Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

The placement of students of color in special education programs and services is a complex and contested issue. This entry provides an overview of assumptions and issues that permeate students of color in special education, and the equity issues that emerge for this group. Throughout the entry, terms are used purposely. The term students of color is increasingly used to describe students traditionally labeled as culturally, ethnically, racially, and/or linguistically diverse, or children and youth from so-called minority backgrounds. Objections have been raised to the use of some of these terms. For instance, some commentators object to the term minority because these students represent the numerical majority in many educational and community contexts. However, a counterargument is that the term minority is used to describe members of groups that occupy a subordinate position in society, even when they improve their status, because the group itself does not have the power of the dominant group.

The term diverse (with its various permutations) has also been critiqued because of the assumption that the experiences, language, and cultural practices of White middle-class students implicitly represent the norm, and all others are regarded as different. A related term, English learners or English language learners, describes students who speak a home language other than English. This term has also been criticized because it does not recognize the value in being multilingual and focuses instead on what students cannot do. Problems arise when the entire educational system is built on the practices and mores of the dominant group and consequential actions and measures are applied to groups of students who do not fit such norms. The term diverse, therefore, reifies the assumption that privileges the dominant group. The term students of color can also be criticized along similar lines, but it is currently favored because it is perceived as having fewer negative connotations.

Teaching Students of Color with Disabilities: Assumptions and Practices

Educational systems use technologies and practices to differentiate groups of students to cater to their presumed distinctive needs. For instance, grade levels or compensatory interventions are created to target groups of students clustered by age or social class, respectively. Special education aims to provide individualized intensive interventions for students with disabilities or with gifts and talents. Special education's creation came about as a landmark civil rights achievement in the United States for people with disabilities because this population had been historically neglected. Special education law gave individuals with disabilities rights and entitlements to educational programs, provided resources for personnel preparation, and granted families pivotal roles in the education of their children.

Nevertheless, the nature and value of special education have evolved in the past several decades to embody positive and negative meanings and desired, as well as controversial, consequences. The placement of students of color in these programs represents a case in which the identity and value of special education are contested and debated. This is an important issue considering the unprecedented growth of students of color in U.S. schools, the achievement gap between these students and their White counterparts, and the increasing racial segregation of students in U.S. schools. Although students of color with disabilities need special education interventions, equity questions have been raised in light of their overrepresentation in mild disability categories and their underrepresentation in programs for students with gifts and talents. The presence and treatment of students of color in special education reflect both positive and negative dimensions of the meaning and place of this form of educational service.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading