiality diminishing access to information, psychological autopsies being expensive and time consuming, and the lethality of suicide causing certain information to be collected after a suicide completion. That being said, it can be assumed that gifted youth complete suicide at rates commensurate with the general population, at the minimum. Suicide is listed as the third leading cause of death in adolescents between the ages of 15 and 24. For youth ages 10 to 14, suicide rates increased by 51 percent between 1981 and 2004, according to the American Association of Suicidology. Internationally, suicidal rates are 0.5 for girls and 0.9 for boys per 100,000 in children between the ages of 5 and 14. It increases to 12.0 for girls and 14.2 for boys per 100,000. No matter what country a young person may call home, suicide is listed as a common cause of death in adolescents. This entry discusses suicide risks and warning signs, along with theories of suicide and possible interventions, with regard to youth in general and gifted youth in particular.

Risks

The typology of suicide behavior includes ideation, gesturing, attempts, and completions. Youth who ideate think about killing themselves. Gesturors engage in nonserious suicide attempts. Attemptors involve themselves in bona fide, but unsuccessful, suicide attempts, and completers take up behaviors that end their life. Gifted adolescents who may be at a heightened risk for attempting suicide are youth with prior history of a psychological disorder. Other risks identified by Lucy Davidson and Markku Linnoila include a history of drug or alcohol use, lethal weapons in the home, genetic factors, gender (boys are four times more likely to complete suicide than are girls; girls are three times more likely to attempt suicide than are boys), homosexuality, impulsiveness, and aggressiveness. Risk factors that may be particular to gifted youth consist of perfectionism, sensitivity, social isolation caused by extreme introversion, Kasimierz Dabrowski's five overexcitabilities, and inappropriate educational accommodations.

Philip Rutter and Andrew Behrendt warn that overemphasizing demographic variables in discussions of suicide risk can obscure who truly in the population is in peril. For example, current studies about suicide in young people focus on White youth. Consequently, intervention strategies may be tailored to this population. Suicide rates for African American, Native American, and Latino youth have mushroomed during the past decade. Focusing on demographic variables may misidentify some and underidentify others from these populations. Moreover, the intervention strategies proposed may be inappropriate or ineffective. Rutter and Behrendt thus urge the consideration of the combination of hostility, a negative self-concept, isolation, and hopelessness as conducive to accurately identifying which youth may be at risk for suicide.

Warning Signs

Young people who evince warning signs for suicide can be said to be ideating about suicide at the minimum. Some warning signs include prior attempts to take one's life; an increase in the use of alcohol and drugs; loss of interest in work, school, and personal hobbies; giving away cherished possessions; and preoccupation with death and dying. Several warning signs particular to gifted students may include an abrupt change in school performance; complete engrossment in schoolwork; lack of social participation; difficulties in relationships with significant others, especially when these peers are similar in ability; and a difficulty delineating the difference between fiction and fact. One should not assume a list will be created that captures all the ways young people may communicate that they are considering suicide. Moreover, Cross, Karyn Gust-Brey, and P. Bonny Ball cautioned against equating giftedness with being troubled. It would be better to err on the side of caution and assume that troubles in a gifted young person's life require attention.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading