Fascinating Hindutva: Saffron Politics and Dalit Mobilisation
Publication Year: 2009
In the present Indian sociopolitical scenario, a large number of dalit castes have become the main players in the electoral arena and politically mobilizing them has become a compulsion of all political parties. The strong desire of these castes to assert their identity based on their sense of pastness is being profitably encashed by many political parties who are appropriating their heroes and recreating their histories to suit their political ideology and thereby politically mobilizing them. This is especially true in UP and Bihar where society is still divided on caste lines and the lower castes are still oppressed.
Fascinating Hindutva examines how, aided by other Hindutva forces like RSS and VHP, the strategies of BJP for mobilizing dalits rests on reinterpreting their Hindu past and ...
- Front Matter
- Back Matter
- Subject Index
- Introduction: Pastness and Politics
- Chapter 1: Saffron Imagining of the Local: A Communal Map of an Indian Village
- Chapter 2: Exploring Dalit Militia: Local Cultures and Communal Politics
- Chapter 3: Making of a Warring Hero: Hindutva Politics of Memory and Forgetting
- Chapter 4: Creating Popular Politics: Caste Histories and BJP's Electoral Discourse
- Chapter 5: Legend War: Mapping the Political Mobilisation of the Nishads
- Chapter 6: The Politics of Cultural Resources: The Mushahars of North India
- Chapter 7: Saffronisation of a Dalit Hero: The Story of Salhes of North Bihar
- Chapter 8: The Path Traversed and the Way Ahead
Copyright © Badri Narayan Tiwari, 2009
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
First published in 2009 by
SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd
B1/I-1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area
Mathura Road, New Delhi 110 044, India
SAGE Publications Inc
2455 Teller Road
Thousand Oaks, California 91320, USA
SAGE Publications Ltd
1 Oliver's Yard
55 City Road
London EC1Y 1SP, United Kingdom
SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd
33 Pekin Street
#02-01 Far East Square
Published by Vivek Mehra for SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd, typeset in 11/13 Book Antiqua by Star Compugraphics Private Limited, Delhi and printed at Chaman Enterprises, New Delhi.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Badri Narayan, 1965–
Fascinating Hindutva: saffron politics and Dalit mobilisation/Badri Narayan.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
1. Dalits—India—Political activity. 2. Dalits—India—Social conditions. 3. Bharatiya Janata Party. I. Title.
ISBN: 978-81-7829-906-8 (PB)
The SAGE Team: Elina Majumdar, Samprati Pani and Trinankur Banerjee
This book is dedicated to the radical, emancipatory forces in society engaged in the struggle for social change
A Folk Tale[Page vi]
There once lived a bird in a forest which was part of a kingdom. The name of the bird was Lalmuni Chiriya. When Lalmuni Chiriya sang, the whole kingdom sang along. When she cried, all the people cried with her. Seeing her influence on the people, a thought struck the king—why should he waste time and money constructing roads and digging wells for the people to keep them happy when he could put Lalmuni under his power and gain control over them? So he summoned the court priests, the ministers and all his courtiers, and asked them to work out how the bird that was ruling the hearts of the people could be controlled.
Unfortunately all the plans suggested by them—like laying a net, setting a trap and hiring a bird catcher—failed to bring Lalmuni under the king's control. The king was greatly perturbed. One day, when he was riding in the forest pondering over the problem, a yogi (roving saint) appeared before him. Seeing his troubled look, the yogi asked him, ‘O king, what makes you so worried?’ The king replied, ‘O Respected Swamiji, it is my intense desire to bring a bird under my control. All my politicians, soldiers and money have failed to ensnare her. What should I do?’
After thinking for some time the yogi came up with an idea. He said, ‘Listen O King, you cannot gain control over a bird in this way. I suggest that you try to arouse within her the memories of being a bird. These memories should emphasise that the forest where she lives is within the kingdom of the king and in the king's welfare lies her welfare. However, for this you will have to seek the help of other birds who will tell her stories that will make Lalmuni Chiriya believe that her entire life is connected with the king's.’
Latching on to the yogi's advice, the king created a group of storytelling birds whose job was to narrate stories to Lalmuni centred on her own past in such a way that her identity and existence both became interlaced with the king, and the king's power became her power.
But when Lalmuni Chiriya started to listen to the stories that were being narrated to her by the king's storytellers, she saw through them and the stories failed to impact her. The storytellers did not lose hope, but continued to narrate stories to her in the same form as the king had told them to do. This process is still continuing and even today the struggle between the king's storytellers and the Lalmuni birds is going on in the forests.A folktale from Shahabpur village, Uttar Pradesh
List of Figures[Page viii]
- Figure 2.1 Suhaldev's Temple in Chittora 63
- Figure 3.1 Statue of Suhaldev in Chittora 91
- Figure 3.2 Statue of Suhaldev in Lucknow 97
- Figure 4.1 Eklavya and Dronacharya 112
- Figure 5.1 Photograph of Nishadraj on the Cover of a Magazine 130
- Figure 5.2 Nishadraj Temple in Shringverpur 131
- Figure 5.3 Statue of Eklavya in Allahabad 132
- Figure 8.1 Ganeshji and Namo Buddhaye together on the Marriage Card of an Ambedkarite Buddhist Dalit Family 182
- Figure 8.2 Invitation Card for a Marriage in an Ambedkarite Buddhist Dalit Family 183
List of Abbreviations[Page ix]
BJP Bharatiya Janata Party BSP Bahujan Samaj Party MP Member of Parliament NDA National Democratic Alliance OBC Other Backward Castes RSS Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh SP Samajwadi Party UP Uttar Pradesh VHP Vishwa Hindu Parishad
A story is often narrated in villages about a trickster who could prise the gold nose stud of a newly married woman without her having the slightest inkling of what was happening. In the same way, politically motivated communal forces are silently but ingeniously working among the common people to break up the harmony existing in society. They are doing this by communalising the identity construction of different communities and positing them against other communities who are being projected as their enemies. The feeling of pride that communities have in their own identities is being slowly converted into a feeling of hatred for other communities, and their narratives of self-respect are being replaced by narratives of violence against other communities.
This book is an attempt to study the designs of one such set of communal forces operating in Indian society, that is, the Hindutva forces, who are trying their hardest to bring more and more communities under their influence, both for their political gain and for fulfilling their ideological objective of building up a unified Hindu cultural nation. Initially, these forces used Lord Rama, the hero of the popular Hindu epic Ramayana, who is revered by all upper-caste Hindus, as the symbol to draw together Hindus in all parts of the country.[Page xii]
Today, with a large number of Dalit communities, mainly confined to the rural areas, having entered the political arena, the Hindutva forces have shifted their focus and are devising strategies to bring these diverse Dalit castes, each with their own heroes and histories, under their fold.
Intellectuals in the think tanks of these forces are digging out the myths and legends of each of these Dalit castes that are popular at the local level and re-interpreting them in a Hinduised way by either projecting the heroes of these myths as brave Indian warriors who protected Hindu religion and culture from the Muslim invaders of the medieval period or portraying their heroes as reincarnations of Lord Rama so as to link the myths of these Dalit castes with the unified Hindu meta-narrative represented by Lord Rama. Hindutva workers at the grass roots are doing this by erecting communal walls, slowly but steadily, between the various castes that form the composite local culture of the villages. While the folk traditions of many of these castes have communal elements, portraying other communities including Muslims as enemies, Dalits and Muslims have been living together harmoniously in a network of mutual interdependence for the last many centuries. Today, the communal forces are using these communal elements, both for instilling among Dalits a hatred of Muslims and for linking them to a consolidated Hindu identity, and are well on their way to fragmenting the grass-roots society. There is great danger that these forces will ultimately succeed in achieving their objective like the trickster in the folk story mentioned earlier, unless they are prevented from doing so by radical, emancipatory forces aware of their evil designs.
In this book my attempt is to bring to the notice of the readers the cultural narratives of the politics of hate of the Hindutva forces at the grass-roots level that are slowly corroding the social fabric of the country. In this endeavour I was greatly facilitated by the insights of scholars like Ashish Nandy, Christophe Jaffrelot, Rajen Harshe, Gyan Pandey, Sudha Pai, Simon Charsley and Jyotirmay Sharma, who [Page xiii]helped me to understand the subtler elements of the drama being staged at the grass roots of north India. I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude to Ravi Srivastava, Bhaskar Majumder, Bishnu Mohapatra and Susan Legene who have constantly given me moral support in my adverse times. A major portion of this book was written in Cambridge University when I was there as a Smuts Fellow. My stay there enabled me to consult the libraries of Cambridge University and other libraries in London and also to interact with a number of scholars, which greatly enhanced my scholarship. I am grateful to Kathy White and to the staff of Wolfson College, Cambridge, for providing me all the infrastructure to make my stay there a smooth and pleasant one. One chapter of this book is based on an article published in the Economic & Political Weekly (EPW) and one on a chapter in the book Political Process in Uttar Pradesh: Identity, Economic Reforms and Governance, Pearson, New Delhi, edited by Sudha Pai. I would like to express my gratitude to the editor of EPW and to Sudha Pai for accepting them for publication. Lastly I would like to thank my wife, my father and my daughters for their unwavering encouragement throughout the study.[Page xiv]
Bibliography[Page 184]2002. ‘Daliton ke Devpurush’, in PrafulKumarMaun and RampratapNeeraj (eds), Raja Salhes: Sahitya aur Sanskriti, pp. 55–58. Muzaffarpur: Namita Prakashan.1996. Lineages of the Present: Political Essays. New Delhi: Tulika..1993. Phoolan ki Kajri. Mirzapur: Sansar Press..Amar Ujala. 2007. 13 September.Amar Ujala. 2004a. Allahabad, 11 March.Amar Ujala. 2004b. Allahabad, 13 March.Amar Ujala. 2004c. Allahabad, 2 April.Amar Ujala. 2004d. Lucknow, 3 April.Amar Ujala. 2004e. Allahabad, 15 April.Amar Ujala. 2004f. Allahabad, 19 April.Amar Ujala. 2004g. ‘Nishad Samaj Sab Ka Karz Utare’, Amar Ujala, Lucknow, 24 April.Amar Ujala. 2004h. Allahabad, 26 April.Amar Ujala. 2004i. Lucknow, 6 May.2004. ‘Gaon’, translated in Hindi in Bharti Kanwal'sAmbedker ki Kavitaen, translated in English as Poems of Ambedkar in BadriNarayan and A.R.Mishra (eds), Multiple Marginalities. New Delhi: Manohar.1999. ‘Historical Memory, Global Movements and Violence: Paul Gilroy and Arjun Appadurai in Conversation, Interview by V. Bell’, Theory, Culture and Society, 16 (2): 21–40.1996. Modernity at Large: Cultural Dimensions of Globalisation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.1999. Amannamra Sangathan, Shaktivardhan and Gandhi Vichar. Shimla: Bharatiya Uchcha Adhyayan Sansthan, Rashtrapati Niwas.Booklet. Farookhabad: Bharatiya Nishad-Mallah Samaj Bachao Front.. n.d. [Page 185]1994. ‘Maharashtra Ke Do Doctor Jinhone Sujhaya Samajik Nyaya Ka Marg’, Panchjanya, Samajik Nyaya Ank, 23 January..Bharat Kranti Rakshak Party. 2004. Leaflet published during Parliamentary Elections, Lucknow.1994. ‘Chalo Mann Samrasta ke Teer’, Panchjanya, Samajik Nyaya Ank, 23 January..2001. ‘Nishad Vanshiya Sankhya Bal’, Nishad Jyoti, 2 (12): 25.BJP. 2004. Vision Document 2004: Election Manifesto of the Bharatiya Janata Party.1990. The Logic of Practice. Stanford: Stanford University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511812507.0051988. The Geneology of Demons: Anti-semitism, Fascism and Myth of Ezra Pound. Evanston: Northwestern University Press.2004. The Politics of the Governed: Reflections on Popular Politics in Most of the World. New York: Columbia University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099%2805%2970225-51994. ‘Punaha Samrasta Ka Vatavaran Banana Hoga’, Panchajanya, 2 January..1997. ‘Bhartiya Sanskriti evam Sabhyata ke Vikas mein Nishadon ki Bhoomika’, Kalindi, Vol. 362, pp. 2–8..1997. Pasi Samrajya. Lucknow: Shruti Prakashan.1999. ‘Nishad Vansh ke Amar Deep’, in AvinashChowdhry (ed.), Smarika: Mahraja Nishad raj Guhya Smriti Samiti. Daraganj, Prayag..1896/1975. The Tribes and Castes of North-western Provinces of Oudh. New Delhi: Cosmos Publications.Dainik Jagran. 2004a. Allahabad, 14 March.Dainik Jagran. 2004b. Lucknow, 14 March.Dainik Jagran. 2004c. Allahabad, 29 April.Dainik Jagran. 1997. 28 February.Dainik Jagran. 1990. ‘Nishadon ke Sahayog ka Sankalp: Advani ka Rath Jal Marg se Ayodhya Pahunch Sakta Hai’, Dainik Jagran, Allahabad, 19 October.2001. ‘Crisis and Representation: Rumours and Circulation of Hate’, in Michael. S.Roth and Charles. G.Salas (eds), Disturbing Remains: Memory, History, and Crisis in Twentieth Century. Los Angeles: The Getty Research Institute.2006. ‘The Communalization and Disintegration of Urdu’, in AtherFarouqui (ed.), Custody in Redefining Urdu politics in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press..1965. Dusadh Jati, Ek Samiksha. Patna: Kanak Press..1997. ‘The Invention of Caste: Civil Society in Colonial India’, in H.L.Seneviratne (ed.), Identity, Consciousness and the Past, pp. 120–135. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.2003. Samata ki Sandesh Wahak Mahatma Phule. Lucknow: Lokhit Prakashan.. [Page 186]1884. Statiscal, Discriptive and Historical Account of the NWP of India, Vol. VIII; Part 2—Allahabad, p. 49. Compiled by C. D. Steel. Allahabad.and .1990. ‘Fascism as Political Religion’, Journal of Contemporary History, Vol. 25.1999. BJP and the Evolution of Hindu Nationalism. New Delhi: Manohar.Government of India. 2001. Census 2001, A-10 State Primary Census for Individual Scheduled Caste.Government of India. 1971. Census of India, Series I—India Monograph Part V, Pasi: A Scheduled Caste in Uttar Pradesh. New Delhi: Office of the Registrar,Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs.Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs 1961. Census of India, Vol. I, Monograph Series: Part V-B (iv) Mallah of Delhi. New Delhi: Office of the Registrar General of India, Ministry of Home Affairs.Government of Uttar Pradesh. 1903/1988. Bahraich: A Gazetteer, Vol. XLV of the District Gazetteers of United Provinces of Agra and Oudh. Lucknow: Government Press.1997. ‘Jana Sangh and Social Interests’, in SudiptaKaviraj (ed.), Politics in India, pp. 274–92. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.2005. ‘Quota Must for Dalits in Private Sector—BJP’, The Times of India, Lucknow, 20 October..2006. ‘Ritual Enactments in Hindi “Mythological” Betab's Mahabharat in Parsi Theatre’, Economic and Political Weekly, XLI (48): 4985–4991..2000. ‘Representation and Redistribution: The New Lower Caste Politics of North India’, in Francine. R.Frankel, ZoyaHasan, RajeevBhargava and BalveerArora (eds), Transforming India: Social and Political Dynamics of Democracy, pp. 146–75. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Hindustan. 2007. 13 September.Hindustan. 2004a. Allahabad, 23 April.Hindustan. 2004b. Allahabad, 25 April.Hindustan. 2004c. ‘Veer Eklavya Ke Raaste Par Chalein—Dr Gaur’, Hindustan, Lucknow, Allahabad, 28 April.Hindustan. 2001. Patna, 13 February.1994. ‘Musalman Kabhi Daliton Ka Samarthan Nahin Karenge’, Panchajanya, 23 January..1993. The Hindu Nationalist Movement and Indian Politics 1925 to the 1990s. New Delhi: Viking.2002. ‘Salhes Ka Shravani Mahotsav’, in P.Maun and R.Neeraj (eds), Raja Salhes: Sahitya aur Sanskriti. Muzaffarpur: Namita Prakashan.2004. ‘Replication or Dissent? Culture and Institutions among “Untouchable” Scheduled Castes in Karnataka’, in D.Gupta (ed.), Caste in Question: Identity or Hierarchy, Contributions to Indian Sociology Occasional Studies 12. New Delhi: Sage Publications.[Page 187]2001. ‘Amar Shaheed Himmat Rai Dheewar’, Nishad Jyoti, 2 (12): 6..1997. Hindu Samaj ka Gaurav: Pasi Veer Maharaja Suhaldev ki Shaurya Gatha. Allahabad: Samajik Samrasta Abhyan Samiti..2007. ‘Space Photos No Proof of Ram Setu: NASA’, The Hindustan Times, 14 September..Kusuma-Salhes Play. n.d. Patna.1994. ‘Samajik Manchan ki Avashyakta’, Panchjanya, 23 January..Ludden, D. (ed.). 2007. Making India Hindu: Religion, Community and the Politics of Democracy in India,Second Edition. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.Maharaja Nishadraj Guhya Smarak Samiti. 1997. Pamphlet, published on the occasion of the Nishad, Bind, Kashyap, Lodh Ekta Sammelan, 23 January 1997, Allahabad.Maharaja Suhaldev Sewa Samiti. 2003. ‘Rashtra Rakshak Veer Shiromani Maharaja Suhaldev’, Pamphlet published by Maharaja Suhaldev Sewa Samiti, Bahraich.Manav Vikas Sangrahalaya. n.d. Zindagi Nadi Kinare, a booklet based on the oral history of Nishads. Allahabad: Manav Vikas Sangrahalaya, Govind Ballabh Pant Social Science Institute.1973. RajaSalhes. Kolkata: Maithili Prakashan..1984. ‘Andhere Mein’, in Pratinidhi Kavitaen. Delhi: Rajkamal Publications..1994. ‘Musalmaani Raaj Mein Dar Ke Maare’, Panchjanya, 23 January..2001. Time Warps: The Insistent Politics of Silent and Evasive Pasts. New Delhi: Permanent Black.2007. ‘BJP's Political Strategies: Development, Caste and Electoral Discourses’, in SudhaPai (ed.), Political Process in Uttar Pradesh: Identity, Economic Reforms and Governance, pp. 136–56. New Delhi: Pearson.2006. Women Heroes and Dalit Assertion in North India: Culture, Identity and Politics. New Delhi: Sage Publications.2004. ‘Inventing Caste History: Dalit Mobilization and Nationalist Past’, Contributions to Indian Sociology, 38 (1 & 2): 193–220. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0069966704038001082001. Documenting Dissent: Contesting Fables, Contested Memories and Dalit Political Discourse. Shimla: IIAS.Myth, Memory and Politics: A Study of the Language of Mobilization of Grassroots Dalits’, unpublished project report submitted to ICSSR, New Delhi.n.d. ‘Narendra. 1985. Raja Salhes, a booklet. Motihari: Champaran News.[Page 188]1999. Tirashkar. Kanpur: Bhuddh Upasak Sangh Sahitaya Prakashan.1888. ‘The Mushera of Central and Upper India’, The Calcutta Review, 171 (January): 1–53.Nishad Kalyan Sabha. 1979. Pamphlet, published on the third annual convention, 10 and 11 November, Uttar Pradesh.1994. ‘Manusmriti Par Jati Bhed Ka Ja Raha Hai Aarop Niradhar’, Panchajanya, 23 January.Pandey, Kailash. Narayan (series ed.). 1988. Uttar Pradesh District Gazetteer. Lucknow: Government of UP, Department of District Gazetteers, UP.1997. Man ki Vyatha kaise Chhupaun, Smarika, Virangana Udadevi Pasi Shahid Diwas. Lucknow: Virangana Udadevi Smarika Sansthan..2006. ‘Path Samrasta Ka’, in RameshPatange and TarunVijay (eds), Samrasta ke Sutra. New Delhi: Samrasta Granth Prakashan.1992. Phoolan: Dasyu Sundari Athwa Swabhiman ki Prerna. Bahraich: Lakshya Sandhan..1997. The Battle of Valle Giulia: Oral History and the Art of Dialogue. Madison, Wisconsin: The University of Wisconsin Press, Wisconsin Press.2007. ‘Mayawati: Potential and Prospect, Time for a Reality Check’, The Times of India, 23 May..1983. Kirat Nadi mein Chandra Madhu. Varanasi: Vishwavidyalaya Prakashan..1982. Man Pawan Ki Nauka. Delhi: Prabhat Prakashan..1974. Nishad Bansuri. Delhi: Prabhat Prakashan..1998. Combating Communal Conflicts: Perception of Police Neutrality during Hindu-Muslim Riots in India. Allahabad: Anamika Prakashan..Chhuachhoot Ghulami ke den hai. New Delhi: Bharatiya Samajik Itihas Sansthan.n.d.Rao, V. and M.Walton (eds). 2004. Culture and Public Action. Delhi: Permanent Black. http://dx.doi.org/10.1596/0-8047-4787-3Rashtriya Nishad Sangh. 1992. Pamphlet, published on the occasion of rally held on 23 November 1992. Allahabad: Shankar Printing Press.2004. Memory, History, Forgetting. Trans. by KathleenBlamey and DavidPalleaeur. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226713465.001.0001RSS. 2004. Path Sanket, a pamphlet dated 8 April. Lucknow: RSS.Savarkar, S.S. and G.M.Joshi (eds). 1967. Historic Statements: V.D. Savarkar. Bombay: Popular Prakashan.1949. Hindutva,4th Edition. Poona: S.P. Gokhale.2002. ‘The Untouchable Present: Everyday Life of the Musahars in North Bihar’, in H.Joshi and SanjayKumar (eds), Asserting Voices: The[Page 189]Changing Culture, Identity and Livelihood of the Musahars of the Gangetic Plains, pp. 19–41. Delhi: Deshkal Publication.2005. Dr B.R. Ambedkar, Bharat-Bharati Bal Pustak Mala, p. 28. Nagpur: Shri Bharati Prakashan, Dr Hedgewar Bhawan.2003. ‘Aitihasik kal Khand ke Prishth’, Unpublished Manuscript.,1991. Purvanchal Ke Shram Lokgeet, pp. 38–39. Allahabad: Parimal Prakashan..1994. ‘Jinhone Islaam Kaboolne Se Mana Kiya, Unse Maila Dhulvaya Gaya’, Panchajanya, 23 January..2004. Local Pracharak, Chowk Bazaar, Bahraich of RSS, 25 April.1994. Hindu Samaj mein Dalit ya Asprishya Kahe Jane Wali Varg ka Nirmata Kaun. Allahabad: Samajik Samrasta Abhiyan Samiti..2004. 54 years, Hospital Road, Bahraich, 26 April.1993. ‘Visharad ji ka Sangharshmay Jiwan’ in Shivshankar lal Visharad Smarika. Kanpur: Shivshankar Lal Visharad Smarak Samiti.Sunday Times. 2007. ‘“Divine” Raje Fuels Fresh Row in BJP’, 27 May.2000. Culture ad Power: The Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.1980. Mithila ke Itihas. Patna: Maithili Prakashan..2003. ‘Sri Guruji Aur Samta Aur Samrasta’, Panchjanya, 6 April..The Times of India. 2006a. ‘Tension after Alleged Conversion’, The Times of India, Lucknow, 25 January.The Times of India. 2006b. ‘Propagating Social Harmony’, The Times of India, Lucknow, 16 October.The Times of India. 2006c. 29 November.The Times of India. 2004a. Allahabad, 3 April.The Times of India. 2004b. Lucknow, 3 April.1998. ‘Semiology of Dalit Consciousness’, The Eastern Anthropologist, 51 (2): 169–82.1997. Lokgeeton mein Krantikari Chetna. New Delhi: Publication Department, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.1999. Joothan. Delhi: Radhakrishana Prakashan..
About the Author