Exaggerated Claims: The ESRC, 50 Years On
Publication Year: 2016
What is the role of the state in distributing research money? How do ‘arm’s-length’ funding agencies relate to public policy and business? This original study looks at the main social science funding agency in the UK, which was established 50 years ago. It examines how funding decisions are related to power. The ‘critical’ and ‘policy’ aspects of successful research bids are discussed. Walker asks the tricky question, why has social science research not achieved a more salient role in state policy formation and management strategy: is the funding agency responsible? Insightful, engrossing and highly original, the book will be required reading for anyone who has written or will write a Social Science research bid and, more widely, for students of power, knowledge and culture.
- Front Matter
- Back Matter
- Subject Index
SAGE Publications Ltd
1 Oliver’s Yard
55 City Road
London EC1Y 1SP
SAGE Publications Inc.
2455 Teller Road
Thousand Oaks, California 91320
SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd
B 1/I 1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area
New Delhi 110 044
SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd
3 Church Street
#10-04 Samsung Hub
© David Walker 2016
First published 2016
Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form, or by any means, only with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction, in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers.
Library of Congress Control Number: 2015954635
British Library Cataloguing in Publication data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Editor: Chris Rojek
Editorial assistant: Delayna Spencer
Production editor: Vanessa Harwood
Marketing manager: Michael Ainsley
Cover design: Jen Crisp
Typeset by: C&M Digitals (P) Ltd, Chennai, India
Printed and bound by CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY
About The Author
This is in part a labour of autobiography, using my own cuttings from The Times Higher Education Supplement (where I was once social sciences correspondent) and contributions to New Society, The Times, Guardian and other media. I also declare an old financial interest. As holder of an SSRC Studentship I did a master’s but, along with many others at the time, then failed to complete a PhD – to the topic of which neither my supervisor nor the SSRC paid the least attention. So I added in a small way to the political pressure on the SSRC mounting from the late 1970s onwards. I can bring empathy to the SSRC’s survival as a friendless quango, having worked at the Audit Commission when its doom was pronounced by the Cameron government, albeit by a Tory minister less intellectually complex than the SSRC’s nemesis, Sir Keith Joseph.
To make amends for squandering my studentship I have over the years contributed time and enthusiasm to ESRC projects, as a serial member of advisory committees then, from 2006, a member of the Council itself. On it, I first chaired the Information Committee, then the Research Resources Board, which became the Methods and Infrastructure Committee. This is, however, in no way an official project. The ESRC has known about it, but that is all. I acknowledge the assistance of Jacky Clake, head of information, in providing material from the archive at Swindon.
[Page viii]I would like to dedicate the book to Sharon, Jane and Tessa, who demonstrate that whatever commitments a social scientist takes on, in government, organisational life and academe, she retains the capacity to hold roles and institutional settings at an analytical distance.
More a critique than celebration … 50 years of ambiguity, missed opportunities and muddling through. Walker captures the enduring tensions that have characterised ESRC – and UK social science more broadly. A ‘must read’ for all social scientists, especially those who want to influence the next 50 years.Jonathan Grant, King’s College London
David Walker offers a characteristically sharp-minded – and sharp-worded – verdict on the first half-century of the UK’s research council for the social sciences, once the SSRC now the Economic and Social Research Council. If he privileges policy research over other forms, and focuses on relationships with Whitehall (and the ‘public’) over those with universities (and social scientists themselves), that does not diminish the power of his critique. If the vigour of his analysis and ability to stimulate controversy may tend in the eyes of some to undermine his own thesis that the social sciences have been marginalised, others will see these same characteristics as proof of the social sciences’ enduring creativity – and challenge.Peter Scott, University College London
David Walker’s analysis is incisive and hard hitting. Anyone who believes in the power of social science to inform better policy making should take his criticisms seriously.Sue Duncan, Former Chief Government Social Researcher and Head of the Government Social Research Service
References[Page 109]1999. The RAE and the production of knowledge, History of the Human Sciences, 12: 116–120.1976. Britain’s Economic Problem: Too few producers. London: Macmillan.and2015. How to Run A Government So That Citizens Benefits and Taxpayers Don’t Go Crazy. London: Allen Lane.1972. A Sociological Portrait. London: Penguin.BBC Trust, 2012. Seminar on Impartiality and Economic Reporting, 6 November.1972. The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism. New York: Basic Books.2003. In The Scientific Study of Society. Boston, MA: Kluwer.BIS (Department for Business, Innovation and Skills) 2010. The Allocation of Science and Research Funding 2011/12 to 2014/15. December.BIS (Department for Business, Innovation and Skills) 2013. A Strategy for Future Retail. October.BIS (Department for Business, Innovation and Skills) 2014. The Allocation of Science and Research Funding 2015/16. May.BIS (Department for Business, Innovation and Skills) 2014b. 7th Survey of Knowledge Transfer Activities – PSREs and Research Councils. July.1987. Social science in Whitehall: two analytic perspectives in (ed.) Social Science Research and Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.2000. Influence or irrelevance: can social science improve government? ESRC lecture February. Research Intelligence, 71: 12–21.Understanding the third sector – the work of the Third Sector Research Centre 2008–2013, University of Birmingham.n.d.British Academy, 2008. Punching our weight: the humanities and social sciences in public policy making. September.British Academy, 2015. State of the nation: a review of evidence on the supply and demand of quantitative skills. June.1982. Despite the Welfare State. A report on the SSRC/DHSS programme of research into transmitted deprivation. London: Heinemann.andBSA, HaPS, ESRC. 2010. British Sociological Association, Heads and Professors of Sociology Group, ESRC International Benchmarking Review of UK Sociology.BSA. 2014. ‘ESRC Consultation’ response by British Sociological Association and Council of Heads and Professors of Sociology.1978. ‘Social science research and policy-making in Britain’ in (ed.) Social Policy Research. London: Macmillan.[Page 110] 1985. The influence of research on policy: how do they relate? Research Policy and Planning 3, 2.1987. Social Science Research and Government: Comparative Essays on Britain and the United States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.(ed.)1996. Are university departments research organisations? Bulletin de Méthodologie Sociologique, 50: 84–92.2014. ‘The London Effect’ in Britain in 2015. ESRC.2012. The Great Persuasion: Reinventing free markets since the depression. Boston, MA: Harvard.1994. Failure in British Government: Politics of the poll tax. Oxford: Oxford University Press., andCabinet Office, 2012. Open Data White Paper June, Cm 8353, par 2.67.2014. Campaign for Social Science. Annual Lecture. https://campaignforsocialscience.org.uk/news/glass-half-full-social-science-campaign-annual-lecture-hears/1981. Industrial Policy and Innovation. London: Heinemann.(ed.)CASE (Centre for the Analysis of Social Exclusion, LSE), 2015. The Coalition’s Record on the Under Fives: Policy, Spending and Outcomes, 2010–2015.* 2009. How Markets Fail. London: Penguin.1988. Joint Approaches to Social Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.et al.1972. Introduction, in , , (eds) Social Science and Government: Policies and problems. London: Tavistock.1979. Using the Social Sciences. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.1976. The development and structure of social science research in Britain, in and (eds) Demands for Social Knowledge: The role of research organizations. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.andClapham Committee Report, 1946. Provision for Social and Economic Research Cmnd 6868, HMSO.Commission on the Social Sciences, 2003. Great expectations: the social sciences in Britain, Academy of Learned Societies for the Social Sciences.CPRS, 1971. Central Policy Review Staff. A Framework for Government Research and Development, Cmnd 4814, London: HMSO.1976. Demands for Social Knowledge: The role of research organizations. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.and (eds)1975. Foreword, SSRC Newsletter, 26 February.2002. Survey research and electoral change in Britain. Centre for Research into Elections and Social Trends Working Paper 96, March.1995a. Whither Social Sciences? The 6th ESRC Annual Lecture.1995b. LSE Oxford.2015. ESRC Alpha Territory Project, LSE Seminar, Elites and urban dynamics, 22 July.2015. Hubris: Why economists failed to predict the crisis and how to avoid the next one. London: Yale University Press.1978. ‘Research for Policy’, in (ed.) Social Policy Research. London: Macmillan.[Page 111] 2001. Government policy and the direction of social science research. PhD thesis, University of Sussex, November.2015. Personal communication.1990. Interpreting Political Responsibility. Cambridge: Polity Press.2000. The Cunning of Unreason: Making sense of politics. London: HarperCollins.DWP (Department of Work and Pensions) 2003. Evaluation of the New Deal for Lone Parents, Working Age Report 146.ESRC, 1989. Urban and regional change in the 1980s. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 1990. Social Sciences Issue 7, October.ESRC, 2004a. Operating report 2003–2004. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2004b. Seven ages of man and woman. A look at life in Britain in the second Elizabethan era. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2008. The edge, Spring. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2009. Britain in 2010. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2010. Britain in 2011. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2013a. Evaluation Committee Annual Report 2012. June. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2013b. External Communications Plan 2011–2014 Annex 1. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2013c. Global summit for retail and researchers. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2013d. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2014a. Press Release, The changing face of the high street. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2014b. Delivery plan 2015–2016. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2015a. Strategic plan. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2015b. Life style study. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2015c. Annual Report and Accounts 2014–15. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/ESRC, 2015d. Society Now, Summer 2015. Issue 22. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/1978. ‘A question of numbers?’, in (ed.) Social Science Research and Government: Comparative Essays on Britain and the United States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.1980. ‘A planner’s perspective’, in and (eds) The Inner City Employment and Industry. London: Heinemann Educational Books for the CES.Evidence Briefing n.d. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/1987. ‘Pulling through: Conspiracies, counterplots and how the SSRC escaped the axe’, in (ed.) Social Science Research and Government: Comparative Essays on Britain and the United States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Fulton Report, 1968. Report of the Committee chaired by Lord Fulton: The Civil Service, Cmnd 3638.1994. The New Production of Knowledge. London: Sage.et al.2010. Society Now, Spring.1980. Social Mobility and Class Structure in Modern Britain. Oxford: Clarendon Press.[Page 112] and 1998. Childhood disadvantage and success or failure in the youth labour. Centre for Economic Performance, Discussion Paper 397.1994. Transforming Central Government. Buckingham: Open University Press.Guardian, 2010. http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2010/dec/19/coalition-government-chaos-theory-politics2011. Making Policy Better: Improving Whitehall’s core business. Institute for Government, April.and2004. A History of Sociology in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.2002. Educational Research: Policymaking and Practice. London: Sage.(ed.)2015. Times Higher Education, 5 February, p. 31.1996. Teaching as a research-based profession. The Teaching Training Agency, Annual Lecture.Some fulfilment of a lifetime’s ambition. Quoting from: Peter Townsend’s 1979 Poverty in the UK. London: Penguin.n.d.1994. Social Scientists Meet the Media. London: Routledge.and (eds)2007. Why We Hate Politics Cambridge: Polity Press.1990. Viewpoint, Social Sciences, Issue 7, October.1974. The Private Government of Public Money. Berkeley and Los Angeles: The University of California Press.and2007. The New Protective State. London: Continuum.(ed.)1965. Heyworth Committee Report of the Committee on Social Studies, Cmnd 2660.2014. Good Times, Bad Times: The welfare myth of them and us. Bristol: Policy Press.HM Treasury, 2011. The Magenta Book. Guidance for Evaluation, April.HM Treasury, 2015. A country that lives within its means. Cmnd 9112, July.1985. The Pathology of Public Policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.and2015. A Government that Worked Better and Cost Less? Oxford: Oxford University Press.and2014. When the Party’s Over: The politics of fiscal squeeze in perspective. London: British Academy., and (eds)1978. Indicators of the State of Society, in (ed.) Social Policy Research. London: Macmillan.House of Commons Library, 2015. http://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summary/CBP-7257#fullreport2011. Lionel Robbins. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Impact Case Study (REF 3b). UoA2 family and gender role change. University of Cambridge.2015. A question of economics, Society Now, Summer, Issue 22.Institute for Government, 2015. Select Committees under scrutiny, June.[Page 113] ISER n.d. a. Institute for Social and Economic Research. Taking the long view 2013–2014.ISER n.d. b. Institute for Social and Economic Research. Taking the long view 2014–2015.IUS Committee, 2009. House of Commons Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Committee Putting science and engineering at the heart of government policy 8th report2005. Conservative Governments: Morality and social change in affluent Britain 1957–64. Manchester: Manchester University Press.1988. Fifty years of economic research. National Institute Economic Review, 128: 36–59.JRF, 2014. Joseph Rowntree Foundation: Reducing Poverty in the UK: A Collection of Evidence Reviews, August.2015. What is the good company? Social Europe, 17 August. http://www.socialeurope.eu/2015/08/what-is-the-good-company/1968. Model makers and decision makers: Economist and the policy process, Public Interest, No. 12, Summer.1998. Local industrial development and dynamics: the East Anglian case. ESRC Centre for Business Research, Working Paper 96, June.2013. The Blunders of our Governments. London: Oneworld.and2000. ‘Future directions for higher education policy research’, in and (eds) The Institutional Basis of Higher Education Research. New York: Kluwer.and2015. Breadline Britain: The rise of mass poverty. London: Oneworld.and2013. Lessons from abroad. International approaches to promoting evidence-based social policy, Alliance for Useful Evidence, July.The fluctuating fortunes of the social sciences since 1945, unpublished paper submitted to Commission on the Social Sciences 2003.n.d.LGA, 2015. Local Government Association, Centre for Population Change. Local Government and the Demography of Ageing, March.1980. The Policy Making Process. New York: Prentice Hall.2013. Weathering the perfect storm? Austerity and institutional resilience in local government. Policy & Politics, 41 (4): 533–549.and2014. Regulatory Policy and Behavioural Economics. OECD Publishing. (http://www.keepeek.com/Digital-Asset-Management/oecd/governance/regulatory-policy-and-behavioural-economics_9789264207851-en#page3).1939. Knowledge for What? Princeton: Princeton University Press.2011. The research excellence framework and the ‘impact agenda’: are we creating a Frankenstein monster? Research Evaluation 20 (3), September: 247–254.1990. ’25 years of the ESRC’. Social Sciences, October, Issue 7.1968. Foreword to Research in Political Science, SSRC Review, cited in 1975 On economics and social sciences in Britain, Révue Economique, 26 (6): 1025.MRC, 2014. Maximising the value of UK population cohorts. March. London: Medical Research Council.NAO, 2013. Cross-government evaluation in government. December. National Audit Office.[Page 114] 1988. Social Science in Government. Uses and misuses. New York: Basic Books.1990. Social Sciences, Issue 7. ESRC.New Society, 1984. 1 March.2001. The Social Sciences Arrive. ESRC. http://www.esrc.ac.uk/2007. Using Evidence. Bristol: Policy Press., and2014. Father and Daughter. Patriarchy: Gender and social science. Bristol: Policy Press.2007. From Dreams to Disillusionment: Economic and social planning in 1960s Britain. London: Macmillan.2015. British Social Attitudes: 32nd Report. London: NatCen. http://www.bsa.natcen.ac.uk/and (eds)2015. The economic performance of UK cities. Centre for Economic Performance Paper, EA025.PASC, 2012. House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee Strategic thinking in government, 24th Report, HC 1625, April.PEP, 1966. Political and Economic Planning, Attitudes in British Management. London. Penguin.1976. Research settings in the social sciences: a re-examination, in and (eds) Demands for Social Knowledge: The role of research organizations. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.2003. The British Sociological Association. A sociological history. BSA Sociology Press.1982. Preface to . and Despite the Welfare State. London: Heinemann.2015. Presentation at Strategic Forum for the Social Sciences, July.2015. High performing councils: Recipe not alchemy. Public Policy Institute for Wales, July.1976. Social Science and Public Policy. London: Penguin.2009. This Time is Different: Eight centuries of financial folly. Princeton: Princeton University Press.and1973. Quoted in . and (eds) 2014. The Palgrave Handbook of Sociology in Britain. London: Palgrave. p. 402.1969. Social sciences and social problems, Social Science Information 8 (1): 101–129.2010. The Logic of Discipline: Global capitalism and the architecture of government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.1983. Tax Policy Making in the UK. London: Heinemann.and1982. Lord Rothschild’s Enquiry into the Social Science Research Council, Cmnd 8554, HMSO.Science and Technology Committee, 2012. House of Commons Science and Technology Committee. The Census and social science. Third Report of session 2012–2013, September.2013. Pauperland: Poverty and the poor in Britain. London: C. Hurst & Co.2014. How to achieve more effective services: the evidence eco system. What Works Network, Cardiff University.[Page 115] Shonfield A. 1965. Modern Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.1972a. ‘Research and public policy’, in , , (eds) Social Science and Government: Policies and problems. London: Tavistock.1972b. The Social Sciences in the Great Debate on Science Policy. Minerva X, No. 3, July.1975. SSRC Newsletter, 29, November.1981. Does government have a role?, in (ed.) Industrial Policy and Innovation. London: Heinemann.1992. War, skirmish or feint? Education against poverty 1960–1980, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 13 (4): 465–474.and1965. House of Lords debates, 18 November, vol. 270, col. 701.(Lord)SSRC, 1968. Research in Political Science. London: Heinemann.SSRC, 1971. Annual Report 1970–1971.SSRC, 1976. Social Science Research Council, Annual Report 1975–1976, p. 17.2006. Theorizing about violence. Violence Against Women, 12 (6): 543–555.2003. The Scientific Study of Society. Boston, MA: Kluwer.2010. The Chair, the city and the case for research, Society Now, Spring, Issue 6.2014. Sir Humphrey and the Professors: What does Whitehall want from academic? Manchester: University of Manchester.andThe Times, 1965, Leader column, 3 June.1985. The Aims and Outcomes of Social Policy Research. London: Croom Helm.1979. Poverty in the UK. London: Penguin.2010. The Verdict. Did Labour change Britain? London: Granta.and2015. Cameron’s Coup: How the Tories took Britain to the brink. London: Guardian Faber Publishing.and1972. Types of output mix of research organizations, in , , (eds) Social Science and Government: Policies and problems. London: Tavistock.University of Leeds, 2012. http://www.sociology.leeds.ac.uk/assets/files/research/Regulatory_Dance/ImpactReportFinalDec2012.pdf2010. Recession Britain: findings from economic and social research. Undated ESRC.1975a. A man able to keep the balance, Times Higher Education Supplement, 25 July.1975b. SSRC doubts and uncertainties 10 years on, Times Higher Education Supplement, 5 December.1975c. Times Higher Education, 4 April.2001. Times Higher</I> <I>Education. 14 December, p. 33.2002. Times Higher</I> <I>Education. 7 September, p. 25.2015. Accounting for Hodge. Public Money & Management, 35 (3): May.1996. Open the Social Sciences. Report of the Gulbenkian Commission, Stanford University Press.et al.White Paper, 1993. Realising our potential: a strategy for science, engineering and technology, Cmnd 2250.[Page 116] 1979. The Art and Craft of Policy Analysis. London. Macmillan.2015. The Metric Tide. Report of the Independent Review of the Role of Metrics in Research Assessment and Management, Hefce, July.et al.2010. Knowledge Power. London: Routledge.2002. Expanding the domain of policy-relevant scholarship in the social sciences, CASE paper 52, London School of Economics.2015. Personal communication.1968. Forecasting and the Social Sciences. London: Heinemann.(ed.)1975. SSRC Newsletter, 29, November.