Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Dump digging refers to the practice of excavating old garbage sites. From beachcombing with metal detectors to digging through 18th-century outhouse contents, whatever the location, dump diggers share a common pursuit—unearthing items that people threw away in the past. Dump diggers also refer to themselves as “historical diggers” to highlight the differences between their work and professional archaeology, particularly garbology. Unlike archaeological garbologists, dump diggers normally search for intact items of historical interest, particularly household artifacts like glass and ceramics, leaving shards or scraps behind. Other dump diggers search for military relics, buttons, stoneware, and coins. Motivations for dump digging range from recreation to improving private collections and commercial sale.

Dump diggers are usually hobbyists, though some supplement their incomes by selling excavated materials at antique fairs and on the Internet. Dump diggers measure the value of the artifacts they find based on the objects’ “collectiblity.” To measure collectibility, diggers visit antiquarian shows and public gatherings, circulating photographs and stories about what they find. For example, glass bottles from the mid-1800s are exciting dig finds and popular collectors’ items because diggers know that during this period, the United States saw a boom in the production of commercial medicines and home remedies, many of which were sold in glass bottles. During the same era, glassblowing and bottle manufacture evolved rapidly. Dump diggers value medicine bottles not only for the unique advertisements and labels they bear but also because 19th-century glassblowers constructed them using a range of ingredients and blowing techniques.

Techniques

To locate potential dig sites, dump diggers use spring steel probes and metal detectors as well as historical maps and photographs maintained in local libraries and historical societies. Unlike archaeologists, dump diggers generally do not obtain special permits. Most dump digging occurs on private property or on sites marked for development or demolition. Earth-moving machinery often reveals potential new dump sites. According to most veteran diggers, gaining permission from landowners or construction supervisors is as important in the digging process as digging test pits and consulting archives.

While most dump diggers search through abandoned town dumps they locate with archival maps and city plans, disused latrine wells are some of the most publicized dump-digging sites. As archaeologists and diggers know, privies doubled as household trash receptacles in the era before widespread household plumbing and curbside garbage removal. Digging organizations like the Manhattan Well-Diggers, who excavate wells on construction sites, have popularized privy digging, particularly in urban areas, which contain a surprising number of old latrine pits. Diggers look for undisturbed “night soil,” or the privy's human waste layer, where they hope to find glass or ceramic bottles, pots, pitchers, plates, and bowls. After the advent of household plumbing, many privies were “dipped.” Their human waste contents were removed and used as fertilizer. This process did not necessarily strip the wells of all their contents, and dump diggers continue to excavate these pits in search of artifact-filled night soil.

Controversy

Dump digging is controversial, and digging artifacts out of privy wells elicits particularly active debate between professional archaeologists and dump diggers. Archaeologists have clashed with diggers over how best to conserve and document the contents of dump sites. In particular, archaeologists critique amateur diggers’ focus on the bottom of the wells. Archaeologists stress that in order to understand a site, they must excavate and document all of its contents in a meticulous and thorough fashion. Archaeologists of 19th- and early-20th-century U.S. cities point out that a great deal of meaningful evidence, including clues about social and cultural context, lies in pieces along the sides of privy wells. They claim that dump digging hinders their understanding of historical consumption patterns because diggers, in their haste to extract the most intact pieces, disturb or destroy the shards and organic material that are crucial to providing details about social life around dump sites. For this reason, some professional archaeologists have derided dump digging as “looting.” Others have recommended that cities place stricter limits on digging at construction and demolition sites. They have also warned journalists and historical societies against overpublicizing or glamorizing the practice.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading