Judaism

Judaism views honesty as crucial for both collective social function and individual moral integrity. Truthfulness is crucial within the Jewish legal system, in which dishonesty and deception is forbidden. Habitual lying and lying to children are also always forbidden. Dishonesty, however, is permitted, viewed favorably, and even required in certain situations. Jewish beliefs regarding truth (emet) and dishonesty are taken from the Torah and the Talmud as well as from Jewish tradition. Situations that allow for untruthfulness include the preservation of peace, respect for another person, and the protection of one's humility, modesty, property, and life.

The Torah comprises the written text of the first five books of the Bible, which God gave to Moses. The Talmud consists of the written compilation of oral commentary on the Torah given to Moses simultaneously with the written Torah, as well as historical rabbinic commentaries on the Torah. The Talmud and other Jewish commentaries discuss both Jewish legal matters (Halakha) and the broader Jewish tradition, including ethics and folklore. Scholarly religious commentaries, such as the Talmud, form an important component of the Jewish tradition, serving as guidelines linking eternal religious values such as truthfulness with everyday life.

The Talmud and post-Talmudic rabbinic commentaries interpret historical and biblical examples of lying and deception to extract scholarly interpretations of Jewish guidelines regarding truthfulness and lying. While truth is an essential guiding principle within Jewish law, religion, and tradition, Judaic scholars acknowledge the commonality of dishonesty in everyday life. Judaic scholars recognize the need to make historical and biblical teachings on truth relevant to new generations and the realities of the modern world. They also struggle with situations in which truth comes into conflict with other, equally important Jewish values.

The Talmud emphasizes the importance of truth as a central attribute ascribed to God within the Torah, stating that the “seal of God is truth.” Truth is a personal attribute to be emulated by God's people as a dynamic way of life rather than a universal value. Truth is an essential component of one's relationship to God and an essential component of the final judgment, when one must account for one's life. Liars, on the other hand, are categorized among those who are not worthy of God's presence. Truth also aids in the fulfillment of tikkun olam, the general belief in the restoration of the world through positive deeds and commandments known as mitzvot.

Judaism views truthfulness as more than simply the accurate statement of facts or the philosophical conflict between objective universal natural laws and mankind's subjective perception of the world. Truth is a dynamic, highly personal, all-encompassing guideline for living that shapes one's character and should inform all aspects of a person's life and decisions. The Talmud also emphasizes the importance of truth in everyday life, noting that habitual liars will quickly lose people's trust. Some scholars note that the Hebrew word for truth, emet, includes the first, middle, and last letters of that alphabet to highlight its all-encompassing nature.

The Torah contains several clear proscriptions against untruthfulness within the Jewish legal system, including the proscription to distance oneself from a false matter (Exodus 23:7), as well as prohibitions against bearing false witness (Exodus 20:16) and against theft, false denials, and lying (Leviticus 19:11). The applicability of these proscriptions to nonlegal matters, however, is debated. Scholarly commentaries also debate whether the Torah prohibits dishonesty that does not negatively affect another person. The Talmud recognizes that certain situations allow for or require dishonesty even if the proscription [Page 564]to distance oneself from a false matter is taken to encompass all types of lies and not just those within the judicial system.

...