Fieldwork has often been viewed as a great black hole, untaught and unteachable. While recent years have seen an increase in the number of how-to manuals for doing fieldwork, they never fully convey the complexity of the experience–the loneliness, the uncertainty, the moral dilemmas, the ambiguities. In Experiencing Fieldwork, a group of top ethnographers addresses various issues and challenges of the fieldwork experience. How do you gain entree into a setting? What tricks are there to learning the rules of the community without alienating the people you came to study? How are good relations maintained with informants? What happens after you leave the field? Using examples of research from police departments to schools, from nursing homes to motorcycle gangs, the essays in this absorbing volume make the process of fieldwork come alive for the reader and provide invaluable advice for those entering the field. Scholars, researchers, and students in the fields of sociology, anthropology, education, and organization studies will benefit from the insights contained in this practical volume. “The depth of research experience among the authors is impressive, as is the range of groups they have studied–from students to survivalists, and from health care practitioners to motorcycle gangs…. The articles are ideally suited to help novices realize that emotional and interactional quandaries are an integral part of field research, rather than idiosyncratic experiences deriving from their own lack of expertise.” – Contemporary Sociology “The central strength of this edited volume as an instructional tool is its organizational respect for the theoretical tradition of symbolic interactionism…. Shaffir and Stebbins succeed in characterizing the research act as fully social action–as an ongoing production between positioned subjects…. Essays in each section provide a range of substantive materials and accounts from diverse ethnographic settings. The result is a detailed account of the process of doing fieldwork which provides the reader with a clear sense of ethnography as a practical accomplishment which rarely goes according to plan. A pedagogical strength of this text is to be found in the range of substantive settings made available to students…. Provides a tool through which students may demystify the exotic and attend to the problematic qualities of the everyday lives which they live…. A Valuable text for those teaching research oriented field methods courses.” – The Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology “A very credible work…this volume as a whole represents a distinctive contribution to the fieldwork literature. Most of the chapters more than adequately convey a meaningful sense of fieldwork experiences, and some of them are unique, exceptionally powerful, and truly outstanding. The text is valuable as an introduction to qualitative field research for advanced undergraduates, and especially for graduate students. Nonspecialists in other fields with an interest in methodology, research practice, and qualitative fieldwork will find it an inestimable resource. Specialists will especially appreciate the selections that develop key concepts on the basis of copious, concrete examples, as well as the several chapters that talk directly to other field-workers.” – Journal of Contemporary Ethnography “For cultural anthropologists working in North America, and especially applied anthropologists, these essay's provide an insider's perspective on qualitative fieldwork and the many lessons to be learned from it.” – American Anthropologist
Chapter 8: The Researcher Talks Back: Dealing with Power Relations in Studies of Young People's Entry into the Job Market
The Researcher Talks Back: Dealing with Power Relations in Studies of Young People's Entry into the Job Market
Field research involves many different forms of intervention, from silent observation, muttered agreement, and expressions of surprise to asking direct questions and providing information about oneself or the study. An important additional aspect of any research intervention is the researcher's appearance, accent, age, sex, ethnic or cultural group, and so on. All of these elements will shape participants' reactions to the researcher and the study itself. There is no such animal as the totally detached and value-free observer. Listening to someone speak in apparently passive silence can have a major ...