Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Subaltern studies is a broadly influential academic movement whose goal is to refocus history on the unique role of subaltern or marginalized people in bringing about large-scale transformations in society. The implications of subaltern studies for geography are especially apparent in the group's exploration of spatialized categories of class, ancestry, and religion.

Subaltern studies began in 1982, when a collective of South Asian scholars in Britain, including Dipesh Chakrabarty and Partha Chatterjee, began publication of a book-length journal titled Subaltern Studies, edited by Ranajit Guha. Much of the collective's early work dealt with the politics of peasants who had been involved in the mass movements that ultimately led to India's independence. The journal's inauguration stemmed from a critique both of nationalist historians of India, who tended to focus on the local elites, and of orthodox Marxists, whose restriction of the concept of the working classes to industrial workers alone was, as the members of the subaltern studies collective argued, Eurocentric and badly suited to the varied economy of the Indian subcontinent.

Subaltern studies’ turn away from traditional methods of historical research was signaled by ongoing debates over the definition of the term subaltern. Although influenced by the Marxist philosopher Antonio Gramsci, who used it to refer primarily to industrial laborers, in the work of the collective the word subaltern came to describe any group that is wholly left out of the elite. In this light, the collective's focus also developed in relation to long-standing populist debates in South Asia, from the nationalist writings of N. G. Ranga and L. Natarajan to the variegated Marxism of scholars like A. R. Desai.

Marxism and Subaltern Studies

In recent years, subaltern studies has often been seen as a post-Marxist movement because many of its scholars selectively combine Marxist theory with a variety of other influences. The relationships between cultural Marxism and subaltern studies were particularly close during the 1980s, with the group's focus on material analyses of subaltern political movements. As such, subaltern studies theories developed in relation to transformations in British Marxism, wherein academics such as E. P. Thompson and Eric Wolf increasingly began to focus on ordinary people as the agents of history in Europe.

However, at that time, the rifts between subaltern studies and orthodox Marxism were also most apparent. Early-subaltern studies research placed particular emphasis on the self-contained autonomy of peasants, whereas some orthodox Marxists portrayed peasants as a byproduct of the particular history of capitalism in South Asia rather than a vibrant political group. Subaltern theorists also critiqued orthodox Marxist views on historical progress, including the assertion that every nation must pass through a transition from feudalism to capitalism. They argued instead that the histories of oppressed peoples needed to be recovered to produce a more accurate picture of major shifts.

Poststructuralism and Subaltern Studies

In the 1990s, the advent of poststructuralist theory was accompanied by a turn to discourse analysis that resonated with the collectives privileging of subaltern voices, voices that are often only minimally available in the historical record. As a result of this mutual influence, over time, subaltern studies research has focused increasingly on texts and textuality, including analyses of the ways elite leaders have defined subaltern groups. Some scholars have seen this move as evidence of greater theoretical sophistication inspired by the work of Jacques Derrida and Michel Foucault. Others, like the former subaltern studies collective member Sumit Sarkar, have seen it as a denial of human agency and therefore simply another form of subaltern disempowerment.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading