Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

After remaining conspicuously stable for nearly 100 years, the number of people under criminal justice control increased nearly fivefold during the last quarter of the 20th century. During this “prison boom,” racial and ethnic disparities in criminal justice outcomes remained high. Today, U.S. prisons and jails house nearly 2 million people, and Blacks are three times more likely than Latinos and six times more likely than Whites to be in jail or prison. In the post-civil rights United States, most discussions about racial and ethnic disparities in criminal processing concern the apparent disjuncture between race-neutral law and racially disparate punishment outcomes, as reviewed in this entry.

Stages of Criminal Processing

Individuals arrested for allegedly committing crimes are processed through the criminal justice system. During pretrial processing, the defendant's charge is finalized, and a criminal justice official makes several decisions that affect whether or not the defendant will be kept in jail while awaiting trial. The first decision involves whether or not a defendant's release is conditional upon posting bail; if no bail is required, this is called a “nonfinancial release.” The second set of decisions is relevant only if bail is required; these decisions involve the amount of the bail and the forms of payment that will be accepted as bail. Third, in many states, a criminal justice official can decide that a defendant must stay in jail while awaiting trial; this is generally called “denying bail.”

After pretrial processing is over, defendants either agree to a plea bargain or go to trial. In a plea bargain, defendants enter a guilty plea in exchange for fewer charges, a decrease in the severity of charges, a lighter sentence, or a combination of the three. Following either a plea arrangement or a trial conviction, offenders are sentenced to a variety of punishments, including fines, treatment, probation, and incarceration. Once offenders are serving sentences, criminal justice officials decide when they are to be released and, later, if that release is to be revoked. Disparities—or differences—in each of these punishment outcomes are associated with both legal characteristics, such as the crime of conviction and prior record, and “extralegal” characteristics, such as race, employment status, sex, and age.

Racial Disparities

Pretrial Processing

Over a quarter of the individuals incarcerated in the United States are being held in local jails, and over half of these individuals are being held pending trial. Blacks and Latinos are overrepresented among those held pretrial. This disparity is generated by a combination of factors. First, many characteristics that are correlated with race and ethnicity, like residential stability and employment status, have been codified as legal factors that criminal justice officials are supposed to consider when making pretrial decisions. Second, there is strong evidence that racial and ethnic stereotypes influence criminal processing at this stage. Finally, because Black and Latino people have fewer financial networks and resources, they are less likely to be able to post bail when it is required for release.

Besides being a significant and detrimental experience in itself, pretrial incarceration also affects later processing decisions. People who are held pretrial are more likely to be sentenced to incarceration than those who are released pretrial, and, when sentenced to incarceration, they are given longer sentences than those who were released pretrial. Thus, disparities in pretrial incarceration are significant both in themselves and due to their contribution to disparities in later criminal justice outcomes.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading