Human Rights and Peace: Ideas, Laws, Institutions and Movements
Publication Year: 2009
Human Rights and Peace: Laws, Institutions and Movements explores the shifts in the way peace has been envisaged in the rhetoric and practice of human rights. Peace has come to be seen as a continuing process of the pursuit of liberation, a progressive dismantling of relationships, of exploitation based on gender, caste, class, race, ethnicity and nationality, and a countervailing force to the coercive practices of the state. Woven around the themes of ideas, laws and institutions, and movements, the articles in this volume show how peace has become an over-arching framework in the domain of human rights. The book traces how the idea of peace has transformed from a passive condition of 'sepulchral silence' associated with 'guided' peace, into a praxis led by and ...
- Front Matter
- Back Matter
- Subject Index
- Section A: Ideas and Visions
- Chapter 1: Declaration on the Right of Peoples to Peace
- Chapter 2: The Human Right to Peace
- Chapter 3: In Life, in Death
- Chapter 4: SAARC in 2020: The Dream, the Nightmare and the Wake-Up Call
- Chapter 5: Archiving Disquiet: Feminist Praxis and the Nation-State
- Chapter 6: Democracy in Search of Dignity
- Chapter 7: On Liberation: Biography of a Consciousness
- Section B: Encountering Undemocratic Laws
- Chapter 8: POTA and Beyond: The Silent Erosion
- Chapter 9: Gendered Face of Extraordinary Powers in North-East India
- Chapter 10: Dalit Lynching at Dulina: Cow-Protection, Caste and Communalism
- Chapter 11: War in the Heart of India
- Chapter 12: Borders in the Mind: Bangladeshis, a Nowhere Policy for a Nowhere People
- Section C: Rights, Movements and Institutions
- Chapter 13: The Concept of Civil Liberties
- Chapter 14: Terrorism, State Terrorism and Democratic Rights
- Chapter 15: Human Rights Movement(s) in India: State, Civil Society and Beyond
- Chapter 16: Reduced to Ashes: The Insurgency and Human Rights in Punjab
- Chapter 17: The Punjab Mass Cremations Case: A Postscript
- Chapter 18: National Human Rights Commissions and Internally Displaced Persons: The Sri Lankan Experience
South Asian Peace Studies[Page ii]
Series Editor: Ranabir Samaddar
Other Titles in the Series
Volume 1: Peace Studies: An Introduction to the Concept, Scope, and Themes (edited by Ranabir Samaddar)
Volume 2: Peace Processes and Peace Accords (edited by Samir Kumar Das)
Volume 3: Women in Peace Politics (edited by Paula Bannerjee)
Editorial Advisory Board
Daya Varma, Professor, McGill University, Montreal, President CERAS, Montreal, Canada
Ghislaine Glasson Deschaumes, Founder and Director of the international journal of critical thought Transeuropéennes, Paris, France
Itty Abraham, East–West Center, Washington DC, USA
Jyrki Kakonen, Jean Monnet Professor, Department of Political Science and International Relations, University of Tampere, Finland
Oren Yiftachel, Professor, Department of Geography, Ben Gurion University, Beer Sheva, Israel
Paul Joseph, Professor of Sociology, and Peace and Justice Studies, Tufts University, MA, USA
Rada Ivekovic, Professor, Department of Sociology, Jean Monnet University, Saint Etienne, France
Shree Mulay, Director, McGill Centre for Research & Teaching on Women, McGill University, Montreal, Canada
Stefano Bianchini, Director, Europe and the Balkans International Network, University of Bologna-Forli Campus, Forli, Italy
Editorial Board for this Volume
Ujjwal Kumar Singh
Bikram Jeet Batra
Copyright © Mahanirban Calcutta Research Group, 2009
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
First published in 2009 by
SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd
B 1/I-1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area
Mathura Road, New Delhi 110 044, India
SAGE Publications Inc
2455 Teller Road
Thousand Oaks, California 91320, USA
SAGE Publications Ltd
1 Oliver's Yard, 55 City Road
London EC1Y 1SP, United Kingdom
SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd
33 Pekin Street
#02-01 Far East Square
Published by Vivek Mehra for SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd, typeset in 10.5/12.5pt Minion by Star Compugraphics Private Limited, Delhi and printed at Chaman Enterprises, New Delhi.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Human rights and peace: ideas, laws, institutions and movements/edited by Ujjwal Kumar Singh.
p. cm.—(South Asian Peace Studies; v. 4)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
1. Human rights—South Asia. 2. Peace-building—South Asia. I. Singh, Ujjwal Kumar.
JC599.S64H86 323.0954—dc22 2008 2008045018
ISBN: 978-81-7829-884-9 (Pb)
The SAGE Team: Elina Majumdar, Anupam Choudhury, Mathew P.J. and Trinankur Banerjee
Series Note[Page vii]
Peace has become a maximal concept, refusing to accept a minimalist version that stops with the master-idea of security. This was never so apparent as in the present time, when draconian laws, outright aggression, plunder, global control of monopolies, resource wars, immigration control and new racism—all are being justified in the West, particularly in the United States, in the name of security against terrorism and a new global order. At the same time, the world is being told that this is the pathway to peace. This series is intended to address the critical time as this. It brings together writings that refuse to accept the dominant ideas on peace given to us by national and international security establishments.
The first volume of the South Asian Peace Studies introduces the concept, scope and themes of peace studies. The second volume deals with peace accords in this region. The third volume narrates experiences of women in conflict and peace. The fourth volume deals with human rights institutions in this region.
This series of volumes is different from the usual conflict and conflict resolution studies that revolve around interest-based approaches and game theories. While it remains uncertain how much these studies have contributed to an enriched understanding of conflicts and the dynamics of their resolution, now it is reasonably clear that these, while focusing on conflicts, neglect the ideas and visions of peace, justice and reconciliation and were often used as post facto justification of the way in which a particular conflict was handled, the most well-known example in this region being the Indo-Pakistan wars over Kashmir. Conflict studies by and large divorced the idea of conflict resolution and peace from practices of democracy and justice. More important, in these kinds of studies, there was little recognition of the social and political realities of the colonial and post-colonial world. Peace with justice seems to be an impossible agenda to the conflict and conflict resolution theorists and practitioners. The South Asian Peace Studies [Page viii]series has been planned as an exercise against that politics of excluding justice and democracy from conflict resolution and peace—by bringing into light practices of human rights, justice, dignity, reconciliation and democracy, and lodging them at the heart of peace studies. In a world characterised by structures of dominance and inequality and the received histories of freedom, the volumes will show that peace studies will have to be of a critical nature.RanabirSamaddar Calcutta Research Group, Kolkata
This is the fourth volume in the peace studies series. In keeping with the specific concerns of the volume, it brings together writings of scholars who are organically embedded in the democratic rights movement. The selection of themes for the volume and the identification of corresponding writings involved a long process of several discussions with Ranabir Samaddar. I am grateful to him for both offering me this opportunity to edit the volume and for steering it along. Each discussion on the volume was a revelation of his commitment to the democratic rights movement and his incredible repertoire of writings in the field over the past several years. We are fortunate to have among our contributors, scholars whose works are inextricably interwoven with concerns arising from their activism in the field. I am thankful to Randhir Singh, Uma Chakravarti, Manoranjan Mohanty, Gopal Guru, Rubina Saigol and Paula Banerjee for agreeing to give for this volume their writings, which flow from their experiences in the democratic rights movement, and are deeply reflective of the manner in which the struggle for transformative change has been articulated over time. To Uma, I am particularly grateful for putting me in touch with Rubina, and giving me access to two truly wonderful papers on women's experiences with the state in South Asia; to Manoranjan Mohanty for a fascinating autobiographical exploration of the idea of liberation; to Gopal Guru for his perceptive piece on dignity and to Randhir Singh, as always, for his article which raises issues which inspire and never cease to amaze you for their enduring relevance. Thanks are also due to Ram Narayan Kumar for agreeing to have us reprint excerpts from their path-breaking report on human rights violations in Punjab and to Ashok Aggarwal, another lead member of the team, for bringing us abreast with the developments that took place thereafter. I am grateful to Nandini Sundar for giving us permission to print excerpts from the report by the Independent Citizen's Initiative on Chhattisgarh and to the People's Union for Democratic Rights for its report on violence [Page x]against Dalits in Jhajjhar. I am obliged to Professor Sobhanlal Datta Gupta for allowing us to reproduce Gopal Guru's paper which was first published as an occasional paper at the Political Science Department of Calcutta University and to the Economic and Political Weekly for giving permission to print Randhir Singh's article. Dr Ram Manohar Lohia's essay on civil liberties in India has been excerpted from The Struggle for Civil Liberties published by the Foreign Department, All India Congress Committee, Allahabad at the Allahabad Law Journal Press.
I was fortunate to work with a brilliant team of theme editors, Anupama Roy, Bikram Jeet Batra and Ajay Gudavarthy, to whom I am especially thankful for taking up the task with meticulous zeal. The bibliography was prepared with great care and interest by Pushpa Kumari. I am grateful to the SAGE team, particularly Anupam Choudhury, for their enduring support in bringing out this volume.
Human Rights and Peace: An Introduction[Page xi]Ujjwal KumarSingh
For a long time now, the idea of human rights has broken out of the passivity imposed by an overriding concern in the interwar years with the reclamation of peace through negotiations for collective security forged among those at war. The relationship between peace and human rights has since become increasingly and inextricably symbiotic. Indeed, the mutuality spelt by this relationship as one of prolonged and necessary association and interdependence, has transformed itself over the years into one of coalescence. Subsequently, peace has woven into human rights, as an overarching framework filling up the entire domain of human rights as well as forming an interlacing and interlocking network, giving human rights its contemporary form and substance.
The shift from one relationship to the other has been accompanied by a process of change in a way in which peace has been envisaged in the rhetoric and practice of human rights. If collective security and negotiated peace were the guiding principles for the ‘world without war’ that the League of Nations envisaged, the United Nations Covenant gave a positive connotation to peace as a condition which did not mean merely the absence of war, but the removal of conditions that impeded self-determination. The centrality which the right to self-determination came to assume in human rights instruments since the United Nations Covenant articulated it, has progressively entrenched itself as the foremost rallying point and a propelling force for human rights praxis. This positive inclination and thrust to peace undoubtedly reflected the historical contexts within which the Covenant was framed—the aspirations for liberation of ‘the oppressed majorities’ and the tumultuous process of decolonisation that had [Page xii]begun unfolding in much of the colonised world. In many ways the language of self-determination began almost an inexorable process of pushing at the frontiers of human rights and charting out a course to peace, which involved active pursuit of a self that was unbridled and unshackled by all forms of domination based on caste, class, gender, race, nationality and ethnicity.
The idea of peace as it emerged from the processes which followed the Second World War, became the foundational principle of reparation and restructuring that was to mark not just the end of war, but also become an emblem of hope and rejuvenation countering the misery and devastation wrought by war. Indeed peace was redefined in two significant ways. First, the peace that followed war, was not something which was solely a condition to be regulated and determined by a confederation of sovereign states, steering themselves into a state of perpetual peace. Neither was it merely the ‘restoration’ of a previously existing condition or the substitution of one relationship of exploitation with another. Rather, peace came to be defined as freedom from domination in all forms, so much so that it embodied the ideas and processes of democratisation and the multifarious struggles against injustice and repression in all their manifestations. Thus, rather than a sepulchral silence associated with ‘guided’ peace, a multitude of ideas and struggles, envisioned and set off a process of restructuring, of rolling back and dismantling relations of domination, making peace a form and measure of action, a praxis both led by and producing radical politics of liberatory and transformative change. Second, the struggles being waged at the multiple sites of domination and repression produced a diversification and proliferation of ideas that provided a driving force to struggles for self-determination, redefining the relationship between peace and human rights. If the idiom of self-determination propelled national liberation struggles, the logic of liberation gave momentum to the deepening of democracy, so that popular sovereignty extended not only to a people defining themselves as a nation, but to all communities and groups repressed by ideologies of power and domination. Peace was therefore, a continuing process of pursuit of liberation, which not only led to a radical pluralisation of human rights; in a manifestation of the progressive dismantling of relationships of exploitation, this radical pluralisation further led to the fragmentation of universal notions dictated and regulated by [Page xiii]‘conquerors’. Peace ceased to be an incremental notion whereby more and more people could be included into a hallowed universal circle. Articulated at every node of exploitation, it became de-centred. Yet, this de-centring did not make the aspiration for peace discrete or insulated—the shared experiences of exploitation made the struggles for peace ultimately interdependent and relational.
The active pursuit of peace imbued with the language of liberation and self-determination, has seen the drawing of lines between a politics of power and a countervailing praxis of resistance. Yet, the lines between them are not clearly or unambiguously drawn, and as Upendra Baxi, points out ‘there is not one world of human rights, but many conflicting worlds’ (Baxi 2002: 5), requiring that the politics of legitimation of power masquerading as human rights be unmasked by a relentless praxis of liberatory and emancipatory politics. The contested worlds of resistance and power, would in the process of unmasking become more demarcated. Moreover, the world of resistance would be more multitudinous, generating the praxis of emancipatory politics, which would manifest itself in a progressive dismantling of the world of power and domination, laying down the basic structures of a just and fair society. The politics of power vis-à-vis the politics of resistance locks horns over contesting rationale for peace and human rights. The politics of power is driven by reasons of state and governmentality, and social relations informed by exclusions, justifying relationships of hierarchy, marked and sustained by routine and structural violence. The world of human rights which corresponds to the politics of power, is best illustrated by social relations and social and political institutions that are exclusionary, eliminate assertions of difference, are intolerant of ideological and cultural plurality, and promote and justify violence against women, ethnic and racial minorities and Dalits.
Not surprisingly, much of this violence is justified as essential and appropriate. In the wake of 9/11 bombings, for example, President Geroge W. Bush claimed legitimacy for the military onslaught on the so-called axis of evil, under an ‘international consensus’ over the Bush Doctrine of ‘spreading democracy’. The war for ‘preserving’ democracy was accompanied by a spate of anti-terrorist measures worldwide. Replete with claims of ensuring ‘enduring freedom’ and liberty, these measures purportedly aimed at making the world safe for democracy. Much has been said and written about what actually lies under the [Page xiv]veneer of the international consensus—the neo-conservative agenda, US global military, economic and strategic domination, and so on. It is perhaps ironical that the use of war as an instrument for conflict resolution was legitimised through authorisation from the international community. The ‘keepers of the Great Peace’, as Partha Chatterjee calls it, who descended as ‘a dark shadow’ on the earth following the end of the Cold War and the spread of the free market and liberal politics (Chatterjee 2004: 82), took upon themselves the task of ‘protecting democracy’ through war. That the war itself was wanton, irresponsible and unjust, is indicative of the ways in which instant regimes of dominant legalities based on force, tyranny and terror, render people rightless.
There are some who advocate ‘a global civil society governed by fair rules’ (Young 2007: 107) emphasising the power of the international public sphere and global rule of law to ‘shame and pressure’ (ibid.). Iris Marion Young, for instance, argues for ‘legitimising and strengthening international institutions’ particularly the United Nations, which is the only transnational institution having representation of nearly all the people of the world (ibid.: 109–10). However, there are others who see these practices as generating a ‘compromistic web of textual politics’ giving rise to a ‘paradoxical situation’ where ‘the number of rightless people grows even as human rights norms and standards proliferate…the more people stand endowed with normative human rights by international and constitutional instruments, the greater and keener emerges the suffering of people existentially deprived…’ (Baxi 2002: viii).
Moreover, as Upendra Baxi emphasises:
[W]hile the notion of human rights violations presupposes a sort of concern with violence, human rights languages do not always import the same order of heavy consequences for actors that produce human suffering in peace time as in warlike situations. The emerging standards of international criminal law in warlike situations do not extend to systematic, sustained and planned peacetime denials of the right to satisfaction of basic human needs such as food, clothing, housing and health…The millions of rightless people have different stakes in the future of human rights than many epistemic human rights communities. While, the latter finds in every human rights enunciation a signature of a better human future, the rightless peoples, all too often, find these enunciatory moves rather callous. (ibid.: vii)
[Page xv]While human rights instruments may form the basis for fashioning epistemic communities constituted by active and emancipatory politics, leading eventually to human rights as a global discourse, the communities of resistance formed through sufferings and struggles at the local levels, are distanced from the actual unfolding of the epistemic community by a spatial, communication and intelligibility barrier. It is not surprising then that democratic rights groups and movements, are deeply suspicious of what they perceive as ‘system supportive word management’ (Randhir Singh in this volume). On issues of violence and democratic rights in particular, this management becomes all the more evident and the contests between contending worlds of human rights and the corresponding worlds of power and resistance become more palpable. Moreover, the different ways in which the violence emanating from these opposing worlds is perceived in relation to peace, conflict resolution or human rights violations is more than obvious. The discussion on Salwa Judum in this volume, for example, shows how Salwa Judum, a so-called people's movement launched by the government of Chhattisgarh to counter Maoist presence in certain districts of the state, is promoted by the state government as a ‘peace mission’. However, as the more accurate translation of Salwa Judum as ‘purification hunt’ portends, it has been responsible for a huge amount of violence in the region, which includes killing of civilians, burning and looting their houses, and raping women, thereby, spawning more retaliatory killings by Maoists.
It is interesting how again, as Randhir Singh puts it, a ‘law-based state’ in which there exists an elaborate procedural and institutional ensemble to deal with non-state violence, unleashes violence on its own citizens with impunity, without a corresponding mechanism for controlling ‘state lawlessness’. Again, violence whether based on caste, gender or religion, is perpetrated with the active support of the state (through its own laws) or through its tacit complicity and collusion. Moreover, the manner in which laws like the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA), the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act (TADA) and the Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA) have been used by the state in India to buttress the nation's territory against its own people in one case, or against the ‘enemy within’ in the other, marking out entire communities as suspects. The impact such laws have on the lives of people, and legal and political institutions, may be [Page xvi]called, following Hillyard (1993), the violence of jurisprudence. Rather than being the antitheses of violence and the guarantors of ‘peaceful’ social and political relations, laws are capable of deploying ‘awesome’ physical force. Any effort towards building ‘enduring peace’, must necessarily examine, with all seriousness, the ‘effects of legal force’ (ibid.: 263) unraveling in the process the legitimising discourses of ‘national security’, ‘territorial integrity’, ‘democracy’ and ‘justice’ that shroud it.
It may be important, therefore, to examine how far human rights instruments are able to reflect the sufferings that people experience in their lives routinely as a result of rampant poverty or on account of their caste, race, gender, ethnicity or nationality. Moreover, for peace to realise itself truly as a maximal concept, as Ranabir Samaddar puts it, it has to step out of a minimalist definition that associates it with the master idea of ‘security’—an idea which has historically provided the western countries with the ‘democratic capacity’ to wage colonial wars and commit genocide (Samaddar 2004: 14). Looking for pathways to peace which steer clear of the ‘vigorous way to peace’ makes it merely an ancillary of war (ibid.: 13). The chapters in this volume show how peace is ultimately concerned with issues of equality, dignity and recognition of equal worth; that it is a condition of freedom from coercion, want and deprivation; and that this state of freedom may be achieved through a process of liberation, which is not only a political consciousness but also the edifice on which a democratic society may be built.
In this context, specific institutions in charge of protecting people's rights, for example—the courts which have the constitutional mandate to preserve fundamental rights of the people, enhance the repository of rights and be vigilant against their violation by the legislatures—or the National Human Rights Commissions (NHRCs), which have the power to investigate cases of violation, have been intermittently ambivalent and inconsistent at times and inadequately effective at others. However, at other times there have been sparks of energy and vigour that have promised to plug the democratic deficit set off by the crisis in political institutions. Irrespective of such vacillations, the democratic rights movement continues to meander through the vexed dilemmas and anxieties over its ‘anti-state predispositions’ and the compulsion to continually negotiate between state/society/law/rights.
[Page xvii]In the contemporary context, however, where new threats to human rights have unleashed in the form of the state acting as surrogate for global corporate bodies, the task of creating communities of resistance and corresponding worlds of human rights is especially complex. Yet, as the section on movements in this volume shows, the struggle for liberation consists in building an alternative society, as Ram Manohar Lohia puts it, which involves not only democratic control over government but also freedom from the fear of tyranny; or as Randhir Singh suggests, the revolutionary reclamation of the truth that is historically embodied in democratic rights. The struggle for broadening and deepening the practice of democracy in different parts of the world, are manifestations of such fearless voicing and rallying around the democratic truth, the realisation of the self and the actualisation of liberation consciousness.[Page xviii]
Consolidated Bibliography[Page 317]2002. Women and Politics of Violence. New Delhi: Shakti Books..2004. Terrorism Law: The Rule of Law and the War on Terror. Tucson, Arizona: Lawyers and Judges Publishing..2004. Women and Law in India: An Omnibus. New Delhi: Oxford University Press., and .2004. Beyond Lines of Control: Performance and Politics on the Disputed Borders of Ladakh, India. Durham: Duke University Press..Agrawal, Girish and ColinGonsalves (eds). 2005. Dalits and the Law. New Delhi: Human Rights Law Network.2001. The Challenge of Confidence Building Measures in South Asia. New Delhi: Har-Anand..1998. Ethnicity and Politics in Pakistan. Karachi: Oxford University Press..2000. Forlorn Migrants: An International Legal Regime for Undocumented Migrant Workers. Dhaka: The University Press..2002. Policing in India in the New Millennium. Mumbai: Allied Publishers..1995. ‘Women's Rights and Human Rights in Tribal Areas: A Case Study of the Provincially Administered Tribal Areas in Pakistan’, in Nighat SaidKhan, RubinaSaigol and Afiya ShehrbanoZia (eds), Aspects of Women and Development. Lahore: ASR Publications..2002. ‘Manipur’, Gazetteer of Naga Hills and Manipur. New Delhi: Mittal Publications..1998. Nationalism without a Nation in India. Delhi: Oxford University Press.1989. Writing and Speeches of Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar, Vol 1. Mumbai: Government of Maharashtra Publication..1990. Writing and Speeches of Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar, Vol 3. Mumbai: Government of Maharashtra Publication..Amnesty International. 1987. Nepal: A Pattern of Human Rights Violations. London: Amnesty International.Amnesty International. 1999. India: A Vital Opportunity to End Impunity in Punjab. Index Number ASA 20/024/99. Available online at http://www.amnesty.org/en/library.Amnesty International. 2002. Sri Lanka: Rape in Custody. Index Number ASA 37/001/2002. London: Amnesty International.1980. Conflict in Nagaland: A Study of Insurgency and Counter Insurgency. New Delhi: Chanakya Publications.Anderson, Michael R. and SumitGuha (eds). 1998. Changing Concepts of Rights and Justice in South Asia. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.[Page 318]Andhra Pradesh Civil Liberties Committee. Undated. Paura Hakkula Avagahana Charcha Patralu. Hyderabad: APCLC.Andhra Pradesh Civil Liberties Committee. 1985. ‘The State vs Civil Liberties Organisations: The Case of APCLC’, Lokayan Bulletin, 3(3): 77–80.Asian Human Rights Commission. 2001. Monitoring the Right for Effective Remedy for Human Rights Violations. Hong Kong: Asian Human Rights Commission.Assam Tribune. 2004. ‘Violence against Women on the Rise’, Assam Tribune, Guwahati, 10 December.Association for the Protection of Democratic Rights. 1986. Civil Rights: Past and Present. Calcutta: Association for the Protection of Democratic Rights.Association for the Protection of Democratic Rights. 1991. Two Decades of APDR & Human Rights. Calcutta: APDR.2001. The Nation's Tortured Body: Violence, Representation and the Formation of a Sikh Diaspora. Durham: Duke University Press..1994. Human Rights in Developing Countries. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publication.1986. South Asia in Transition: Conflict and Tensions. New Delhi: Patriot Publishers..1987. ‘Our Democratic Future’, Lokayan Bulletin, 5(4–5): 37–44.1995. ‘Democracy and the Fight against Communalism’, Economic and Political Weekly, 31(1): 57–60.‘Human Rights Movement in Andhra Pradesh: A Theoretical Reflection’, in AjayGudavarthy and G.Vijay (eds), Understanding Contemporary Andhra Pradesh.Forthcoming.1987. ‘Tuning Our Ears to Discord: Response of the Democratic Rights Movement to the Question of Violence’, Lokayan Bulletin, 5(4–5): 45–53..1996. Mridula Sarabhai: Rebel with a Cause. Delhi: Oxford University Press..2001. She Comes to Take Her Rights: Indian Women, Property, and Propriety. New Delhi: Kali for Women..2001. Hindu Women and Marriage Law: From Sacrament to Contract. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 1994. Inhuman Wrongs and Human Rights: Unconventional Essays. New Delhi: Har-Anand.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 1997. ‘What is Wrong with Sycophancy?’, in BhikhuParekh and UpendraBaxi (eds), Political Discourse. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 1998. ‘The State and Human Rights Movements in India’, in ManoranjanMohanty, Partha NathMukherji and OlleTornquist (eds), People's Rights. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 2002. The Future of Human Rights. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 2003. The (Malimath) Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System: Premises, Politics and Implications for Human Rights. New Delhi: Amnesty International India.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 2004. The Future of Human Rights. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Baxi, Upendra (ed.). 2007. Human Rights in a Posthuman World. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.[Page 319]Baxi, Upendra and BikhuParekh (eds.). 1995. Justice as Emancipation: The Legacy of Baba Saheb Ambedkar. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Bhargava, Gopal (ed.). 2001. Human Rights: Concern of the Future. New Delhi: Kalpaz Publications.1994. Against All Odds. New Delhi: ISIS and Kali for Women., and .2003. ‘State Terrorism vs. Jihad in Kashmir’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 33 (May): 215–24. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00472330380000131.1996. Insurgent Crossfire: North East India. New Delhi: Lancer Publishers..1949. ‘The Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX’. Available online at http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/debates/vol9p27a.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007)..2003. Kashmir: Roots of Conflict, Path to Peace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press..2003. Human Rights in Development, Year Book 2001: Redressing Past Wrongs. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publication.and .2002. ‘The role of Manipuri Women in Conflict’. Courtesy Imphal Free Press. Available online at http://manipuronline.com/Features/April2002/womeninconflict26_2.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007)..2000. ‘The Strong State and the Fear of Disorder’, in Francine R.Frankel, ZoyaHasan, Rajeev Bhargava and BalveerArora (eds), Transforming India: Social and Political Dynamics of Democracy, pp. 60–88. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.1999. Pakistan: Fifty Years of Nationhood. Bolder: Westview Press..1997. The Other Side of Silence. New Delhi: Penguin..Butalia, Urvashi. (ed.). 2002. Speaking Peace: Women's Voices from Kashmir. London: Zed Books.1987. ‘Nation Building in Multi Ethnic Setting: The Sri Lankan Case’, Asian Affairs, 14(Spring): 1–19.2001. ‘Adaptive States: The Proliferation of National Human Rights Institutions,’ Working Paper, Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, Harvard University, USA..1987. ‘The Human Rights Crisis in Sri Lanka: Its Background and Possible Solutions’, Denver Journal of International Law and Policy, 15(Winter/Spring): 355–77., and .Centre for Development and Human Rights. 2004. The Right to Development: A Primer. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Centre for Policy Studies. 2003. Ethnic Violence and Justice: The Debate over Responsibility and Accountability. Intervention by Centre for Policy Studies, Open Society Institute, New York. New York: Centre for Policy Studies.1988. ‘Whatever Happened to the Vedic Dasi: Orientalism, Nationalism and a Script for the Past’, in KumkumSangari and SudeshVaid (eds), Recasting Women: Essays on Colonial India, pp. 27–87. Delhi: Kali for Women..2002. ‘Kashmir Diary: Seven Days in an Armed Paradise,’ in UrvashiButalia (ed.), Speaking Peace: Women's Voices from Kashmir. Delhi: Kali for Women.. [Page 320]2007. ‘The Burdens of Nationalism’, in Neloufer deMel and SelvyThiruchandran (eds), At the Cutting Edge: Essays in Honour of Kumari Jayawardena. New Delhi: Women Unlimited..1949. ‘The Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX’. Available online at http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/debates/vol9p27a.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007)..2001. ‘The ‘Civil’ and the ‘Political’ in Civil Society’, Democratisation, 8(2): 1–24. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/714000194.2003. Conceits of Civil Society. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..2003. In the Name of Democracy. New Delhi: Penguin..2003. Untouchability and the Law. New Delhi: Commonwealth.and .2003. Human Security in South Asia: Energy, Gender, Migration and Globalization. Oxford: Berghahn Books.and .1993. Nation and its Fragments. Delhi: Oxford University Press..1994. ‘Development Planning and the Indian State’, in Terence J.Byres (ed.), The State and Development Planning in India. Delhi: Oxford University Press..2004. The Politics of the Governed: Reflections of Popular Politics in Most of the World. New Delhi: Permanent Black..Chaturvedi, Archna (eds). 2004. Muslim Women and Law. New Delhi: Commonwealth.2002. Militarism and Women in South Asia. New Delhi: Kali for Women.ChimniB.S. (ed.). 2000. International Refugee Law: A Reader. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Coalition of Human Rights Organization. 1984. Human Rights Activism in Asia: Some Perspectives, Problems and Approaches. New York: Coalition of Human Rights Organization, Council on International and Public Affairs.Committee of Concerned Citizens (CCC). 1998. In Search of Democratic Space. Hyderabad: CCC.Committee of Concerned Citizens (CCC). 2006. Negotiating Peace: Peace Talks Between Government of Andhra Pradesh and Naxalite Parties. Hyderabad: Committee of Concerned Citizens.Committee on Initiative on Kashmir. 1990. Kashmir Imprisoned. New Delhi: Committee on Initiative on Kashmir.Committee for the Protection of Democratic Rights (CPDR). 1991. ‘The Civil Liberties Movement: A Perspective’, in A. R.Desai (ed.), Violation of Democratic Rights in India, Vol. 3. Bombay: Sangam Books.Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women. 2002. Sri Lanka: Concluding Observations. 26th Session, document number CEDAW/C/2002/I/CRP.3/Add.5. New York: Division for the Advancement of Women, United Nations.1994. Preliminary Report of the Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, E/CN.4/1995/42. New York: United Nations Economic and Social Council..2001. ‘Sardar Sarovar Judgement and Human Rights’, Economic and Political Weekly, 36(18): 1503–04..2006. Terrorism and Militancy in South Asia. New Delhi: M. D. Publication.. [Page 321]1990. Mirrors of Violence: Communities, Riots and Survivors in South Asia. Delhi: OUP..2006. Life and Words: Violence and Descent into Ordinary. California: University of California Press..1995. Internally Displaced Persons, UN Document E/CN.4/1995/50, 2 February. New York: United Nations.Desai, A.R. (ed.). 1986. Violation of Democratic Rights in India. Mumbai: Popular Prakashan.Desai, A.R.1990. Repression and Resistance in India. Mumbai: Popular Prakashan.Desai, A.R.1991. Expanding Governmental Lawlessness and Organised Struggle. New Delhi: Popular Prakashan.1994. State and Repressive Culture: A Case Study of Gujarat. New Delhi: Popular Prakashan.and .1987. Sri Lanka: A History. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House.,1988. ‘Action Groups and Social Transformation in India’, Lokayan Bulletin, 6 (May): 37–59.2000. ‘Governance, Policing and Human Rights’, Indian Journal of Public Administration, 46(2): 199–218.2004. War or Peace in Sri Lanka. Mumbai: Popular Prakashan.1998. ‘From Subject to Citizens: Towards a History of the Indian Civil Rights Movement’, in M. R.Anderson and SumitGuha (eds), Changing Concept of Rights and Justice in South Asia. Delhi: Oxford University Press..1978. ‘Political Judges and the Rule of Law’, 64 Proceedings of the British Academy, 259(262)..1996. Anti Dühning. Available online at http://www.marx.org/archive/marx/works/download/Engels_anti_duhning.pdf (downloaded on 22.10.2008)..2003. The Gujarat Carnage. New Delhi: Orient Longman..2001. The Politics of Human Rights: A Global Perspective. London: Pluto Press..2000. Human Rights Horizons: The Pursuit of Justice in a Globalizing World. New York: Routledge..2007. The Concise Guide to Global Human Rights. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..1996. ‘The Paradox of Civil Society’, Journal of Democracy, 7(3, July): 38–52. http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/jod.1996.0048and .2000. Rights Beyond Borders: The Global Community and the Struggle Over Human Rights in China. Oxford: Oxford University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/0198297769.001.0001.1988. ‘The Political Technologies of Individuals’, in Technologies of the Self, L. H.Martin, H.Gutman and P. H.Hutton (eds). Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press..2005. ‘Civil Society and Citizenship in Western Democracies: Historical Developments and Recent Challenges’, in RajeevBhargava and HelmutReifeld (eds), Civil Society, Public Sphere and Citizenship, pp. 59–83. New Delhi: Sage Publications..1972. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Middlesex: Penguin Books.. [Page 322]1984. Competing Equalities: Law and Backward Classes in India. Berkeley: University of California Press..2002. Resistance and the State: Nepalese Experiences. New Delhi: Social Science Press.1990. Discourses of Extremity. London: Verso..1994. ‘Democracy and the Ends of Marxism’, New Left Review, 203 (January-February)..1980. Echoes from North Eastern India. New Delhi: S. Chand.and .2005. ‘Civil Society and the Limits of Identity Politics’, in N.Jayaram (ed.), On Civil Society. London: Sage Publications..2002. From the Depth of Silence: Voice of Women Survivors of War. Quezon City: Asian Centre for Women's Human Rights (ASCENT)..Goonesekere, Savitri (ed.). 2004. Violence, Law and Women's Rights in South Asia. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Gopalan, S. (ed.). 1998. India and Human Rights. New Delhi: Lok Sabha Secretariat.2006. Law in Time of Crisis, Emergency Powers in Theory and Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511493997and .1996. ‘Marxism, Authoritarianism and People's Movements’, Economic and Political Weekly, 31(13): 847–49..2005. ‘Dalit and Naxalite Movements in Andhra Pradesh: Solidarity or Hegemony?’, Economic and Political Weekly, 40(51): 5410–18..2004. ‘Andhra Pradesh: Some Contemporary Trends’, Economic and Political Weekly, 39(16): 1571–74.and .2007. ‘Antinomies of Political Society: Implications of Uncivil Development. Economic and Political Weekly, 42(29): 3051–59.and .2004. ‘Civil Society or the State: What Happened to Citizenship?’, in C.M.Elliot (ed.), Civil Society and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press..1986. ‘Party Politics in Parliamentary Reserved Constituency’. PhD dissertation, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi..1997. ‘Human Rights and Dalits: An Inquiry into the Human Rights Discourse in India’, Indian Journal of Human Rights, January-June..1986. ‘Human Rights: The Indian Law’, Indian Journal of International Law, 26(1, 2): 53–71.2004. ‘Tried by the Media: The SAR Geelani Trial’, in Sarai Reader, 04: Crisis/Media. New Delhi: Sarai..2007. Framing Geelani, Hanging Afzal. New Delhi: Promilla and Co..2000. ‘Women Across Borders in Kashmir: The Continuum of Violence’, Canadian Women Studies, 19(4, Winter): 77–87..2001. Internally Displaced Women from Kashmir: The Role of UNHCR. Dhaka: South Asia Refugee Watch..1993. ‘The Koyyur Kidnap: Question of Human Rights’, Economic and Political weekly, 28(49): 2650–55.1998. Political Economy of Human Rights: Emerging Dimensions. Mumbai: Himalayan Publishing House.2002. ‘Rights of Dalits: Law and Reality’, Journal of the National Human Rights Commission. 133–59.[Page 323]1998. ‘Civil Liberties Movement and the State in India’, in ManoranjanMohanty, Partha NathMukherji and OlleTornquist (eds), People's Rights. New Delhi: Sage Publications.and .1981. ‘The Role of Women as Agents of Change and Development in Pakistan’, Human Rights Quarterly, 3(3, Summer): 68–75. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/761896.2005. India's Living Constitution: Ideas, Practices, Controversies. London: Anthem Press., and .1993. Suspect Community: People's Experience of Terrorism Acts in Britain. London: Pluto Press..1981. ‘Bangladeshi Women and Development’, Human Rights Quarterly, 3(3, Summer): 76–82. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/761897.Human Rights Forum. 2000. Untitled Pamphlet. Hyderabad: Human Rights Forum.Human Rights Watch. 1999. Kashmir Conflict: Abuses by Indian Security Forces and Militant Groups Continue. New York: Human Rights Watch.1989. Personal Liberty and Preventive Detention. Peshawar: University Foundation Press..2004. ‘Nationalities, Ethnic Processes and Violence in India's North-East’ in RanabirSamaddar (ed.), Peace Studies: An Introduction to the Concept, Scope and Themes, pp. 292–317. New Delhi: Sage Publications..Hussain, Neelam, SamiyaMumtaz and RubinaSaigol (eds). 1997. Engendering the Nation-State. Lahore: Simorgh Women's Resource and Publication Centre.1985. Democracy in Peril: Sri Lanka: A Country in Crisis. Sydney: LAWASIA, Human Rights Committee..Indian Express. 2005. ‘On Godhra, Gujarat Rejects POTA Review Panel Report’, Indian Express, New Delhi, 10 June.Indian Express. 2006. Indian Express, Bangalore, 14 January.Indian Social Institute. 2001. State of Human Rights in India, 2000. New Delhi: Indian Social Institute.Integrated Regional Information Network. 2007. The Shame of War: Sexual Violence against Women and Girls in Conflict. New York: Integrated Regional Information Network/United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.International Colloquy on the Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement (ICGPID). 2000. Report of ICGPID. Brookings-Bern Project on Internal Displacement. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.International Initiative for Justice. 2003. Threatened Existence: A Feminist Analysis of the Genocide in Gujarat. Mumbai: International Initiative for Justice.International Peace Research Institute Oslo. 1986. Prospects for Peace in Sri Lanka. International Alert. Oslo: International Peace Research Institute Oslo (PRIO).International Works Group for Indigenous Affairs. 1986. The Naga Nation and Its Struggle against Genocide. IWGIA Document No. 56. Copenhagen: International Works Group for Indigenous Affairs (IWGIA).1998. The Moral and Political Thought of Gandhi. Delhi: Oxford University Press..1990. Human Rights and Inhuman Wrongs. New Delhi: B. R. Publishing Corporation.and . [Page 324]1988. ‘Stoning to Death in Pakistan’, Human Rights Internet Reporter, 12(2, Winter): 124–26..2003. The Crisis of Governance in Pakistan. Lahore: Sang-e-Meel Publication..1995. ‘The Private/Public Dichotomoy and Patriarchy in the Ideology of Human Rights’, in Nighat SaidKhan, RubinaSaigol and Afiya ShehrbanoZia (eds), Aspects of Women and Development. Lahore: ASR Publications..1986. Feminism and Nationalism in the Third World. London: Zed Press..1998. ‘Displaced Persons and Discourse of Rights’, Economic and Political Weekly, 33(5): 30–36..1986. What's Happening to India? Punjab, Ethnic Conflict, Mrs Gandhi's Death and Test of Federation. New York: Holmes and Meier publication..Joint Investigation Team. 2001. Grim Realities: Of Life, Death and Survival in Jammu and Kashmir. Report of the Joint Investigation Team: Andhra Pradesh Civil Liberties Committee, Human Rights Forum, Organisation for the Protection of Democratic Rights, People's Democratic Front, People's Union for Democratic Rights. New Delhi: People's Union for Democratic Rights.1998. Genocide and Gross Human Rights Violations in Comparative Perspective. New Brunswick: Translator Publishers.and .2001. ‘Violation of Human Rights by Indian Police’, World Focus, 22(1, January): 10–6, 18.Just World Trust. 1996. Human Wrongs: Reflections on Western Global Dominance and its Impact upon Human Rights. Penang: Just World Trust.1985. ‘Organizing Landless Women in Bangladesh’, Community Development Journal, 3(20): 203–11. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cdj/18.104.22.1688. ‘Subordination and Struggle: Women in Bangladesh’, New Left Review. 168(March-April): 95–121..Kabeer, Naila, Geetha B.Nambissan and RamyaSubrahmanian (eds). 2003. Child Labour and the Right to Education in South Asia: Needs Versus Rights?New Delhi: Sage Publications.1993. Civil Rights Movement in India. Ph.D. Dissertation. Surat: Centre for Social Studies..1949. ‘The Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX.’ Available online at http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/debates/vol9p3a.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007).1993. ‘Koyyuru: Reflections on a Kidnap’, Economic and Political Weekly, 28(12–13): 495–98.2004. The Wages of Impunity: Power, Justice and Human Rights. Hyderabad: Orient Longman.2002. De-Erotizing Assaults: Essays on Modesty, Honour and Power. Calcutta: Stree.and .Karki, Arjunb and DavidSeddon (eds). 2003. The People's War in Nepal: Left Perspectives. New Delhi: Adroit Publishers.[Page 325]2002. The Partition of Memory: The Afterlife of the Division of India. Bloomington: Indiana University Press..2003. The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act and Its Impact on Women in Nagaland. New Delhi: WISCOMP..Khan, Nighat Said (ed.). 2004. Up Against the State: Military Rule and Women's Resistance. Lahore: ASR Publications.1988. State Against Democracy. Delhi: Ajanta Publications..Kothari, Smitu and HarshSethi (eds). 1991. Rethinking Human Rights: Challenges for Theory and Action. Delhi: Lokayan Publications.2007. Human Rights, Justice and Constitutional Empowerment. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.and .2004. The Juvenile Justice System in India: From Welfare to Rights. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..1999. Encyclopedia of Human Rights Issues Since 1945. Westport: Green Wood Publishing Group.1936. The Struggle for Civil Liberties. Allahabad: Foreign Department, All India Congress Committee..Lokayan Bulletin. 1987. ‘The Politics of Human Rights’, Lokayan Bulletin, 5(4/5): 161.1984. Nagaland File: A Question of Human Rights. New Delhi: Lancer International.and .1985. Marxism and Morality. Oxford: Oxford University Press..2007. Women Building Peace between India and Pakistan. New Delhi: Anthem Press..2001. Identities and Rights: Aspects of Liberal Democracy in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..2004. ‘Civil Society and its Avatars: What Happened to Freedom and Democracy?’, in C. M.Elliot (ed.), Civil Society and Democracy, pp. 167–90. Oxford: Oxford University Press..1999. ‘Patriarchy and State Systems in North East India: A Historical and Critical Perspective’, in KumkumSangari and UmaChakravarti (eds), From Myths to Markets: Essays on Gender. Shimla and Delhi: Indian Institute of Advanced Studies and Manohar Publishers..1996. Fighting for Faith and Nation: Dialogues with Sikh Militants. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press..Mahmood, Tahir (ed.). 2005. Cases in the Muhammadan Law of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.1998. Development, Ethnicity and Human Rights in South Asia. New Delhi: Sage Publications..Manchanda, Rita (ed). 2001. Women, War and Peace in South Asia: Beyond Victimhood to Agency. New Delhi: Sage Publications.2002. Minority Rights Discourse in India. Shimla: Indian Institute of Advanced Studies.2003. Minorities and Religious Freedom in a Democracy. New Delhi: Manohar Publishers.[Page 326]2000. Recovering Subversion: Feminist Politics beyond the Law. New Delhi: Permanent Black..1997. Borders and Boundaries. New Delhi: Kali for Women.and .1985. Philosophy, Ideology and Social Science. New York: Prentice-Hall..Mohanty, Manoranjan, Partha NathMukherji and OlleTornquist (eds). 1998. People's Rights: Social Movements and the State in the Third World. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Mohanty, Manoranjan (ed.). 2004. Class, Caste, Gender. New Delhi: Sage Publications.2007. Grassroots Democracy in India and China: The Right to Participate. New Delhi: Sage Publications., and .2002. The Law of Internal Armed Conflict. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO97805114951681999. From Patriarchy to Gender Equity: Family Law and Its Impact on Women in Bangladesh. Dhaka: The University Press..Mumtaz, Khawar and FareedaShaheed (eds). 1980. Women of Pakistan: Two Steps Forward, One Step Backward. London: Zed Press.1988. ‘The Politics of Secularism and Recovery of Religious Tolerance’, Alternative, 13(2 April): 177–94..2006. India's Legal System: Can It be Saved?New Delhi: Penguin.2001. ‘Where the NHRC has Failed in India’, World Focus, 22(1, January): 17–18..1999. ‘Rule of Law and Organised Crime: Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Bill’, Economic and Political Weekly, 34 (18).2001. ‘Audit of Human Rights’, Economic and Political Weekly, 36(44, 3 November): 4167–69.2002. Citizen's Rights: Judges and State Accountability. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.2005. ‘Repeal of POTA and UPA's Bill’, Economic and Political Weekly, 40(1, 7 January): 11.North East Sun. 1996. ‘Dharna against Draconian Law’, North East Sun, 2(8, 15–30 November): 17.1980. We Will Smash This Prison: Indian Women in Struggle. London: Zed Press..Organisation for the Protection of Democratic Rights (OPDR). 2003. Rights on Gallows and Repression on People: A Compilation of Fact-Finding Reports. Vijaywada: OPDR.2001. ‘NHRC and Human Rights Activists’, Mainstream, 39(43): 12–23.2001. ‘Caste, Race and Human Rights’, Economic and Political Weekly, 36(35): 3344–45.1995. ‘Jawaharlal Nehru and the Crisis of Modernisation’, in UpendraBaxi and BikhuParekh (eds), Crisis and Change in Contemporary India, pp. 21–56. Delhi: Sage Publications.. [Page 327]1981. ‘ILO and India In Pursuit of Human Rights through Labour Standards’, Journal of Indian Law Institute, 23(4): 555–77.1985. ‘Women's Liberation in India’, New Left Review, 153 (September/October): 75–86..2003. Human Rights Developments in South Asia. New Delhi: Authors Press.1995. ‘Burden of Marx and Morals’, Economic and Political Weekly, 31(20): 1202–04.2000. Protection of Human Rights. New Delhi: Commonwealth.People's Union for Democratic Rights. 2002. Quit India: Ban, Deportation and Rights of Nepali People. New Delhi: People's Union for Democratic Rights.People's Union for Democratic Rights. 2006. Casting the Net Wider! The Chhattisgarh Special Public Security Act 2006. New Delhi: People's Union for Democratic Rights.1987. Pakistan: Human Rights after Martial Law. Geneva: International Commission of Jurists., , and .1993. Insurgency Movement in Northeastern India. New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House..2005. Politics and Internal Security. Mumbai: Popular Prakashan..1949. ‘The Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX’. Available online at http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/debates/vol9p27a.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007)..2001. ‘Sovereignty, Territorial Integrity and Right of Self-determination’, Economic and Political Weekly, 36(4): 263–64..2001. ‘Human Rights Debate’, Frontline, 18(19, 28 September): 116–17.2001. ‘Role and Construction of National Human Rights Commissions in Promoting National and International Human Rights Norms in the National Context’, Indian Journal of Public Administration, 47(2, April–June): 222–36.1986. ‘Civil Rights Situation in India’, in A.R.Desai (ed.), Violation of Democratic Rights in India, Vol. 3. Bombay: Sangam Books..1991. Impressions of the Recent Visit to the Kashmir Valley From the 6th of April to the 14th of April, 18th April.and .1993. ‘Democratic Movements and Dialectics’, Economic and Political Weekly, 18(32): 1469–71.2001. Human Rights, Democratic Rights and Popular Protest. Calcutta: Progressive Publishers..Raza, Rafi (ed.). 1997. Pakistan in Perspective 1947–1997. Karachi: Oxford University Press.2000. The Weakness in Internal Protection of Minority Rights. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publication..2004. Human Rights: Concepts and Issues. New Delhi: Commonwealth..2003. Social Work and Human Rights: A Foundation for Policy and Practice. Jaipur and New Delhi: Rawat Publication..1987. Cycles of Violence: Human Rights in Sri Lanka Since the Indo-Sri Lanka Agreement. Washington, D.C.: Asia Watch.[Page 328]1997. Conflict and Displacement in Sri Lanka. Washington DC: US Committee for Refugees.and .1985. Ethnic Violence, Human Rights and Early Warnings, PRIO Papers, 5/86. Oslo: International Peace Research Institute..2004. Human Rights: Perspectives and Challenges. New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House..2001. ‘Human Rights and Wrongs’, World Focus, 22(1, January): 3–6.Samaddar, Ranabir (ed.). 2004. Peace Studies: An Introduction to the Concept, Scope and Themes, pp. 292–317. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Samaddar, Ranabir (ed.). 2005. Politics of Autonomy. New Delhi: Sage Publications.2001. ‘Why Women Reject Nuclearisation’, in SmituKothari and ZiaMian (eds), Out of the Nuclear Shadow. New Delhi: Rainbow., , and .2004. ‘New Patriotisms: Beauty and the Bomb,’ in RadaIvekovic and JulieMostov, From Gender to Nation. New Delhi: Zubaan..1983. ‘Status of Women and Law as an Instrument of Social Change’, Journal of Indian Law Institute, 25: 262–69..2001. Hindu Wife, Hindu Nation. Delhi: Permanent Black..2002. ‘Semiotics of Terror: Muslim Children and Women in Hindu Rashtra’, Economic and Political Weekly, 37(28): 2872–76..2003. ‘Sexual Violence and Armed Conflict’, The People's Review, pp. 24–30, Kathmandu, 24 July..1983. Sri Lanka: National Conflict and the Tamil Liberation Struggle. London: Zed Books..1986. ‘Legal Status of Refugees: Indian Position’, Indian Journal of International Law, 26(2–3, July-December): 501–15.1986. Kant, Respect and Injustice. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.2001. Development as Freedom. London: Oxford University Press..2001. ‘Right to Development as a Human Right’, Economic and Political Weekly, 36(27, 7 July): 2527–36..‘Media Trials and Courtroom Tribulations: A Battle of Images, Words, Shadows’.Unpublished.2001. Shari'a Law and Society: Tradition and Change in South Asia. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..1975. India in Crisis. Delhi: Vikas.Shah, Ghanshyam (ed.). 2001. Cultural Subordination and the Dalit Challenge: Dalit Identity and Politics. New Delhi: Sage Publications.Shah, Ghanshyam (ed.). 2002. Social Movements and the State. New Delhi: Sage Publications.2004. ‘Counsel Picks Holes in Rifles Defence’, Hindustan Times, Kolkata, 5 November..Sharma, Mool Chand and RajuRamachandran (eds). 2005. Constitutionalism, Human Rights and the Rule of Law: Essays in Honour of Soli J. Sorabjee. New Delhi: Universal Law Publishing Company.[Page 329]1984. Ordinary Vices. Harvard: The Beknap Press..2005. Let Freedom Ring: Story of Naga Nationalism. New Delhi and Chicago: Promila and Co. and Bibliophile South Asia..2007. The Impact of Armed Conflict on Women in South Asia. New Delhi: Manohar..2002. Debates, Joint Sitting of the Houses of Parliament, p. 105, Lok Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi, 26 March..1983. ‘The Prevention of Terrorism Act’, Journal of Law and Society, 10(1): 75. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1410001and .2002. Colonialism to Democracy: A History of Manipur, 1819–1972. Guwahati: Spectrum Publications..1990. Of Marxism and Indian Politics. Delhi: Ajanta Publications..1992. ‘Terrorism, State Terrorism and Democratic Rights’, The Administrator, XXXVII (July-September): 95..1998. Political Prisoners in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..2007. The State, Democracy and Anti-Terror Laws in India. New Delhi: Sage Publications..1982. A Special Caste? Tamil Women in Sri Lanka. London: Zed Press..South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1992. Bhutan: The Human Rights Situation on the Ethnic Conflict in Southern Bhutan. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1993. Kashmir-Human Rights Update. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1995. Armed Forces Special Powers Act: A Study in National Security and Tyranny in India. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1996. The Return of the Maoist-Midnight Knocks and Extra Judicial Killings in Nepal. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1997. Survival, Dignity and Democracy: Burmese Refugees in India. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1997. The Stateless Chakmas and Hajongs of the Indian State of Arunachal Pradesh. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1998. The Bhutanese Political Crisis and Refugee Problem. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 1999. Abandoned and Betrayed: Afghan Refugees under UNHCR Protection in New Delhi. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 2006. Introducing Human Rights: An Overview Including Issues of Gender Justice, Environment and Consumer Law. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Commission and Oxford University Press.South Asian Human Rights Documentation Centre (SAHRDC). 2007. Handbook of Human Rights and Criminal Justice in India: The System and Procedure (2nd ed.). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre. (Not Dated). Massacre in Sopore in Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir. New Delhi: South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre.[Page 330]1987. In Other Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics. New York: Routledge..1989. We were Making History: Life Stories of Women in Telangana People's Struggle. Delhi: Kali for Women..2001. ‘Human Rights of the Tribal People: Basic Issue in Tripura’, Mainstream, 39(6): 23–32.1992. Individual Responsibility in International Law for Serious Human Rights Violations. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.2001. Inside Apartheid's Prison. Melbourne: Ocean Press..Symonides, Janusz (ed.). 2000. Human Rights: Concept and Standards. Aldershot: Ashgate.1986. Sri Lanka: Ethnic Fratricide and the Dismantling of Democracy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Tarabout, Giles and RanabirSamaddar (eds). 2007. Conflict, Power, and the Landscape of Constitutionalism. New Delhi: Routledge.1991. ‘In Defence of Freedom’, in A. R.Desai (ed.), Expanding Governmental Lawlesness and Organised Struggles, pp. 302–09. Bombay: Popular Prakashan.2002. Essentials of POTA and Other Human Rights Laws. New Delhi: Authors Press.The Hindu. 2003. ‘Supreme Court Frowns on Custodial Deaths.’The Hindu, New Delhi, 11 September.The Hindu. 2004. ‘Gujarat is Ready with “Alternative” if POTA is Repealed’. The Hindu, New Delhi, 2 June.The International Colloquy. 2000. The Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement. Vienna: Brookings Institution Project on Internal Displacement.The Sangai Express. 2006. Apunba Lup Scoffs at AR's gestures. Available online at http://www.peacewomen.org/news/India/Aug06/womensgroup_army.html (downloaded on 12.05.2007).The Tribune. 2002. ‘Dulina Lynching Case: 6 more Surrender’, The Tribune, Chandigarh, 3 December.The Tribune. 2006. ‘NPMHR in solidarity with Sharmila's cause’, The Sangai Express, Imphal, 14 October.1999. Human Rights, Terrorism and Policing in India. New Delhi: Indian Social Institute Publication.2000. ‘Human Rights of Ex-untouchables in India: Violations and Rights Enforcement’, Indian Journal of Human Rights, 4(1 & 2).University Teachers for Human Rights. 1996. Jaffna: The Contest between Man & The Beast Within, Special Report No. 7, pp. 16–18. Jaffna: University Teachers for Human Rights.US Committee for Refugees. 1994. People Want Peace. Washington DC: US Committee for Refugees.2004. Nationalism, Ethnic Conflict and Rationality Perspectives on Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.. [Page 331]2003. ‘For a Fair Trial’, Frontline, 16–29 August, 20(17): 6.2004. Indian Democracy: Meaning and Practices. New Delhi: Sage Publications.and .1983. Spheres of Justice. Oxford: Basil Blackwell..Ward, Jeanne (ed.). 2005. Broken Bodies, Broken Dreams: Violence against Women Exposed. Nairobi: Integrated Regional Information Network (IRIN) UNO.Welch, Claude E. Jr and Virginia A.Leary (eds). 1990. Asian Perspectives on Human Rights. Boulder: Westview Press.Welchman, Lynn and SaraHossain (eds). 2005. Honour, Crimes, Paradigms and Violence against Women. London: Zed Books.Wilson, Richard Ashby (ed.). 2005. Human Rights in the ‘War on Terror’. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.1983. Towards 2000. London: Hogerth Press..Winslow, Deborah and Michael D.Woost (eds). 2004. Economy Culture and Civil War in Sri Lanka. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.WIRE Collective. 1985. Women of India: Lives in Jeopardy. New York: Women's International Resource Exchange (WIRE).Women Living Under Muslim Laws. 2003. Knowing Our Rights: Women, Family, Laws and Customs in the Muslim World. New Delhi: Zubaan.Women's Initiative. 1994. Women's Testimonies from Kashmir: The Green of the Valley is Khaki. New Delhi: Women's Initiative.Wordsmiths Publications. 2003. Pakistan: The Rot Deepens. The Wordsmiths Companion. New Delhi: Wordsmiths Publications.2007. Global Challenges: War, Self-Determination and Responsibility for Justice. Cambridge: Polity..1949. ‘The Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. IX’. Available online at http://parliamentofindia.nic.in/debates/vol9p4b.htm (downloaded on 10.05.2007).Zaidi, S. Akbar (ed.). 2003. Continuity and Change: Socio-Political and Institutional Dynamics in Pakistan. Karachi: City Press.1994. Sex Crime in the Islamic Context: Rape, Class and Gender in Pakistan. Lahore: ASR Publications..Websites and Online Resources[Page 332]
About the Editors and Contributors[Page 333]Editor
Ujjwal Kumar Singh is a Reader in the Department of Political Science, University of Delhi, Delhi. He was earlier a Fellow at the Centre for Contemporary Studies, Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, Teen Murti Bhavan, New Delhi. He obtained his Masters degree from Delhi University, and PhD from School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. He has written and published extensively on laws and institutions, electoral governance and issues concerning democratic rights. His articles have appeared in Economic and Political Weekly, Diogenes, Scienza & Politica, Ethnic Studies Report, Contemporary India and Indian Journal of Human Rights. He is the author of the books Political Prisoners in India (Oxford University Press, 1998, paperback 2001) and The State, Democracy and Anti-Terror Laws in India (Sage, 2007) and the co-editor of Towards Legal Literacy: An Introduction to the Law in India (Oxford University Press, 2008).Section Editors
Anupama Roy is a Senior Fellow at the Centre for Women's Development Studies (CWDS), New Delhi. She was Sir Ratan Tata (Post Doctoral) Fellow at the Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi, and also received the Nehru Centenary British Fellowship for research at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. A PhD from State University of New York, Binghamton, USA, she has been working and writing on the socio-historical, political, legal and juridical dimensions of citizenship in India. She is the author of the book Gendered Citizenship: Historical and Conceptual Explorations (Orient Longman, Delhi, 2005) and co-editor of Poverty, Gender and Migration (Sage, 2006). Her research articles have appeared in various journals [Page 334]including Contributions to Indian Sociology, Economic and Political Weekly, Indian Social Science Review and Contemporary India.
Bikram Jeet Batra is a Delhi-based lawyer and researcher. In 2007, he received the New India Foundation Fellowship to write a monograph on the death penalty in independent India. He was a Visiting Fellow at the Centre for Study of Law and Governance, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi; Legal Officer at Amnesty International India and Research Associate at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies, Pune. He studied law at the Universities of Pune and Warwick. His publications include Lethal Lottery: The Death Penalty in India, Amnesty International India and People's Union for Civil Liberties, 2008, ‘Public Prosecution in India: An Argument for Autonomy’ (co-authored), Aman Trust, 2005 and The (Malimath) Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System: Premises, Politics and Implications for Human Rights, Amnesty International India, 2003. He has written extensively on domestic and international human rights issues in various journals including Economic and Political Weekly, Seminar and The Book Review.
Ajay Gudavarthy is Assistant Professor, Centre for Political Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India. He has taught earlier at the National Law School of India University, Bangalore. He has published research articles in the area of theory of social movements and civil society in Economic and Political Weekly. He is currently working on ‘Human Rights Movement(s) in India: State, Civil Society and Democracy’ which is part of a larger on-going work on a book titled Beyond Civil Society: Rethinking Radical Politics in India.Contributors
Ashok Aggarwal graduated from law school in 1982 and joined the bar in Delhi, where he has been practicing as an independent lawyer focussing on issues of accountability and State impunity. He was a leading member of the committee which filed a petition in the Indian Supreme Court seeking a comprehensive enquiry into allegations of enforced disappearances in Punjab. Between 2002 and 2005 he conducted a study of the effectiveness of the writ of habeas corpus in the [Page 335]state of Jammu and Kashmir. He has been writing in these areas and among his recent works is a monograph on social justice, in which he has analysed the Indian Supreme Court's stand on the issue of affirmative action for Dalits.
Paula Banerjee is a historian and specializes in feminist interventions in issues of conflict and peace in South Asia. She has published extensively on issues of forced displacement. She has recently co-edited a book on Internal Displacement in South Asia (2005). She has also worked on diplomatic history, particularly on American foreign policy in South Asia, which was published as a book in 2004. She has also co-edited a book on the situation of girl children entitled Girls in the Twilight Zone: South and Southeast Asian Scenario. Currently, she is teaching at the Department of South and Southeast Asian Studies, University of Calcutta.
Uma Chakravarti is a feminist historian associated with the women's movement and the democratic rights movement in India. She has taught History in Miranda House, Delhi University, is on the visiting faculty at the Institute of Women's Studies Lahore, IWSL, and a Distinguished Fellow at the Centre for Women's Development Studies, Delhi. She has worked and written extensively on issues of caste, labour and gender. Among her published works are The Delhi Riots, Three Days in the Life of a Nation (co-authored with Nandita Haksar) (1997), Social Dimensions of Early Buddhism (1987), Shadow Lives: Writings on Widowhood in India (2001), Rewriting History: Life and Times of Pandita Ramabai (2000), Gendering Caste Through a Feminist Lens (2003), Indra and Other Vedic Deities (2006), and Everyday Lives, Everyday Histories, Beyond the Kings and Brahmanas of Ancient India (2006).
Mario Gomez is a human rights lawyer and a leading peace activist of Sri Lanka. He was previously a lecturer in the University of Colombo and a member of the Sri Lankan Law Commission. He has published in the areas of economic and social rights, women's rights, human rights commissions, internally displaced persons and public law. He has designed and conducted training programmes for human rights activists, judges and staff of human rights commissions.
[Page 336]Gopal Guru is Professor at the Centre for Political Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University. He has taught earlier in the University of Delhi and Pune University. His research areas lie in social and political theory and he has written and published extensively on empirical and normative concerns of Dalit, women and other marginalised groups.
Ram Narayan Kumar has been involved with human rights, democracy and peace issues in South Asia since 1975, when he was imprisoned for 19 months for his opposition to the Emergency regime in India. A founder member of the Committee for Information and Initiative on Punjab, which petitioned the Supreme Court in April 1995 for a comprehensive investigation on the matter of police abductions resulting in the secret cremations in Punjab, Kumar is the lead author of Reduced to Ashes: The Insurgency and Human Rights in Punjab. Some of his other publications are The Sikh Unrest and the Indian State: Politics, Personalities and Historical Retrospective (1997), The Sikh Struggle: Origin, Evolution and Present Phase (1991), Confronting the Hindu Sphinx (1991), Four Years of the Ceasefire Agreement be-tween the Government of India and the National Socialist Council of Nagalim: Promises and Pitfalls (2002), Critical Readings in Human Rights and Peace (2006) and Terror in Punjab: Narratives, Knowledge and Truth (2008). A former Reuters Foundation Fellow at the University of Oxford, Kumar is currently the Director of Understanding Impunity: Failures and Possibilities of Rights to Truth, Justice and Reparation, a three-year long research program under South Asia Forum for Human Rights, Hong Kong.
Manoranjan Mohanty is currently Durgabai Deshmukh Professor of Social Development at the Council for Social Development, New Delhi. He was Director of the Developing Countries Research Centre, University of Delhi from 1993 till 2004 when he retired as Professor at the Department of Political Science, University of Delhi. A founder-member of the China Study Group, he is a member of the editorial board of China Report and China Quarterly. His publications include Revolutionary Violence (1977), The Political Philosophy of Mao Tse-tung (1978), Chinese Revolution: Comparative Perspectives (ed. 1992), Why is Orissa Poor? (in Oriya, co-author, 1993), People's Rights (co-editor, 1998), [Page 337]Contemporary Indian Political Theory (2000), Class, Caste, Power (ed. 2004), Science and Security in China and India: Selected Writings of Giri Deshingkar (co-editor, 2005), Grass-roots Democracy in India and China: The Right to Participate (co-editor, 2007) and Success Trap: A Study of China's Rural Reforms in Wuxi (forthcoming).
Pamela Philipose was Senior Associate Editor, The Indian Express, and is currently Director, Women's Features Service. She has, as a journalist, written extensively on issues of social concern. She was awarded the Chameli Devi Jain Award for Outstanding Woman Journalist in 1999 and the Zee Astitva Award for Constructive Journalism in 2007. Her satirical work on Indian politics, Laugh All the Way to the Vote Bank, has been published by Penguin India.
Rubina Saigol received her MA in Developmental Psychology from Columbia University and PhD in the Sociology of Education from the University of Rochester, New York. She has written books, articles and research papers for national and international journals in both English and Urdu. Her writings include Knowledge and Identity (1995), Education: Critical Perspectives (1993), Symbolic Violence (2000) and Qaumiyat, Taleem Aur Shanakht in Urdu and several co-edited books and articles on the subjects of women's rights, feminism, the state, nationalism, terrorism and human rights. The latter include Aspects of Women and Development (1995), Engendering the Nation-state (1997), Aurat Aur Mazahmat and Insaani Huqooq ki Tehreek. She is a member of Women's Action Forum and is active in human rights and justice issues.
Ranabir Samaddar is the Director of the Calcutta Research Group and the Founder-Editor of the journal Refugee Watch. Known for his critical studies on contemporary issues of justice, human rights, nationalism, and popular democracy, some of Professor Samaddar's publications include The Materiality of Politics (2007), The Politics of Dialogue (2004), In the Time of Nationalism (2002), A Biography of the Indian Nation (2001) and The Marginal Nation: Trans-border Migration from Bangladesh to India (1999).
[Page 338]Randhir Singh, a distinguished teacher and formerly Professor of Political Theory, University of Delhi, is the author of Reason, Revolution and Political Theory (1967), Of Marxism and Indian Politics (1990), Five Lectures in the Marxist Mode (1993) and Crisis of Socialism: Notes in Defence of a Commitment (2006).