Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Since the late 1980s, geographic information systems, or GIS, have become almost ubiquitous in public organizations and throughout the nonprofit sector. Over this period, geospatial capability has become essential. The powers of GIS, including the assimilation, analysis, and graphical display of large volumes of geographically coded (geocoded) information, are widely recognized. They are typically used for purposes such as managing planning and zoning, geodemographic service management, emergency response system optimization and path selection, targeted-facilities location, and many others. Much of the innovation has been driven by the use of GIS for private sector marketing and spillover functionality that public organizations have capitalized on. At the same time, some functional areas, such as more reflexive data capture for GIS using Internet applications, are being targeted by both academic researchers and public sector developers and practitioners.

But why does—or should—GIS matter for public policy? Normatively, this entry assumes that the purpose of GIS in public policy is to increase spatial justice, that is, the distribution of costs and benefits across regions, areas, and populations. This justification is often presented by public organizations charged with improving the quality of public goods allocation. As Paul Longley (2005) argues,

In policy terms, these developments [widespread adoption and use of GIS by governing institutions] also arise out of greater recognition of the importance of preventative communications programmes (e.g., in health and policing) and the opportunity to improve efficiency by targeting them to those most at risk. (p. 59)

This entry presents a brief overview of significant trends within GIS literature in geography, planning, and critical GIScience literature and connects these with the public policy field. The range of public policy applications considered includes policy, environmental management, transportation and land use planning, and infrastructure design. Rather than presenting a laundry list of citations and examples of technical applications, this entry highlights several current trends in the deployment of GIS for public policy, to illustrate some technical developments that promise to increase functionality and to outline some structural impediments to the achievement of better spatial justice in public policy application.

Overview

A deep-rooted but rather thinly supported and almost ideological set of assumptions governing the utility and value for money of GIS generates significant enthusiasm among policymakers and government officials. Almost all the claims advanced in relation to public policy applications of GIS have focused on its potential to “improve” collaborative decision making in some way or another, either by including more stakeholder valuations and more data or by analyzing them in more effective ways, or both. Other advantages include supporting decision making and improving communication and collaboration. Improved spatial justice is imputed from this performance. The practical justifications offered by software vendors focus on efficiency. For example, the GIS developer and vendor ESRI (Environmental Systems Research Institute) lists 10 advantages of GIS for state and local governments, 5 of which involve revenue maximization or cost avoidance. Similar claims have been made by IT vendors with respect to their products for more than 30 years. In this regard, as with most IT domains, even the more limited efficiency claims advanced by software vendors are hard to quantify because focused life cycle benefit-cost analysis does not exist. Indeed, in a 2002 survey of the public sector GIS user base, Gregg Kreizman found that 37% of respondents stated, “No financial analysis is used to justify GIS implementation.”

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading