Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

With the media occupying such a large presence of the daily lives of children and teens, calls have been issued for schools to take up the study of media, beginning as early as kindergarten and continuing through 12th grade. Proponents of media education in the classroom argue that in the modern world, the subject of the media deserves a place alongside more traditional topics such as social studies, science, and math. The term media education is often used synonymously with media literacy, describing endeavors that entail learning to “read” the media in an informed manner and with a healthy dose of skepticism.

Definition and Debates

Despite the calls for media education in schools, researchers, teachers, parents, and others have had difficulty agreeing on how this should be accomplished. Should media education adopt a protectionist tone (e.g., “you shouldn't watch that”), or will that turn young people off and make them resistant to the curriculum? How political should media education be, especially if it is conducted in public schools? Should negative effects of media on children and teens be emphasized, or should positive roles and media appreciation take center stage? Does media education include learning how to make media (e.g., learning audio or video production or how to make a website), or is media analysis the primary concern (e.g., developing and applying critical thinking skills)?

While these and other debates continue, a basic definition of media literacy has been offered by Patricia Aufderheide. It states that media literacy is the ability to create, access, analyze, and evaluate the media in all its forms. Aufderheide also identified a small list of key aspects. Media education should help young people learn that media “construct reality,” which basically means that media shape understandings and interpretations of the world. It should promote comprehension of the ways in which media portrayals are unrealistic (or are “constructions of reality”). Media education should advance knowledge of the potentially complex and varying ways that media affect audiences. It should help students to understand how media are made as well as why they are made (which introduces discussion of the commercial enterprise of making media). Finally, media education should foster awareness that media messages have inherent values associated with them. For instance, the relative absence of an ethnic group from prime-time television can serve to devalue the group, whereas the abundance of commercial messages in media can promote consumerism as a positive value.

Examples and Effectiveness

A number of media education curricula have been implemented in schools with both children and teens, and the effects of these efforts have been studied using social scientific research methods. The curricula vary widely in terms of age group targeted, the topic that they take on, and the exercises and assignments that they entail. Yet, they share a common objective: to increase critical thinking about media, often with the desire to intervene in media effects.

Advertising

A small number of published studies exist on the role of school-based media education in bolstering students' resistance to advertising. In one study conducted by Renee Hobbs and Richard Frost, 11th graders participated in a lengthy curriculum with an emphasis on the critical analysis of advertisements (among other topics). Later, participants were more likely than control-group members to be able to identify the purpose of an ad, its target audience, and the techniques used to create it. In studies by Erica Weintraub Austin and colleagues, media literacy training among third graders led to enhanced understanding of tobacco advertising techniques, diminished perception that most young people use tobacco, and increased endorsement of anti-tobacco advocacy.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading