Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Most Significant Change Technique

The most significant change (MSC) technique is a dialogical, story-based approach designed to run throughout the life of a program. In what is basically a form of continuous values inquiry, examples of significant program outcomes are collected and presented to designated groups of stakeholders who deliberate on the value of these outcomes in a systematic and transparent manner. In evaluation, its primary purpose is to facilitate program improvement by focusing the direction of work toward explicitly valued directions and away from less-valued directions. Other possible roles are to provide decision makers with a vicarious experience of the project, encourage recognition of diversity in values among stakeholders, identify unintended outcomes, and provide performance information in the form of client success stories.

Initially devised for the evaluation of a social development program in Bangladesh, MSC has so far largely been used for monitoring and evaluating international development programs. As the MSC approach has developed and spread, the name has evolved too, with the technique having been referred to as the “evolutionary approach to organizational learning,” the “story approach” and “monitoring without indicators.”

MSC has points in common with critical incident technique and Kibel's results mapping. Critical incident technique focuses on variations from prescribed practice and generates negative information, whereas MSC searches for significant outcomes through an inductive process and tends to generate mainly positive information. Kibel's results mapping differs from MSC in that stories are coded by experts against a results ladder and a contribution analysis, whereas MSC stories are filtered up through the organization using a participatory process involving values inquiry.

Overview of MSC Methodology

The MSC approach has three main stages:

  • Establish domains of change
  • Collect and review stories of change
  • Monitor the process and verify the stories

Stage One: Establish Domains of Change

The first step is for the people managing the MSC process to identify the domains of change they think should be evaluated. Selected stakeholders are asked to identify loosely defined areas, such as “changes in people's lives,” that can be flexibly interpreted by the people who collect the stories. This discrete activity need occur only once, although it can be worth revisiting. It helps to have one category that is broad enough to include unintended and unanticipated outcomes.

Stage Two: Collect and Review Stories of Change

Stories of significant change are collected from beneficiaries, clients, field staff, and others directly involved in the program. A simple question is used to help collect the stories: “During the past month, in your opinion, what was the most significant change that took place in the program?” Respondents are asked to allocate their stories to a domain category. They are also encouraged to report why they consider a particular change to be the most significant one.

Next the stories are analyzed and passed up through the levels of authority commonly found within an organization or program. Each level of the program hierarchy reviews the stories sent to them by the level below and identifies the single most significant account of change in each domain. The “winning” stories are then passed on to the next level, and the number of stories is gradually reduced through a systematic and transparent process. At every stage of story selection, the selection criteria are recorded and made available to all interested stakeholders. This means that subsequent stages of the collection and selection process are informed by feedback from previous rounds. In this way, the organization effectively records and adjusts the direction of its attention—and the criteria it uses to assess the events it observes there.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading