- Subject index
Acclaimed by researchers, students, and general readers, this informative, lively, and easy-to-use volume fills the public need for information about key recent and historical cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. Now significantly updated, this new edition includes all the new major cases-over twenty five in total-handed down by the Court since the first edition was published in 2000. The new entries include many high-profile cases that have stirred public controversy, including: Boy Scouts of America v. Dale (2000), granting the right to exclude homosexuals from leadership positions in the Boy Scouts; Bush v. Gore (2000), ceasing ballot recounts in the 2000 presidential election; PGA Tour v. Martin (2001), obliging the PGA to accommodate a disabled golfer; Lawrence v. Texas (2003), stating that a law criminalizing same-sex sodomy violates due process; Gratz/Grutter v. Bollinger (2003), stating that an affirmative action program to achieve diversity in universities may or may not violate the equal protection clause, depending on how it's implemented. In each of the over 100 cases summarized, author Tony Mauro succinctly describes the decision, provides background and facts of the case, the vote and highlights of the decision with verbatim excerpts, and, in conclusion, discusses the long-term impact of the decision on United States citizens and U.S. society. Topic search aids let readers easily trace the evolution and impact of rulings in particular issue areas. Added features also enhance the volume, including many new portraits, political cartoons, and drawings, a comprehensive bibliography and an easy-to-access case/subject index. A perfect starting point for research on Supreme Court decisions, this newly updated volume is an essential addition to every public, high school, and college library.
Boy Scouts of America v. Dale
Decided June 28, 2000
530 U.S. 640
The government may not force the Boy Scouts to reinstate a gay assistant scoutmaster. Requiring the scoutmaster's reinstatement would violate the Scouts’ freedom of association and interfere with its ability to convey its beliefs to its members and to others.
As a young boy in New Jersey, James Dale joined the Cub Scouts as soon as he could, and by age eleven he was a fullfledged Boy Scout. He enjoyed the camping and the camaraderie, and even when he turned eighteen—the age limit for Scouts—he stuck with the organization. As he began college at Rutgers University, he became an assistant scoutmaster for his old troop.
While at Rutgers, Dale also “came out” ...