The Discursive Mind
Publication Year: 1994
This lucidly argued volume covers the key philosophical revolutions that are shaping contemporary psychology. Harr[ac]e and Gillett herald a new paradigm in psychology, dissolving the Cartesian distinction between mind and body in favour of the discursive turn in psychological theory. The authors explore the discursive origins of the self, the problem of agency and social understanding of personality. In the process, they elevate the emotions to a significant place in our understanding of mind, action and being. The theoretical breadth of the book is matched by its treatment of a wide range of subjects, including: consciousness; the brain; perception; thought; personality; and the emotions.
- Front Matter
- Back Matter
- Subject Index
- Chapter 1: A Clash of Paradigms
- Chapter 2: The Second Cognitive Revolution
- Chapter 3: Thoughts
- Chapter 4: Cognitive Psychology of the First Kind
- Chapter 5: Cognitive Modeling
- Chapter 6: Discourse and the Brain
- Chapter 7: The Discursive Origins of the Sense of Self
- Chapter 8: Agency and Personality
- Chapter 9: Emotion Words and Emotional Acts
- Chapter 10: Perception and Consciousness
Copyright © 1994 by Sage Publications, Inc.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
For information address:
SAGE Publications, Inc.
2455 Teller Road
Thousand Oaks, California 91320
SAGE Publications Ltd.
6 Bonhill Street
London EC2A 4PU
SAGE Publications India Pvt. Ltd.
Greater Kailash I
New Delhi 110 048 India
Printed in the United States of America
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
The discursive mind / Rom Harré, Grant Gillett.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 0-8039-5501-4. — ISBN 0-8039-5502-2 (pbk.)
1. Discursive psychology. I. Gillett, Grant, 1950- II. Title.
BF201.3.H37 1994 93-43672
94 95 96 97 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Sage Production Editor: Diane S. Foster
The rapid rise of “discursive psychology” in the last five years indicates the appearance of a genuinely “new psychology” compared with what has gone before. Behaviorism passed away, leaving only its experimental methodology behind, and even that is kept in being more by institutional pressures than by any scientific merit. The new dawn seemed to many to be heralded by the development of computer-oriented “cognitive science,” but that too proved to be an illusion. The technical sophistication of the programming model was not matched by a coherent theory of the relation between formal computation and real-life human thought. Pressure from within cognitive psychology to achieve ecological validity led to an examination of human function in actual social and cultural settings. The ubiquitous role of symbol use in human [Page viii]life was immediately evident and has finally been reflected in an orientation in psychology that takes that fact centrally into account.
Discursive psychology is the culmination of a number of independent developments, reaching as far back as the work of G. H. Mead and L. Vygotsky. It incorporates such contemporary movements as ethnomethodology, social constructionism, and ethogenics. There has been a flood of new publications in the new style, but none of them is pitched at a level suitable for undergraduate study, nor do they attempt an overview of the new orientation and its working synthesis of linguistically oriented methods with the study of neuropsychology.
This book is an attempt to make the main tenets and some of the research results of discursive psychology easily available. It is meant too as an introduction to the forthcoming Sage text, the three-volume Rethinking Psychology edited by Rom Harré, Jonathan Smith, Luk van Langenhove, and Peter Stearns. Together the four volumes are intended to provide a basis for course work at both an intermediate and an advanced level.
Though the chapters in this book are new writing, the themes of several chapters have been developed in articles in Common Knowledge, Theory and Psychology, and Research on Language and Social Interaction.
In nearly every context in this book, psychological observations are meant to apply to human beings of either gender. To avoid some of the clumsy circumlocutions currently in use, we have adopted the vernacular device of the gender-neutral third person singular usage of they, their, and them as recommended by Muhlhausler and Harré (1991, Chap. 9).
We are grateful to Kevin Weinfurt, of the graduate psychology program at Georgetown University, for giving us a “student's eye” view of an earlier draft of this text, from which we drew some valuable lessons in more “user friendly” exposition.
References[Page 181]1983“Language and cognition” in Approaches to languageR.Harris (ed.) Oxford: Pergamon1937Personality: a psychological interpretationLondon: ConstableAristotle1925Nichomachean ethics (tr. D.Ross) Oxford: Oxford University Press1982Anger and aggression: an essay on emotionNew York: Springer-Verlaghttp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4612-5743-11973The central questions of philosophyHarmondsworth: Penguin1974“Criteria, a new foundation for semantics”RatioXVI156–1891968The evaluation of personal constructsLondon: Academic Press&1965“The snark was a boojum” in Readings in animal behaviorT. E.McGill (ed.) New York: Holt Rinehart & Winston[Page 182]Billig, M. (ed.) 1988Ideological dilemmasLondon: SageBilligM. (ed.) 1991Ideology and opinions: studies in rhetorical psychologyLondon: Sage1973 (1924) Psychology from an empirical standpointLondon: Routledge & Kegan Paul1929Sensory and noetic consciousness (tr. M.Schattle & L.McAlister) O.Kraus (ed.) London: Routledge & Kegan Paul1973Beyond the information given: studies in the psychology of knowingNew York: Norton1990Acts of meaningCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press1991“The ontogeny and phylogeny of joint visual attention” in Natural theories of mindA.Whiten (ed.) Oxford: Blackwell1993“Theory of mind and the facts of embodiment” in Origins of an understanding of mindC.Lewis & P.Mitchell (eds.) Hove: Erlbaum1966The scientific analysis of personalityChicago: Aldine1972Language and mindSan Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich1980Essays on actions and eventsOxford: Clarendon1984Inquiries into truth and interpretationOxford: Clarendon1641Meditations on the first philosophy (tr. J. R.Weinberg) New York: Adam & Tannery, Meditation 61979“Facial expression of emotion”Annual Review of Psychology30527–554http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.ps.30.020179.002523&1953The structure of human personalityNew York: Plenum1985Personality and individual differencesNew York: Plenumhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4613-2413-3&1990) Cognitive psychologyHove: Erlbaum& (1968Psychological explanationNew York: Random House1975The language of thoughtNew York: Crowell1972The archaeology of knowledgeLondon: Tavistock1977Logical investigations (tr. P. T.Geach & R.Stoothoff) Oxford: Blackwell1940“An outline of psychoanalysis”International journal of Psychoanalysis2127–841985“Civilisation and its discontents” in Civilisation, society and religion (Vol. 12) Harmondsworth: Penguin1979The ecological approach to visual perceptionBoston: Houghton Mifflin1984The constitution of societyCambridge: Polity1992aRepresentation, meaning and thoughtOxford: Oxford University Presshttp://dx.doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198239932.001.0001[Page 183]1992b“Language, social ecology and experience”International Studies in the Philosophy of Science51–81993“Humpty Dumpty and the night of the Triffids: individualism and rule following”Synthese19931992“Discursive practices and psychological science”American Behavioral Scientist36114–123http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/00027642920360010101970The intelligent eyeNew York: McGraw-Hill1991“Seeing, representing and describing: an examination of David Marr's computational theory of vision” in Investigating psychologyJ.Hyman (ed.) London: Routledge1984Representing and interveningCambridge: Cambridge University Press1981“Psychological variety” in Indigenous psychologiesP.Heelas & A.LockLondon: Academic Press1983Personal being: a rationale for the natural sciencesOxford: BlackwellHarré, R. (ed.) 1987aThe social construction of emotionsOxford: Blackwell1987b“Persons and selves” in Persons and personalityA.Peacocke & G.Gillett (eds.) Oxford: Blackwell1990“Embarrassment: a conceptual analysis” in Shyness and embarrassmentR. A.Crozier (ed.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 181–2041973The explanation of social behaviourOxford: Blackwell&1925 (1866)Physiological optics (tr. J. P. C.Southall) New York: Optical Society of America1965Aspects of scientific explanationNew York: Free Press1984Changing the subjectLondon: Methuen, et al.1984“Gender differences and the production of subjectivity” in Changing the subjectJ.Henriques et al. London: Methuen1952“Perceptual defence”Psychological Review59308–315http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/h00631261969 (1740)A treatise of human natureE. C.Mossner (ed.) Harmondsworth: Penguin1973Cartesian meditations (tr. D.Cairns) The Hague: Nijhoff1929 (1789)Critique of pure reason (tr. N. KempSmith) London: Macmillan1979“A functional approach to child language” in Cambridge studies in linguisticsCambridge: Cambridge University Press1986“From metaprocess to conscious access: evidence from children's metalinguistic and repair data”Cognition2395–147http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0010-0277%2886%2990040-5[Page 184]1955The psychology of personal constructsNew York: Norton1991“The homunculus fallacy” in Investigating psychologyJ.Hyman (ed.) London: Routledge1929Gestalt PsychologyNew York: Liveright1972The savage mindLondon: Weidenfeld and Nicholson1975 (1689)An essay concerning human understandingP.Nidditch (ed.) Oxford: Clarendon1973The working brain (tr. B.Haigh) Harmondsworth: Penguin1988Unnatural emotionsChicago: Chicago University Press1970A sociology of the absurdNew York: Appleton-Century-Croftsand1975The drama of social realityNew York: Oxford University Pressand1986“Whither psychology?” in Psychology: defining the disciplineJ.Margolis et al. (ed.) Oxford: Blackwell1983“Toward an ecological theory of social perception”Psychological Review90215–238http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.90.3.215&1990Cognitive neuropsychologySan Diego: Academic Press&McGill, T. E. (ed.) 1965Readings in animal behaviorNew York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston1934Mind, self and societyChicago: University of Chicago Press.1967Plans and the structure of behaviorNew York: Holt, &1976Language and perceptionCambridge: Cambridge University Press&1990“Truth rules, hoverflies and the Kripke-Wittgenstein paradox”The Philosophical Review94323–353http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/21853471968Personality and assessmentNew York: John Wiley1991Pronouns and peopleOxford: Blackwell&1967Cognitive psychologyNew York: Appleton-Century-Crofts1976Cognition and realitySan Francisco: Freeman1971Imagery and verbal processNew York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston1993“On the scientific study of angry organisms” in Perspectives on anger and emotion: advances in social cognitionR. S.Wyer & T.Srull (eds.) Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum1981Communication, action and meaningNew York: Praeger&1958“Some mechanisms of consciousness discovered during electrical stimulation of the brain”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences4451–66http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.44.2.51[Page 185]1970Personality, theory, assessment and researchNew York: John Wiley1990“The reality of rule-following”Mind991–22http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mind/XCIX.393.1Plato1982Protagoras (tr. B. A. F.Hubbard & E. S.Karnofsky) London: Duckworth1992Discursive psychologyLondon: Sage&1978 (1905)The dissociation of personalityOxford: Oxford University Press1979“Imagery theory: not mysterious—just wrong”Behavioral and Brain Sciences2561–563http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X0006444X1984Computation and cognitionCambridge, MA: MIT Press1967“The problem of perception” in The philosophy of perceptionG. J.Warnock (ed.) Oxford: Oxford University Press,1980Knowledge and passion: Ilongot notions of self and social lifeCambridge: Cambridge University Presshttp://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO97805116218331989Theories of personalityNew York: Wadsworth1992“The construction and deconstruction of self in Alzheimer's disease”Ageing and Society12443–461http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0144686X00005262&1975“Immediate memory for word lists and sentences in a patient with deficient auditory short term memory”Brain and Language2420–433http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0093-934X%2875%2980081-2&1987A historical introduction to phenomenologyNew York: Croom Helm&1987“Emotion and act: roles and rhetoric” in The social construction of emotionsR.Harré (ed.) Oxford: Blackwell, Chapter 51958Being and nothingness (tr. H.Barnes) London: Methuen1977“Scripts, plans and knowledge” in Thinking: readings in cognitive scienceP. N.Johnson-Laird & P. C.Wason (eds.) New York: Cambridge University Press&1992Thinking through culturesCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press1987“Personality: developments in the study of private experience”Annual Review of Psychology38533–574http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.ps.38.020187.002533&1965“Brain dissection and the mechanisms of consciousness” in The brain and conscious experienceJ.Eccles (ed.) New York: Springer-Verlag1988Emotion and social changeNew York: Holmes and Meier&1983From folk psychology to cognitive scienceCambridge, MA: MIT Press1959IndividualsLondon: Methuenhttp://dx.doi.org/10.4324/97802032213031964The explanation of behaviourLondon: Routledge1913The psychology of learningNew York: Teachers College Press[Page 186]1992“The functions of emotions in early infant communication and development” in New perspectives in early communication developmentJ.Nadel & L.Camioni (eds.) London: Routledge1981The analysis of actionCambridge: Cambridge University Press&1962Thought and languageCambridge, MA: MIT Presshttp://dx.doi.org/10.1037/11193-0001978Mind in societyCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press1987Thinking and speechNew York: Plenum1968“The contingent variation: an electrocortical sign of sensori-motor association in man” in Brain Reflexes: Progress in Brain Research22E. A.Astratyan (ed.) 364–377http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0079-6123%2808%2963519-01992The psychology of personal freedomNew York: Springer-Verlag1992Semantics, culture and cognitionNew York: Oxford University Press1958The idea of a social science and its relation to philosophyLondon: Routledge1953Philosophical investigations (tr. G. E. M.Anscombe) Oxford: Blackwell1961 (1922)Tractatus logico-philosophicus (tr. D. F.Pears & B. F.McGuiness) London: Routledge & Kegan Paul1972Blue and brown booksOxford: Blackwell1975Philosophical remarksR.Rhees (ed.) Oxford: Blackwell
About the Authors[Page 191]
Rom Harré is truly a Renaissance man. As lecturer, teacher, and philosopher, he has long been a preeminent and influential voice whose work is recognized in many disciplines. In the last 20 years he has been a pioneer in developing the theory and practice of discursive psychology. He is presently a Fellow of Linacre College, Oxford; Professor of Psychology at Georgetown University in Washington, DC; and Adjunct Professor of Philosophy at SUNY, Binghamton, NY. Author of more than 200 journal articles and 24 books, including The Philosophies of Science, Second Edition (1986), Personal Being: A Theory for Individual Psychology (1983), Physical Being: A Theory for Corporeal Psychology (1991), and Social Being: Revised Edition (1993). He has also edited or co-edited another 26 volumes, including the Blackwell Encyclopedic Dictionary of [Page 192]Psychology (1985). He is the recipient of many academic awards including an honorary D.Pol. (Helsinki), an honorary D.Sc. (Brussels), and the Royden B. Davis Professor of Interdisciplinary Studies (1993). His interests range from the analyses of emotions to social theories and linguistics. A New Zealand native, Harré has held posts and lectured all over the world, most recently in China, the United States, Spain, the Netherlands, and Canada.
Grant R. Gillett has a unique combination of experience and interests as an internationally known neurosurgeon, philosopher, and teacher. He is currently a consultant neurosurgeon at Dunedin Hospital in New Zealand; Associate Professor in medical ethics, Bioethics Centre, University of Otago Medical School (where he established and developed the bioethics teaching course); and Honorary Lecturer in Philosophy, Otago University. In addition to teaching clinical neuroscience, philosophy, and psychology courses, Gillett serves as ethics adviser to the New Zealand Health Department and holds editorial board positions on eight journals, including the Journal of Mind and Behavior, Social Science and Medicine, and the British Journal of the Philosophy of Science. Widely published in the fields of philosophy, medical ethics, and philosophical psychology, he is also author of Representation, Meaning and Thought (1992), coauthor of Practical Medical Ethics (1992), and coeditor of Medicine and Moral Reasoning (1993). He is a Fellow of the Royal Australian College of Surgeons and a member of the New Zealand Neurological Association, Oxford Society for Applied Philosophy, and the Australian Association of Neurological Surgeons. He has also presented over 100 academic papers and addresses in Europe, the United States, Canada, and Australia.