Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Project Follow Through and Direct Instruction

Project Follow Through

Project Follow Through, at the time of its inception in the 1960s, was the largest educational research study ever conducted. The U. S. Office of Education (now the U.S. Department of Education) decided to support implementation of innovative approaches for teaching low-income students and oversee a comparative longitudinal evaluation of the effectiveness of eight of the major models. The instructional models were sponsored by a university or educational laboratory and ran the full gamut of theoretical approaches, from behaviorism to psychoanalysis to discovery learning and constructivist approaches derived from theories of Jean Piaget to direct instruction. The research was considered a test of which approaches were actually effective in helping students born in low-income households achieve at levels that approached their middle-income peers.

Direct Instruction

Of all the Follow Through instructional models that were examined, the one approach that has endured, more or less intact, for more than 35 years is the direct instruction model developed by Engelmann and Becker and their colleagues, such as Jean Osborn and Doug Carnine. The direct instruction model was adapted from pioneering work done by Bereiter and Engelmann in early childhood preschool education in 1966. The direct instruction curricula developed for the Project Follow Through longitudinal study became the precursors of the Science Research Associates (SRA) Reading Mastery and Language for Learning series, which still is used widely.

The overarching and deceptively simple principle of the direct instruction model was to ensure that all students learn, including those with limited exposure to print and formal academic English, by not only having a well-designed curriculum but also presenting the curriculum in a clear and unambiguous manner. Explicitness is thus a cornerstone of direct instruction. A central aim of direct instruction is to ensure high levels of student success, which in turn will lead to increased self-confidence and a willingness to take risks and grapple with conceptual thinking.

Evaluation Research

The actual evaluation design was extremely complex, involving more than a dozen approaches in almost 100 communities. However, the major analyses focused on the effects of eight innovative educational approaches that were considered to be the major models. Each was implemented in at least five and often up to 10 different sites. The independent evaluators were two large federal contractors with a long history of conducting large-scale evaluation research: Abt Associates and SRI International. They assessed the effectiveness of these instructional models on the academic performance and self-concept of students in the primary grades (K–3). The Follow Through students were compared to students with similar demographic characteristics who attended traditional programs. The researchers also explored which models demonstrated the most consistent evidence of effectiveness. The study involved thousands of students and focused on two cohorts that began school in 1969 and 1970.

The eight largest instructional models included direct instruction, the cognitive curriculum model (based heavily on Piaget), the Bank Street model (based on psychodynamic theories), the parent education model and others involving behavioral principles, and models stressing community linkages. Each of the eight models had been implemented in at least eight sites. Although many sites were in low-income urban sites, such as New York, Flint, Williamsburg County, and East St. Louis, some rural areas were included, such as Williamsburg County (South Carolina), the poorest community in the 48 contiguous states at that time. The student sample in Project Follow Through was approximately 70% African American, 15% Latino, 10% Native American, and 5% White. Four in five students were from low-income families.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading