The Other Side of the Report Card: Assessing Students’ Social, Emotional, and Character Development
Publication Year: 2016
Subject: Student Assessment (general)
The work is based on the authors' research into how the behavior ratings and comments sections of the report card relate to academic grades and standardized tests as expressed by CASEL and the SELect social-emotional learning programs. Provides samples and suggested report card designs to help educators model their own report cards after. Includes testimonials from the students and teachers.
- Front Matter
- Back Matter
- Subject Index
- Chapter 1: Is It Realistic to Include Social-Emotional Skills and Character on Report Cards?
- Chapter 2: Methods Currently in Practice: Yours and Others’
- Chapter 3: Adapting Your Report Card Comments for SEL and/or Character
- Chapter 4: Implementation and Case Study Examples
- Chapter 5: Implementation With Case Study Examples for Schools With Current SEL or Character Programming
- Chapter 6: Most Frequent Challenges Addressed and Overcome: Reassuring and Involving Parents and Aligning to Early Childhood Education and Career and Technical Education Goals
- Chapter 7: Checklist of Important Considerations
- Chapter 8: Literature Review on Previous Studies Related to “The Other Side” of the Report Card
Copyright © 2016 by Corwin
All rights reserved. When forms and sample documents are included, their use is authorized only by educators, local school sites, and/or noncommercial or nonprofit entities that have purchased the book. Except for that usage, no part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
A SAGE Company
2455 Teller Road
Thousand Oaks, California 91320
SAGE Publications Ltd.
1 Oliver’s Yard
55 City Road
London EC1Y 1SP
SAGE Publications India Pvt. Ltd.
B 1/I 1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area
Mathura Road, New Delhi 110 044
SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte. Ltd.
3 Church Street
#10-04 Samsung Hub
Senior Acquisitions Editor: Jessica Allan
Senior Associate Editor: Kimberly Greenberg
Editorial Assistant: Katie Crilley
Production Editor: Amy Schroller
Copy Editor: Jared Leighton
Typesetter: Hurix Systems Pvt. Ltd.
Proofreader: Lawrence W. Baker
Indexer: Nancy Fulton
Cover Designer:Scott Van Atta
Marketing Manager: Jill Margulies
Printed in the United States of America
All trademarks depicted within this book, including trademarks appearing as part of a screenshot, figure, or other image, are included solely for the purpose of illustration and are the property of their respective holders. The use of the trademarks in no way indicates any relationship with, or endorsement by, the holders of said trademarks.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Elias, Maurice J., author.
Title: The other side of the report card : assessing students’ social, emotional, and character development / Maurice J. Elias, Joseph J. Ferrito, Dominic C. Moceri.
Description: Thousand Oaks, California : Corwin, a SAGE Company,  | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2015034875 | ISBN 9781483386676
(pbk. : alk. paper)
Subjects: LCSH: Educational tests and measurements. | Personality development—Evaluation.
Classification: LCC LB3051 .E47 2016 | DDC 371.26—dc23 LC record available at http://lccn.loc.gov/2015034875
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
16 17 18 19 20 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
DISCLAIMER: This book may direct you to access third-party content via Web links, QR codes, or other scannable technologies, which are provided for your reference by the author(s). Corwin makes no guarantee that such third-party content will be available for your use and encourages you to review the terms and conditions of such third-party content. Corwin takes no responsibility and assumes no liability for your use of any third-party content, nor does Corwin approve, sponsor, endorse, verify, or certify such third-party content.
List of Essential Tables[Page ix]
- Table 1.1 The CASEL 5: Definitions and Skills Examples 5
- Table 1.2 Character Strengths and Behavioral Indicators 6
- Table 2.4 Steps to Evaluating Current Report Card Comments in Your School 19
- Table 3.2 Common Characteristics of Student Behavior and the Overlap With SEL 26
- Table 3.3 Common Characteristics of Student Behavior by Grade and the Overlap with Character Virtues 29
- Table 3.4 Example: SEL Likert Rating System 34
- Table 3.5 Example: Character Likert Rating System 34
- Table 3.6 Example: SEL Rubric Rating System 35
- Table 3.7 Example: Character Rubric Rating System 38[Page x]
The authors of The Other Side of the Report Card have written an important yet accessible book. It is steeped in the latest research in the fields of social and emotional learning (SEL) and character education (CE) and they make this research both accessible and actionable to the general reader and specialist alike. It will surely have a significant impact on building consensus for alignment in both of these fast-growing fields.
Most important, this book addresses the most critical issue facing the fields today: assessment. The authors help us understand the central importance of SEL and CE both in motivating children to learn and also in educating them in skills and values that will matter to them throughout their lives. But they do more than stipulate to this importance; they show in practical ways how this importance can influence the essential area of assessment and reporting. By providing both examples of innovative “report cards” as well as step-by-step procedures for a school to create its own assessment process, the authors provide a detailed roadmap for creating new and innovative models of assessment that will align with the Common Core and give teachers and parents new and vital information on student development. This is an area that requires urgent attention if SEL and CE are to make a sustained and sustainable difference to teachers, students, and families, and this book will make a significant difference in driving that hope forward. Readers will come to understand what elements of SEL and CE can be assessed quantitatively and which are better left to more open-ended forms of reporting. They will be able to see how new strategies for assessment can be applied to local schools and districts.
This book will go a long way to defining a new consensus on how to measure the things that matter most. There is hardly a more pressing issue in education today.Cofounder of CASELBennett Chair of Prevention Research, Penn State University[Page xii]
Support for the creation of this Guide came in part from funding from the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL), through a grant from the NoVo Foundation.
Foremost, we wish to acknowledge that our project was funded in part by a grant from CASEL, from a larger grant they received from the NoVo Foundation. In particular, Roger Weissberg, Mark Greenberg, and Paul Goren of CASEL lent immeasurable support at various points in the project. We also recognize our intellectual debts to those individuals who founded the fields of social-emotional and character development. They are too many to name, but we are clear that we stand on the shoulders of many visionaries and persistent advocates for promoting the well-being of children and an inspiring, supportive, safe school culture and climate.
We also have some particular personal acknowledgments that we would like to make. We have been blessed with many supportive family members, colleagues, and friends who have influenced and encouraged our work. Joseph (JJ) would like to thank his mother, father, sister, and brother, who have continually served as role models, who broadened his perspective on himself and others. It is JJ’s hope that this form of growth will be promoted for all children through this Guide. Dominic would like to thank his wife, sister, mother, father, and grandparents for being strong supporters of his education and for always providing him with love and emotional support. Maurice would like to recognize the enduring influence and continuing presence of beloved mentors, Joe Zins, Irv Sigel, Tom Schuyler, Jackie Norris, Larry Leverett, Ed Dunkelblau, and Tim Shriver. He would also like to thank a large group of dedicated and talented undergraduate and graduate students at Rutgers who have been such marvelous collaborators on this and related projects, especially Jazmin Reyes, Gwyne White, Cesalie Stepney, Danielle Hatchimonji, and Arielle Linsky.
Finally, we are grateful to our previously anonymous reviewers and to our Corwin editorial team for sharp insights, patient encouragement, and working in the spirit of continuous improvement in the interest of children.
Publisher’s Acknowledgments[Page xiv]
Corwin would like to thank the following individuals for their editorial insight and guidance:
Tennessee Technological University
Retired Elementary School Teacher
Science Curriculum Specialist
Golden Meadow Middle School
Golden Meadow, LA
Charles L. Lowery
Assistant Professor of Educational Studies
Ellenbrook Independent Primary School
Western Australia, Australia
Teacher, Educational Consultant
Clarkston Community Schools
K–5 Literacy Specialist and Subject Area Coordinator
Clarkston Community Schools
Pamela L. Opel
Teacher, Intervention Specialist
Gulfport School District
Sixth-Grade Teacher, NBCT
About the Authors
Intelligence plus character,
That is the goal of true education.[Page xviii]
Educating the mind without educating the heart is not education at all.— Aristotle
To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to create a menace to society.— Theodore RooseveltIn This Section
Utility: We provide a basic overview of the mission and purpose of this Guide.
Key Takeaway and Reflection Points:
- Educators have long been dedicated to the mission of promoting student success in school and life.
- Student success stems from intellectual and academic prowess in combination with an array of behaviors described by SEL skills and character attributes.
- These types of behaviors have long been recognized by educators as important, as is clear based on the long history of having behavioral feedback provided on the “the other side of the report card.”
Educators in schools across the nation collectively interact with millions of students every day. Each student is on a trajectory that will shape and influence the type of citizen he or she will eventually become. After each school day of overflowing responsibilities and endless additional hours of planning, we spend our nights contemplating to what end our hard work is leading our students and how we can reach goals more efficiently. The current educational climate also raises questions about whether our focus on preparing students for academic tests is balanced with preparing them for the tests of life.
Knowing that it is impossible to describe each student’s academic life fully, it is therefore desirable to provide the most essential feedback on student progress in school in a realistic way. Report cards are perhaps the most widely used method of feedback, with subject area grades long representing the top priority of schools: academic achievement. Historically, we also have had “the other side of the report card,” onto which we have recorded comments relevant to character, motivation, preparation, and more. The presence of these comments is a testament to educators who recognize the essential role of behavior in both achievement and student growth. The gifts of individual students, including their academic abilities, personality, character, and skills of relating and interacting, combine with complexity and emerge and develop inevitably in the school environment. It is intuitive as well as grounded in research that these skills relate to how a student functions both inside and outside of school.
[Page 2]Our report cards frame essential, multiyear conversations between students and teachers, teachers and parents, and parents and students. Some of the most important of these conversations, particularly for parents and guardians who are not as closely attuned to schools’ academic rigors, revolve around “the other side of the report card.” We must ask ourselves if current comment systems address the behaviors most worth talking about, that is, those most essential to promote and best aligned with our ultimate goal of educating the future citizens of our society.
The Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL) has conducted systematic research through collaboration with a multitude of school districts throughout the nation to explore this exact question. Which behaviors are most essential for students to develop and display in order to best learn as they grow into young adults? Through this research, they have found that there are specific social-emotional skills composing five major areas that improve academic achievement, increase positive behaviors (e.g., attitude toward school), and decrease negative behaviors (e.g., bullying and truancy) (see http://www.casel.org/library/2014/1/29/meta-analysis-of-school-based-universal-interventions). Referred to as the CASEL 5, the skill areas are self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship skills, and responsible decision making.
At the same time, Paul Tough, in his influential book How Children Succeed, reports on a parallel set of efforts to recognize that aspects of character—such as, responsibility, leadership, caring, and grit—also matter for student success in school and life. Conversations about character also have a place on “the other side of the report card” as they stem from one of the most universal questions parents have when they come into a school to meet with teachers: Is my son or daughter a “good child”? Parallel to the work of CASEL, Character.org has been at the forefront of other educational organizations focusing on the development of students’ character. Among the commonly agreed-upon dimensions of character strengths, drawn largely from the work cited by Tough, are grit, gratitude, responsibility, optimism, zest, and temperance (self-control). These dimensions also have been the focus of research illustrating their relevance to academic and life success (see the Resources section following Chapter 8 for research on social-emotional learning [SEL] and character).
This Guide provides educators with the tools and guidance to adapt current report card comment systems to include aspects of social-emotional competencies and character development that they deem most important. The process of schools and/or districts deciding on the specific content and format of “the other side of the report card” is a powerful vehicle for creating greater cohesion and intentionality within school systems. It creates a connection with systematic efforts to build students’ social-emotional skills and character as well as opportunities for new and valuable conversations involving educators, students, and parents. Additionally, it fosters the conditions essential for academic success and college, career, and citizenship preparation.10.4135/9781483395081.n5
Utility: While it is beyond the scope of this Guide to provide comprehensive steps to improve student social-emotional and character competencies, there are resources that schools have used successfully to accomplish this goal. These are listed here, along with research specifically cited in this Guide.
Our guidelines have emerged from research and the ongoing practice of many schools that have pursued and continue to pursue social-emotional competencies, character virtues, and a positive school culture and climate. We include below: (a) some sources that you can continue to check to see examples and to find potential collaborators or mentors, (b) key sources of updated information on research findings, and (c) books to provide background on SEL and character virtues and guidance for the implementation of SEL and character interventions in schools and districts.SEL and Character Examples and Collaborators
[Page 78]State Standards With SEL and Character
- www.edutopia.org—Edutopia, the George Lucas Educational Foundation
- www.CASEL.org—CASEL, the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning
- www.character.org—Character.org, formerly known as the Character Education Partnership, and Coordinator of National Schools of Character Awards
- www.schoolclimate.org—National School Climate Center
- www.characterandcitizenship.org—Center for Character and Citizenship
- www.jubileecentre.ac.uk—Jubilee Centre for Character and Virtue
- www.amenetwork.org—Association for Moral Education
- www.cfchildren.org—Committee for Children
- www.parenttoolkit.com/index.cfm?objectid=50A8EC10-32D8-11E4-B03B0050569A5318—Parent Toolkit, created and maintained by NBC News Education Nation, providing developmental guidance on SEL in English and Spanish
- njasecd.org—New Jersey Alliance for Social, Emotional and Character Development
- sel.cse.edu—SEL Academy provides online courses and certificate programs in school-focused coordination and leadership of SEL, character, and related approaches (for school and district leaders and leadership teams) and direct instruction of SEL, character, and related approaches in classrooms, small groups, and after-school settings (for teachers, school support personnel, and after-school program providers) (sel.rutgers.edu)
Likert Rating System for SECD Adopted StatewideKansas State Department of Education
- Kansas Social, Emotional, and Character Development Standards—http://www.character.org/wp-content/uploads/Kansas-Social-Emotional-Character-Dev-Standards.pdf
- Pennsylvania Standards for Student Interpersonal Skills—http://www.episcenter.psu.edu/sites/default/files/Student_Interpersonal_Skills_Standards.pdf
- Illinois Learning Standards: Social/Emotional Learning—http://www.isbe.net/ils/social_emotional/standards.htm
- CASEL Scan of State Learning Standards to Advance Social and Emotional Learning—https://www.casel.org/s/state-learning-standards-to-advance-social-and-emotional-learning.pdf
Books for Background on and Implementation of SEL and Character DevelopmentBackground
Implementation of SEL and Character Development
- Lessons From the Classroom by Hal Urban
- Character Matters by Tom Lickona
- You Can’t Teach Through a Rat by Marvin W. Berkowitz
- Eight Habits of the Heart for Educators by Clifton Taulbert
- [Page 79]Relationships + Rules + Routines = Results by Philip Vincent and Doug Grove
- An Ethic of Excellence by Ron Berger
- Building Academic Success on Social-Emotional Learning: What Does the Research Say? by Joe Zins and Colleagues
- Emotionally Intelligent Parenting by Maurice Elias, Steven Tobias, and Brian Friedlander
- Handbook of Social and Emotional Learning: Research and Practice edited by Joseph A. Durlak, Celene E. Domitrovich, Roger P. Weissberg, and Thomas P. Gullotta
- Promoting Social and Emotional Learning: Guidelines for Educators by Maurice Elias, Joe Zins, et al.
- Building Learning Communities With Character by Bernard Novick, Jeffrey S. Kress, and Maurice Elias
- Building an Intentional School Culture by Charles Elbot and David Fulton
- The Educators’ Guide to Emotional Intelligence: Social-Emotional Learning in the Classroom edited by Maurice Elias and Harriett Arnold
- Transforming School Leadership and Management to Support Student Learning and Development: The Field Guide to Comer Schools in Action by Edward T. Joyner, Michael Ben-Avie, and James P. Comer
- The School Leader’s Guide to Student Learning Supports: New Directions for Addressing Barriers to Learning by Howard S. Adelman and Linda Taylor
- Smart and Good High Schools by Thomas Lickona and Matthew Davidson
- Schools of Social-Emotional Competence and Character: Actions for School Leaders, Teachers, and School Support Professionals by Maurice Elias and Marvin Berkowitz [Page 80]
References[Page 81]2003). Eleven principles sourcebook. Washington, DC: Character Education Partnership.(Ed.). (2012). The handbook of prosocial education. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield., , & (Eds.). (Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning. (2003). Safe and sound: An education leader’s guide to evidence-based social and emotional learning (SEL) programs. Chicago, IL: Author.2009). Social-emotional and character development: A laminated resource card for teachers, for students, for parents. Port Chester, NY: National Professional Resources.(2015). Handbook of social and emotional learning (SEL): Research and practice. New York, NY: Guilford., , , & (Eds.). (2006). The educator’s guide to emotional intelligence and academic achievement: Social-emotional learning in the classroom. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin., & (Eds.). (2016). Schools of social-emotional competence and character: Actions for school leaders, teachers, and school support professionals [Laminated resource card]. Port Chester, NY: National Professional Resources., & (1997). Promoting social and emotional learning: Guidelines for educators. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development., , , , , , … (1995). The influence of report cards on the validity of grades reported to parents. Educational & Psychological Measurement, 55, 5–26., & (1998). Computerized report card comment menus: Teacher use and teacher parent perceptions. Spectrum, 16, 37–42., , & (2015). Minority disproportionality in general education. (Journal article under review.), , & . (2015). Grading the other side of the report card: How comments on an elementary school’s report card are connected to current and future academic performance. (Journal article under review.), & . (2015). Social-emotional competencies and academic achievement in diverse high school youth. (Journal article under review.), , , ., & (2014). Handbook of moral and character education (, , & (Eds.). (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.2008). The positive impact of social and emotional learning for kindergarten to eighth-grade students: Findings from three scientific reviews. Chicago, IL: Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning., & (2012). How students succeed: Grit, curiosity and the hidden power of character. New York, NY: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.[Page 82]([Page 93]
Helping educators make the greatest impact
CORWIN HAS ONE MISSION: to enhance education through intentional professional learning.
We build long-term relationships with our authors, educators, clients, and associations who partner with us to develop and continuously improve the best evidence-based practices that establish and support lifelong learning.[Page 94]